Reaper Grimm
Register | User Profile | Member List | F.A.Q | Privacy Policy | New Blog | Search Forums | Forums Home
Doomworld Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.2.5 Doomworld Forums > Classic Doom > Doom General > /Newstuff Needs Another Revival
Pages (3): « 1 [2] 3 »  
Author
All times are GMT. The time now is 09:52. Post New Thread    Post A Reply
schwerpunk
Forum Staple


Posts: 2046
Registered: 05-12



dew said:
On topic of this thread: I haven't reviewed very many projects, but I don't really bother with setting modus operandi for myself. I just compose the text so it's (hopefully) informative and perhaps even enjoyable to read. So if I may be so bold, I recommend you to read your reviews back and think if that's really something you'd read without zoning out if it was someone else's review on a map you've never heard about. Or on a high profile megawad where one slip will bring a mob with torches and pitchforks at your doorstep.
Good advice. I'm trying to balance flavour with substance right now, but I'm definitely not going to sugar-coat my subjective impressions. No matter what, I'll be writing from my own perspective, with the addendum that hopefully I provide enough information that readers will know whether or not they'd like these wads, even if they disagree with me.

edit: grammar

Last edited by schwerpunk on 10-23-13 at 19:25

Old Post 10-23-13 18:41 #
schwerpunk is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Jayextee
Darth Jrrr


Posts: 1250
Registered: 10-00


I've claimed my third review, about to play it.

I haven't really been trying overtly to make my reviews entertaining as such, just informative. Although depending on my mood, some of my sense of humour may threaten to creep in there once or twice (kinda did with Favillesco E1, only ever so slightly)...

Old Post 10-23-13 20:33 #
Jayextee is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
LordK
Junior Member


Posts: 155
Registered: 09-02



Jayextee said:


I'd rather write and see something balanced and well-considered, but thanks for playing.


Balanced and well-considered is all well and good, but if nobody's gonna write those kinds of reviews and there's months' worth of backlog, maybe it's time to think about lowering the standards.

Old Post 10-23-13 20:56 #
LordK is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
dew
experts


Posts: 3056
Registered: 05-08


Yeah, and when we clear the backlist with banal, shitty, cookie-cutter reviews, it'll be time for the mappers to lower their standards, because they'll need to churn out maps faster to meet our new reviewing pace. Who needs quality when you can just drown in shit and feel efficient.

Old Post 10-23-13 21:44 #
dew is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Jayextee
Darth Jrrr


Posts: 1250
Registered: 10-00



LordK said:

Balanced and well-considered is all well and good, but if nobody's gonna write those kinds of reviews and there's months' worth of backlog, maybe it's time to think about lowering the standards.



I just wrote my third. So, there's at least one more than 'nobody' at it. ;)

Old Post 10-23-13 22:30 #
Jayextee is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
schwerpunk
Forum Staple


Posts: 2046
Registered: 05-12


Should we re-review wads that are just re-hosted under different names or just have their music changed, etc? Or just review the changes?

Last edited by schwerpunk on 10-24-13 at 00:06

Old Post 10-23-13 23:59 #
schwerpunk is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
BloodyAcid
Senior Member


Posts: 1281
Registered: 09-11


I haven't played Doom in months, and haven't posted in what feels like forever. Thanks jayextee for the review in advance :) Going to try and clear up the backlog and hopefully push myself back into a dooming mood.

Old Post 10-24-13 00:06 #
BloodyAcid is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Dragonsbrethren
Forum Staple


Posts: 2396
Registered: 03-09



schwerpunk said:
Should we re-review wads that are just re-hosted under different names or just have their music changed, etc? Or just review the changes?

Usually those just mention the changes and link to the original review.

Old Post 10-24-13 00:27 #
Dragonsbrethren is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Jayextee
Darth Jrrr


Posts: 1250
Registered: 10-00



BloodyAcid said:
Thanks jayextee for the review in advance :)


Nawwwww, it's okay. In honesty, if I'd known how long the level was before claiming it I probably wouldn't have done...


spoiler - highlight to read:


...but I'm glad I did, it turns out.



;)

Old Post 10-24-13 12:22 #
Jayextee is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
GreyGhost
Why don't I have a custom title by now?!


Posts: 8153
Registered: 01-08



schwerpunk said:
Should we re-review wads that are just re-hosted under different names or just have their music changed, etc? Or just review the changes?
I'd mention (and provide a link to) the previous review then focus on what's changed - if anything.

