The /newstuff Chronicles #423
Classic Doom - Posted by Bloodshedder
- 20 Comments
Let me guess; one of those reviewers doesn't know how to properly appreciate
a WAD that you liked this week. Want to do something about it? Instead of
complaining in the comment thread like you always do, perhaps you can make a
difference and write some better reviews than those idiots up there. The /newstuff Review Center is the
place to do so. Put that Doomworld
Forums account to constructive use, because you need one to submit reviews.
Atomic Attack -
Doom 2 - Skulltag / Zandronum - Solo Play - 12617722
Reviewed by: Doomguy 2000
This right here is a 16 level joke WAD by Uncle Cracker. It does use resources
from other people put together to make this more appealing to people like
myself. Now, this isn't for the average Doomer, just to let you know. It does
however, contain some assrape threats and swearing to warn you. Most of my
resources that the author uses come from Millennia
Invasion, which was released at the end of September. Regardless I will go
through this WAD level by level to let you know what I think of the individual
level itself, so here we go.
MAP01 - So the game basically starts off in a somewhat similar way as shown in
Doom Rampage with Doomguy returning back to the old Phobos base. Something
strange and stupid happens to the marine within the base. The level itself is
not very hard, since it's got a few cutscenes and very few monsters. You go to
the back of the staircase in order to activate it in order to escape.
MAP02 - Now this level I liked and found interesting. It's got good music for
starters and some interesting gameplay elements. It does have some death traps,
so it will require you to use your brain so you can avoid these traps and
falling off the train to your death.
MAP03 - This is very hard level that requires some strategy to beat.
MAP04 - As the title says, it's a generic 1994 map. It's not much and doesn't
require lots of skill to beat.
MAP05 - What we have here is level with mostly invisible textures, giving it the
HOM effect. It's recommended to use the automap so you don't get lost here.
MAP06 - This is a better version of Real Death
because it's 25,000 Commander Keens instead of 150,000+ of them. Very easy, as
all you have to do is use your ammo to kill them all, thus opening up the exit
to the next level. The estimated amount of time to best the level is roughly 30
minutes at least.
MAP07 - This is another interesting level that pits you against 1,001
Cacodemons. The best way to kill them all, or enough to beat the level, is to
use the Cacodemon weapon since it does major damage to so many in one shot. The
sky was introduced in Heaven, except it's the scaled down version from Millennia
MAP08 - Of course the title says "Wait for an hour without touching anything".
Well me doing something else the other night when I was waiting for 2 1/2
hours! In order to beat the level, you have to wait 6.48 million tics without
doing anything. I'm guessing close to or over a day to beat the level.
Regardless, I used the changemap command in the console to skip this one,
because waiting forever was not worth it.
MAP09 - This one is my favorite level in the entire wad because I found some
parts funny and it uses some of my resources. I also enjoyed the gameplay of
this level. The worst part, however, is trying to navigate through the invisible
maze in order to escape.
MAP10 - I didn't care too much for this level since all you mostly do is run
through the long empty hallways. I guess the hardest part could the 3 Arch-
Viles, or the final wave of monsters that blocks the exit. Personally I go with
the final wave blocking your escape.
MAP11 - Super shot level, where all you have to do is kill the red skull in
order to open up the door for your escape.
MAP12 - The object of the level is to escape before the pepper gas kills you.
MAP13 - This is another one of those tiny box levels that does require some fast
reflexes to prevent the amount of damage you lose from the crusher. The midi
fits this box level perfectly.
MAP14 - This is hands down the hardest level of the entire mapset. The main
objective is to survive in the rectangle arena for 4 minutes while dealing with
the boss eyes summoning an endless swarm of monsters. The author could have at
least put in a megasphere to make this level more playable. The best strategy is
to just keep running around dodging projectiles and demons without alerting
other monsters, otherwise it's game over. If you decide to use your weapons,
then the rest of the boss eyes will be awaken and you have to deal with more
monsters, thus making it impossible to survive for 4 minutes. I had to save
every step of the way to make sure I had a decent percent of health.
MAP15 - The second to last level takes place in the UAC base that started all of
this in the first place. The third to last screenshot shows that I survived the
last level with 22% health. Not going to spoil too much here since I want people
to find out for themselves when playing it. The last 3 screenshots will show
some stuff that is presented in the level. Afterwards you enter the hallway to
fight the final boss.
