Look, everyone whines about how you need to be nice to new mappers and such, give them nice critiquing and such to improve their skills. I agree with this. However, this week the wads that really got slammed hard were the two death match ones, and from what I can see they look like ass. It looks like the mapper took almost no time whatsoever on them.
And then there's Grind2x. From what I can see, Kara isn't really a n00b, so she doesn't need quite the same sugar coating as a n00b. Then there's the fact that the theme is pretty hap-hazard, and some more detailing would be nice. However for me this doesn't matter all that much, as it has pretty good gameplay. But not everyone can stand a map if it just has good gameplay, some people need good graphics to go along with it. Everyone has different opinions, and deathzor was just giving you his opinions as he's supposed to.
The other wads got pretty decent reviews, except for resizing the sprites, which is a genuine and valid comment. He seemed to love zort08, and gave it all the praise he thought it deserved.
On the subject of zort08, this is a damn great wad. The effect were really nifty, and I look forward to more releases from cyb.
So yeah, you have to take everything in context and all that. So c'mon, give him a little break on the reviews, he's doing what he thought he should. If you don't like it, then write your own reviews. Hell, ling even invited people to write their own.
My Zombie Nixon could kick your Zombie Nixon's ass.