Old Post 10-24-13 14:10 #
GreyGhost is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
schwerpunk
Forum Staple


Posts: 2046
Registered: 05-12



GreyGhost said:
I'd mention (and provide a link to) the previous review then focus on what's changed - if anything.
Sounds about right. Are there any examples of this in the Newstuff Chronicles? Should I just paste the link in the "notes" section, and trust Bloodshedder to insert it, or provide it in the review itself? Sorry for the 20-questions, just getting warmed up to hopefully writing reviews semi-frequently.

Just finished playing Simplistic Evil alone, and I'm now looking to host a co-op game on Zandronum to see how it holds up in that mode...

Old Post 10-24-13 14:17 #
schwerpunk is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
GreyGhost
Why don't I have a custom title by now?!


Posts: 8153
Registered: 01-08



schwerpunk said:
Are there any examples of this in the Newstuff Chronicles? Should I just paste the link in the "notes" section, and trust Bloodshedder to insert it, or provide it in the review itself?
There are, but at 1AM I'm getting too tired to go looking for them. Maybe just include it in the review in HTML format.

Old Post 10-24-13 15:23 #
GreyGhost is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Jayextee
Darth Jrrr


Posts: 1250
Registered: 10-00


I'm now five reviews in. Seeing the box go green with 'Approved for publishing' is my happy place right now.

I did Monster House, by the way. I have no idea whether I'm proud of that or not.

Old Post 10-24-13 15:58 #
Jayextee is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
LordK
Junior Member


Posts: 155
Registered: 09-02



dew said:
Yeah, and when we clear the backlist with banal, shitty, cookie-cutter reviews, it'll be time for the mappers to lower their standards, because they'll need to churn out maps faster to meet our new reviewing pace. Who needs quality when you can just drown in shit and feel efficient.

That doesn't make any sense.


Jayextee said:


I just wrote my third. So, there's at least one more than 'nobody' at it. ;)

That's good, but you only did it because of this revival. Is this how's it gonna be in the future? A short period of feverish activity followed by months of neglect? I'd rather have the threshold for review quality lowered permanently.

Old Post 10-24-13 22:19 #
LordK is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Jayextee
Darth Jrrr


Posts: 1250
Registered: 10-00


My first review predates this thread. It's something I've been meaning to get to doing for a while. This thread really only made me push a little harder is all.

Should I make my next review a one-sentence wonder?

Old Post 10-24-13 22:26 #
Jayextee is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Marnetmar
Forum Staple


Posts: 2688
Registered: 09-10


Figured I'd help out. I just claimed a couple.

Old Post 10-24-13 22:41 #
Marnetmar is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
dew
experts


Posts: 3056
Registered: 05-08



LordK said:
I'd rather have the threshold for review quality lowered permanently.

Ugh, that's such a disgustingly defeatist approach. "I'm okay with mediocre shit, guys, so you should be too." Well, I'm not and I want reviews to be good.

To explain myself further: I'm not saying every review has to be a literary gem, a lot of those wads simply don't require (or deserve) that. But it kinda annoys me when someone campaigns for an overarching, constant drop of quality. When an interesting or high profile project turns up, it should get full treatment, be it praise or tongue lashing.

Old Post 10-24-13 23:08 #
dew is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Jayextee
Darth Jrrr


Posts: 1250
Registered: 10-00


I'm with Dew on this matter. Entirely. I think some fresh blood (oh look, enter Schwerpunk and I - among others) is going to help; some people here just love to write and opine on things, why not direct that toward /Newstuff?

Doesn't entirely help that the quality of content varies so wildly. I have wrote a couple of decent (I hope, we'll see when they publish) reviews of less-than-stellar wads though.

Old Post 10-25-13 11:16 #
Jayextee is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
purist
Senior Member


Posts: 1860
Registered: 04-04



Jayextee said:
I'm with Dew on this matter. Entirely.


Me too. I haven't done a review in ages and feel a pang of guilt when I see that the list has built up. I wish I had more free time.

Old Post 10-25-13 13:24 #
purist is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
LordK
Junior Member


Posts: 155
Registered: 09-02



dew said:

Ugh, that's such a disgustingly defeatist approach. "I'm okay with mediocre shit, guys, so you should be too." Well, I'm not and I want reviews to be good.

You're right that I may be too cynical. I also recognize that the reviews mean different things to different people. I treat them mostly as a download guide, so I prefer short and succinct reviews. Lately I've been mostly ignoring /Newstuff because it's not timely anymore. I have been relying on /idgames reviews instead. I guess I could do that in the future too...


dew said:

To explain myself further: I'm not saying every review has to be a literary gem, a lot of those wads simply don't require (or deserve) that. But it kinda annoys me when someone campaigns for an overarching, constant drop of quality. When an interesting or high profile project turns up, it should get full treatment, be it praise or tongue lashing.