MAP16 - Not going to say who the final boss is, but I can sure tell you that
this boss is a complete joke. He's so painstakingly easy that all you need is
one weapon, so the rest of the ammo and different weapons you can pick up are
useless, since they are not needed. You can even beat the final boss from a
pistol start without much effort. So after you kill this guy, a cutscene starts
telling you how the story ends and what happens next.
Overall I enjoyed Atomic Attack (regardless of my few complaints) and would
recommend this to people who still enjoy joke WADs. For people who would prefer
serious wads or care if it has some stuff from me or Terry, it's probably best
to skip it.
Chaos 2 -
Doom 2 - GZDoom - Solo Play - 5373241 bytes -
Reviewed by: walter confalonieri
A short but really nice map for GZDoom from Mr (or Mrs/Miss?) doomaniac that
contains lots of new textures and nice GZDoom 3d sector effects here and there.
Also, we have a brand new catchy BGM for the map and even new sounds (but, dude,
that shotgun sound just sounds so cheesy) and game graphics (like STDISK image
instead of classic blue keycard / skull and "new" guns from Shadow Warrior and
Gameplay is short and straight-forward, although It gets a little disorienting
when you are in the monitor room, but the game is easily beatable with some nice
Architecture and detail is plain but well done, except the pitch black room at
the end (an exit sign or something similar that shows you where to go after you
beat the evil badass red barons [I don't known their name, sorry!] would be
nice) and some un-unpegged textures (especially that pipe that falls from the
ceiling where you find the room after the teleport in the start) are the only
problems I've seen here, but excepting this, is worth a download. Good job!
Combat Shock 2 -
Daniel "dannebubinga" Jakobsson
Doom 2 - Boom Compatible - Solo Play - 8688338 bytes
Reviewed by: mouldy
The first Combat Shock gave us 4 maps of rock hard slaughter-filled mayhem in
beautifully crafted environments. Here then is the sequel, 7 maps this time.
Needless to say this style of play will not appeal to everyone, but if you enjoy
getting your arse kicked by multitudes of angry monsters, then you are in the
right place. For those like me who like to paddle in the shallow end of the
slaughter-map genre, playing on HMP provides a more gradual difficulty curve,
though the later maps will still be tough.
Fans of the first installment need read no further, download and enjoy. But in
case you are interested, here's a brief breakdown of what to expect.
Map 1 sets the scene with overgrown temple surroundings, and the killing here is
relatively low key with lots of options for cover.
Map 2 continues the jungle temple theme but introduces a larger cast of monsters
and more room to play with them. The circular open-plan nature of this map gives
you plenty of choices for where to take the battle, and allows for a fair amount
of chaos to ensue.
Map 3 takes the action into large underground caverns. Here the action is spaced
into a series of smaller and more free-form skirmishes before facing the
familiar arena of monsters with switches to press and nowhere to hide scenario.
The final room is somewhat nasty, and gives a taste of what is to come.
Map 4 is where the monster-count ramps right up, and more casual players will
start to feel the pain. The army of monsters that greets your arrival is
surpassed only by the multitude that awaits in the final room, and the filling
of this monster sandwich is a yellow key room that almost finished me off on UV.
It's worth fighting through it to see that final battle though, and the metal
architecture is filled with complex splendour.
Map 5 – if you made it through the previous map then here is your reward: a
gargantuan and relentless ball-hammering set in a brooding metallic cathedral of
despair. This map is where the combat fatigue really begins to set in. The play
style here favours a more episodic approach, where each cavernous empty space
fills with monsters to be cleared before moving on to the next one. It felt like
a test of stamina in places, but the spaces are varied and inventive enough to
keep the fights interesting, and the colossal and detailed architecture draws
you further into the madness.
Map 6 opens with a hilariously epic battle and is a fitting finale to the wad.
Some timed platforming makes an unwelcome appearance half way through, but the
orgy of violence that follows more than makes up for it.
Map 7 is included as a bonus, and features more traditional gameplay – something
of a chill-out map to wind down with after the relentless slaughter.
I loved this collection. It didn't love me, that's for sure, but I find
something strangely pleasurable about being killed by such overwhelming forces
in such picturesque surroundings. Difficulty-wise I found it a bit more inviting
than the first Combat Shock, and despite being killed an untold number of times,
I only found a few moments truly frustrating. With its hordes of monsters and
baroque design details, it will draw inevitable comparisons with Sunder, though
I found the battles in Combat Shock 2 to be more varied and chaotic, and
subsequently more forgiving.
UNIT 731 - Jesse
Ultimate Doom - ZDoom Compatible - Solo Play - 4123879
Reviewed by: Doomguy 2000
This wad, judging from the title, looks like your ordinary generic wad. What
makes this different is the black and setting. What makes Unit 731 a joke? The
document that came with this for starters, telling people this game is intense
because it's based on real life events and viewer discretion is advised. I
don't see how a bunch of beginner super-short basics maps can be based off real
life events. Trust me, I've seen more intense than this wad. The new weapons
are a knife (which you won't need) and a machine gun (works the same way as your
stock chaingun), and enemies include a 731 guard, commando, and scientist (which
looks like a guy in a radiation suit).
The gameplay is simplistic and boring with no real challenge added to it. On
E1M4, there's no yellow key card, so you will have type idkfa, use the noclip
cheat, or give the card to yourself with the console. Another major gripe is
the zombieman and shotgun guy replacements being able to pick up anything and
make the item disappear when they walk past it. As Mr. Chris pointed out in the
discussion thread before being helled (which got me to open this up in SLADE 3
to see what was in it), this wad has a bunch of maps missing map markers, thus
making the levels themselves inaccessible. One of them is called DEMO4 which is
basically E1M9 with a different name. To top it all off, it has 19 different
DEHACKED lumps, with one of them being a marker, plus Doom IWAD material which
is isn't needed since they are already in Doom.
The ugly graphics, weak simplistic gameplay, poor map design, the unnecessary
amount of DEHACKED lumps, and other numerous things make this wad not worth the
download. Overall, I would avoid Unit 731 based on the reasons I have given
above in this review.
Doom 2 - Vanilla - Solo Play - 56875 bytes -
Reviewed by: Dragonsbrethren
Rocktober is an excellent classic style Doom 2 map that NoneeLlama made for
and Katamori's birthdays. The map is laid out around a central outside nukage
It's flat, but flows well, and you'll revisit areas multiple times. The monster
count is a bit low, but every monster is placed well, particularly the
which lurks in the outside area and can hit several different locations. This
a bit of a threat to areas that would otherwise be trivial. My only complaint
about the map comes down to its texturing: I felt too many texture themes were
used. I loved the stone, zimmer, and wood starting areas, but the base theme
midway through seems completely out of place. Definitely give this a go if you
like the stock Doom 2 maps.
Beyond Reality -
Doom 2 - ZDoom Compatible - Solo Play - 20817624 bytes
Reviewed by: BlackFish
When you first boot up this level set, the first thing you see is a headless
zombieman and a picture of the heavy weapons guy from TF2 on a wall. You then
realize that the room has more of these odd portrait pictures, and you begin to
ask yourself what you're in for. It doesn't take long to run into floating Doom
guy heads and wing crate monsters to realize that this is pretty weird.
Welcome to Beyond Reality, a series of 16 large maps that takes place in bizarre
realms. When I started playing this I gave it a new brand name for a wad,
Absurdist. The mapper's sole intention for the good first half of the 16 levels
you encounter is to mess with your head. However, while doing so, you're playing
in some nicely detailed maps with unique themes not often seen in pwads. You'll
encounter fancy gameplay mechanics like RoTT style traps, "inanimate corridors"
that don't fully activate unless hitting a switch, and following Back to the
Future-esque trails to teleport to different dimensions to complete these
levels. Each one of these levels tends to introduce something new at your face.
The level varies in theme as well, giving an episodic variety.
So does it work? Mostly yes. It's not hard to get the momentum going for most
maps, and once you do you go with the flow with Andrew Sega music (Unreal, In
Persuit of Greed). However, sometimes you'll have to use your brain a bit to get
certain puzzles done. Also, for some reason shotgunners drop a 4 shell looking
item but in reality you only get 2 (and you even get a message indicating 4).
If you want something unique from the usual tech or hell levels you normally
play, I would recommend this to you. Because I know you want to be stuck in an
island made of crates that's guarded by floating Doomguy heads and suicidal
Doomguy's Warzone All
Stars! - Doomguy 2000
N/A - ZDoom Compatible - N/A - 86288879 bytes -
Reviewed by: Obsidian
Behold, Doomguy 2000's latest offering! Doomguy's Warzone Gold Edition is in the
authors words "all about the very best monsters from the 3 generations put
together as one epic cast." What does this mean? Let's play and find out!