I'm not saying that the quality of the reviews should be lowered all over the board, I too am happy to read good reviews about interesting projects. I'm just saying that low quality reviews should be tolerated because that encourages people to make reviews in a spur of a moment, thus encouraging the participation of people who don't normally do reviews or are unsure of themselves.

I can live with the current situation, I just think it's a shame, because I think the purpose of /Newstuff is to show the newest of the new stuff that the Doom community has to offer.

Old Post 10-25-13 18:26 #
LordK is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
40oz
Why don't I have a custom title by now?!


Posts: 6241
Registered: 08-07



LordK said:
I treat them mostly as a download guide,


I like that term. Thats what I think of it too. I kinda like reviews to be short and sweet, but not like the /idgames reviews' one-sentence impression. A few short paragraphs of mostly unbiased talk about what the wad is like and what to look forward to, and/or why you should keep scrolling down instead.

Old Post 10-25-13 21:18 #
40oz is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
cannonball
Forum Staple


Posts: 2101
Registered: 07-11


Back from my UK job hunting adventures, Jayextee you are in the firing line ;)

Old Post 10-25-13 21:20 #
cannonball is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
schwerpunk
Forum Staple


Posts: 2046
Registered: 05-12


I've really got to stop claiming reviews for wads that make me angry, lol.

Unrelated: has has a review really never been done in HYMN?! I remember Pavera even did a playthrough on Twitch what seems ages ago.

Old Post 10-25-13 22:23 #
schwerpunk is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Eris Falling
Forum Staple


Posts: 2613
Registered: 07-12



LordK said:
I have been relying on /idgames reviews instead.

Old Post 10-25-13 22:39 #
Eris Falling is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Springy
Senior Member


Posts: 1193
Registered: 09-12


Well for now I have been relying on idgames reviews until I wait for wow that's new stuff. I noticed though that Doom War has made a comeback and all my stuff is in the pipeline (even the ones I forgot to re upload).

Old Post 10-25-13 22:45 #
Springy is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Jayextee
Darth Jrrr


Posts: 1250
Registered: 10-00



cannonball said:
Back from my UK job hunting adventures, Jayextee you are in the firing line ;)


My body is ready. Bring lube.

As long as it's a more considered review than the comment on idgames which reads "Ugly, amateour [sic] maps!!! 1 star" then I'm fine with whatever you put. It's the purpose of reviews, really - and I'm not going to get too bent out of shape about something experimental like that being ill-received. Which, by and large, it hasn't been so far. :)

*UK brofist*

Old Post 10-26-13 12:57 #
Jayextee is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Bloodshedder
Spellchecker


Posts: 5407
Registered: 03-02


The "I need more time!" link will extend your claim the same as if you relinquished a file and then immediately reclaimed it. If someone is a jerk and abuses this feature, then they will be summarily banned from reviewing.

Old Post 11-01-13 05:48 #
Bloodshedder is online now Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Bloodshedder
Spellchecker


Posts: 5407
Registered: 03-02


You would think that the archive being closed to submissions would be a great time to catch up on reviews...

Old Post 11-28-13 18:16 #
Bloodshedder is online now Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Jayextee
Darth Jrrr


Posts: 1250
Registered: 10-00


December looks to be uneventful for me. I'll see if I can squeeze in some reviews. My first attempts seemed to go down well. :)

Old Post 11-28-13 18:28 #
Jayextee is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Mr. Chris
Forum Legend


Posts: 4622
Registered: 07-02


The backlog definitely needs to be dealt with if you ask me.

Also, why don't we just have Terry type WADs automatically put in themes/Terry because really, these types of maps aren't even funny anymore. They always involve a penis, an asshole, mentions of homosexuality and a few other gags.

__________________
Chris's uploads - Link
Brutal Video Vault
Brutal Tumblr

Old Post 11-29-13 04:31 #
Mr. Chris is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
All times are GMT. The time now is 09:52. Post New Thread    Post A Reply
Pages (3): « 1 [2] 3 »  
Doomworld Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.2.5 Doomworld Forums > Classic Doom > Doom General > /Newstuff Needs Another Revival

Show Printable Version | Email this Page | Subscribe to this Thread

 

Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF
vB code is ON
Smilies are OFF
[IMG] code is ON
 

< Contact Us - Doomworld >

Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.2.5
Copyright ©2000, 2001, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.

Message Board Statistics