Dear lord, I can FEEL my brain cells dying...eargh, sorry about that. From what
I can surmise, Doomguy's Warzone Gold Edition is a random collection of monsters
and items from the previous Doomguy's Warzone wads that replace the stock
monsters and items. Apparently you can access more features if you play it in
Skulltag, but I don't think I'll survive more exposure to this. I actually feel
bad for the person who reviewed the original Doomguy's Warzone: I'm betting he
forgot how to eat solid food after playing through it. Some of the stuff was
mildly amusing (who doesn't want to kill people with a basketball?), but I'm
pretty sure that all the half-decent things were ripped from other more high-
quality wads. All in all, Doomguy's Warzone Gold Edition is a blemish on the
face of Dooming that should be forgotten, if not eradicated. Moving on...
Atrocity - Obsidian
Doom 2 - Vanilla - Solo Play - 92846 bytes -
Reviewed by: Dragonsbrethren
Corridors of Atrocity in a word: cramped. The map is a Spirit World tribute;
parts of it almost seem to have been lifted directly from the original, but the
text files says everything was recreated from scratch. I nearly gave up on it in
the second room: there are steps surrounding the walls and several pits in the
floor, which monsters raise out of as in the original map. The room is so small
that you constantly move over these height variations, which is incredibly
annoying even when you're not evading revenant rockets and hell knight snot. I'm
not sure what Obsidian was thinking with these, but it never should have made it
into a final release. Even (good) hyper detailed maps tend to have flat floors
for a reason.
Pushing on, there are tributes to the original map's throne room and rocky cave
areas, both of which are nice looking but suffer from the same problem of not
having enough room to move around in. You can never take advantage of your
agility and instead have to rely solely on being able to force enemies into
their pain state as you attack them head on. There's another area between these
two where you get to beat up on some skin panels in order to proceed, which goes
on for way too long, and which has a nasty trap with a horde of revenants at the
I really wish this map was more open; it would be a lot more enjoyable. I
thought it did some things right, but as a whole, it's just not very fun.
Monastery of the
damned - Rory Habich (Boared)
Heretic - ZDoom - Solo Play - 179974 bytes -
Reviewed by: Csonicgo
I'll be honest, I'm not a fan of Heretic at all. To me, the weapons seem puny,
the textures really bland, and the sounds really tinny, scratchy and tedious.
But this map feels like an attempt to make me forget all those things I hate so
much about Heretic. The result? I'm actually enjoying Heretic! I never thought
I'd say that.
You'll start in a small outdoor area, and go into what looks like a standard
Heretic castle. Texturing is pretty well done here. I know how limited the
Heretic texture set is, but this mapper pulls it off for the most part. Ammo is
too tight at the start, though. I should never have to use the staff, ever.
Heretic weapons feel weak already, so I shouldn't have to ration my ammo that
much. Most of us are Doom players, after all. We spray and pray, for hell's
Of course, in Heretic fashion, I immediately got lost in the start room. I have
no idea how, but I managed to do it on my first playthrough. There's some sort
of bug that will cause a roadblock not to lower, but that only happens some of
By my third playthrough, I got a tome of power from a Wizard and started
whoopin' ass. That's really satisfying! I opened up a small stairwell where I
immediately got stuck. Like, in the wall. I'm not kidding. I don't know if this
is a ZDoom quirk or what, but I noclipped and was shot across the level like a
Also, is it sacrilege to put armor in a Heretic level? I didn't find a single
piece near the start. Armor is needed in Doom games, and yet it seems I need to
solve a quest to get a shield power-up. Eh.
Apathy is setting in, things are way too dark, and the rest of the map was
pretty easy after the ton of ammo you get in the dark room. I felt like there
could be more here, but it's fun after you know the map. Give it a shot, but be
prepared to be swamped by gargoyles.
To the mapper: it's time to learn not to use blue in dark areas. It looks awful
in Heretic. Let the monsters be the challenge, not lack of resources. I know
that tight gameplay is fun, but artifacts are also part of Heretic, and you
really dropped the ball on that. Quartz flasks aren't useful when you're forced
to use them immediately after getting them. And since I know you tested with
ZDoom, you had to have encountered the bug in the stairwell. I can pull off the
game-breaking bug every time. I fixed it myself by moving the wall a little bit
in an editor.
- Henri Lehto
Doom 2 - GZDoom - Solo Play - 387095 bytes -
Reviewed by: BlackFish
A single GZDoom map for Doom 2, Lehto uses a lot of GZdoom features to make the
map look lively with good usage of 3D floors with moving and colored sectors.
For some reason though, most of the light level is the same both indoors and
out, despite that the lighting sources like torches and ceiling lights are
everywhere. That, and there's messages that pop up that tell me where to go as
if I got lost in a Hexen hub. Criticisms aside, it's a fun 10 minutes of your
time that'll let you look at fun usage of 3D sectors without the ZDoom features
getting too much in the way.
Doom 2 - Limit Removing - Solo Play - 346592 bytes
Reviewed by: BlackFish
A MAP25 replacement for Doom 2, Marbellous is what the title suggests, a map
a lot of marble textures. It makes good and creative usage of the default
textures, creating a modern feeling without having to resort to custom artwork.
It's moderately paced and easy to get around as well. The most interesting part
was the cyberdemon battle that's halfway in the map, which forces you to dance a
bit trying to get the right elevator to come down and not get blown away at the
same time. Play it if you want a nice challenge on UV.
Rust in Peace -
TheSpazztikOne / GeneralRainbowBacon (DoomHero85)
Doom 2 - ZDoom Compatible - Solo Play - 329063 bytes
Reviewed by: Csonicgo
Rust in Peace. That's a perfect name for this wad, really. I really wanted to
give this wad a chance, but this map crosses that threshold of my patience. From
the creator of 1000 Unheard Screams (1001 if you counted mine) comes this "huge"
map that piles the boring on hot and heavy.
I'm Csonig, your tour guide for this map. Get in the Jeep, kid! it's gonna be a
blast! There are no skill settings, so let's hope we make it!
Let's just get down to business, shall we? Start the map. BLAMMO! We're almost
dead! The start of the map has about a dozen hitscanners, half of which are
chaingun guys. And guess what? They're right in front of us! If I didn't move
back to grab the "hidden" chaingun, we would have already been toast. The mapper
throws in a cacodemon at the start for good measure, and stocks the room with
bullet boxes so we can use them all up at once while dodging imp fireballs.
Good luck finding any more ammo for the next 10 minutes of the map, because we
ain't gettin' shit. That's how we roll over here at RIP.WAD! Oh, look!
Have fun with the pain elemental and revenant just ahead with only 100 bullets!
And while we're hiking up these awfully-textured stairs, look down and admire
the weird floor designs that reek of Tormentor Syndrome™. Isn't it great? Don't
you love D_RUNNIN too?
Moving on, did I mention this map has 672 monsters? You wouldn't be able to
tell, because the map is completely empty for its size. There's a cave section
with nothing in it, save for a few lost souls and torches. Hey, wake up! If it
isn't long stretches of empty space and horrid texture usage (with mis-
alignments aplenty!), it's plinking off cacodemons or something equally tedious,
so get used to it!
But that's not the kicker. Oh no, we're not even finished with our tour! After
fending off cacodemons for about 5 minutes, we're rolling into a huge, empty
dirt area with some chaingun guys trying to snipe at us! But they're so high I
can't hit 'em! Step on the gas!
Whew! that was close! I think I heard a Cyberdemon and Spiderdemon as we drove
past. Don't worry, there's a supercharge in this room over here...Wait, what's
THE ENTIRE MAP IS ALIVE!!!
Save yourself! I'm getting outta here! As soon as we touched that lift, the
whole map lowered like a platform! OH NO THE DOOR IS STUCK WHAT'S HAPPEN-
P_AddActivePlat: no more plats!
RIP Csonig 1986-2012
Died while attempting to use intended source port
Center - Sergeant_Mark_IV
Doom 2 - Vanilla - Solo Play - 3587898 bytes -
Reviewed by: Obsidian
Administration Center by Sergeant_Mark_IV: if I had to sum this up in one word,
I'd say "Prodigal". The text file states that this is a "small map to test my
speedmapping skills", and I personally think the author passed with flying
colours: the map itself is a somewhat generic techbase, but look at the
decoration! The cubicles are a nice little touch, and the overall design of the
map, while a bit linear, flows well without looking too sparse or cluttered: an
excellent achievement for a speedmap. The gameplay is decently thought out, with
some tricky encounters and little traps to keep you on your guard. 2 things
stood out in this map that I thought were interesting:
1. No SSG! This may sound bad, but in reality it makes things just that much
trickier and fun – keeps you on your toes, as it were.
2. A good knowledge of gameplay. You grab the blue key – a horde of monsters
teleport into the map. You get the yellow key – nothing. I was constantly
expecting something to jump out at me when I got that key, so it caught me off
guard when nothing happened. It doesn't sound overly special, but it's always
good when a bit of randomness is integrated into a map.
The only gripe that I have with this map is that the doortracks in the bathroom
sections aren't lower unpegged, which in retrospect doesn't really matter
considering the rest of the map. To sum up, Administration Center is a competent
little map that I think is a prelude to greater things. Go Sarge!