Icon of Sin / Baphomet
Register | User Profile | Member List | F.A.Q | Privacy Policy | New Blog | Search Forums | Forums Home
Doomworld Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.2.5 Doomworld Forums > Misc. > Doomworld News > The /newstuff Chronicles #418
Pages (4): [1] 2 3 4 »  
Author
All times are GMT. The time now is 01:45. Post New Thread    Post A Reply
Bloodshedder
Spellchecker


Posts: 5533
Registered: 03-02


  • Logitech Wingman Warrior external driver - Logitech; uploaded by Simon Howard (fraggle)
    Doom/Doom 2 - Vanilla - N/A - 258579 bytes
    Reviewed by: Bloodshedder
    The latest in a number of historic vanilla Doom-related uploads from fraggle, this upload would allow you to play Doom with your Logitech Wingman Warrior joystick, if you were to still have one after so long. Extracted from a set of drivers provided by Logitech, it uses Doom's external control API to hook into the game and send movement events.

  • Deimos Carnage - NoneeLlama
    Doom 2 - Vanilla - Deathmatch - 282451 bytes - (img) (img) (img)
    Reviewed by: MajorRawne
    A deathmatch map built in the style of a Shores of Hell map, but comes across more as an homage to those 1994 that the Phantom Wad Uploaders love so much. (Seriously, are any of these uploaders active on the Doomworld forums?)

    As you'd expect there are clashing textures, the blue-circle-lights that everyone seems to use as a damaging floor, an obnoxious crusher trap above the BFG. There are plenty of wide open spaces to run through, which would keep the gameplay flowing, and there's only one room I can think of where the player can get trapped without a second way out.

    It's rather surprising to see a map that looks like this being built in 2012, but nostalgia hunters might like to give it a try.

  • Titan 1024 - Ixnatifual (Jesper Krag Rasmussen)
    Doom 2 - GZDoom - Solo Play - 6461977 bytes - (img) (img) (img)
    Reviewed by: MajorRawne
    Greetings, fellow Doomers! If I might say, what smashing blouses you're all wearing. Here we have a 10-map level set which is variously described as "crap", "mediocre", "great" and "fantastic" by self-appointed experts in the archive. Seriously, if a map is "great" does that mean its ceiling height is 10,000 and it's made up of a million sectors, or was it designed by Jesus? Does anyone else hate the fatuous use of the word "great"? It's supposed to refer to something or someone so epic they are practically majestic, and now it's used to describe Doom maps and the taste of American breakfast cereals.

    Anyway, onto the opinion of another self-appointed "expert". And if you read any of my old reviews and are waiting for immature fart jokes or Tanith curse-words, I've grown up. So I won't say "fethpoop".

    Titan 1024 gets off to a good start with a little intro animation. Your menu cursor is replaced with the severed bunny-head that super-obsessed Doomers talk about with weird, over-enthusiastic glowing in their eyes and bulging in their boxers. [Ed: Actually, this is just a GZDoom thing.] I may not be the "greatest" player in Doomdom, but I fired this up on UV. Screw you, reality, I'm the Doom Daddy for the next half an hour. All maps were played from pistol starts.

    Map 01, Storage Compartments - It is often a point of wonderment where people get the exciting names for their first maps in a level set. I recommend mouselook for this, as there are enemies directly above your start point and you won't be able to return fire at first. I love the new sky texture, and so will all the other mappers who inevitably nick it for use in their own projects. I loved the wall-mounted camera display. Why don't we see more of this stuff in Doom? For a small map, this is quite hard. It's a pistol map in cramped quarters, which makes the play feel unusually intimate, drawing you further in than a simple run and gun.

    Map 02, Command Tower - Another base map, as small and cramped as you'd expect from a 1024, with a step up in difficulty. I'd rate mouselook as essential here. There is a very cleverly-judged trap towards the end where you think you know what's coming, but the reality scared the crap out of me. Unusually, I finished the map with 100% everything, which shows how much I liked this one. I'd rate one of the secrets as essential, though.

    Map 03, Mining Operation - At first reminiscent of the PC version of Spawning Vats, I took the inevitable step down to HMP here. You can stuff it if you think I'm fighting a Hell Knight at close quarters with a pistol and an empty shotgun, pride be damned!

    Map 04, Research Lab - Anyone who thinks Hell Knights are nancy-boy Hell Baron wannabes should have a go at this map. You'll get to go toe to toe with them in a chaingun cha-cha. I found this map a bit too cramped with that in mind, and was starting to get a bit claustrophobic. There are some wider spaces on this map, but Mancs live in them so you won't get cosy. I was tiring of the cramped quarters by this point, but hey ho, at least it's not an entire megawad.

    Map 05, Belly of the Beast - the ominously-titled map gives you an even more ominous rocket launcher at the start. The music is one of my favourite Ultimate Doom tracks. The music changes when this map plays a nasty trick on you. If you win, which to be frank not everyone will, you finish the episode: hooray! Someone actually bothered to replace the episode text!

    Map 06, Healer's Cavern - An unusual and thought-provoking title for a Doom map. Things take a hellish turn here. The map is not large, like those before it, but it packs a serious wallop in both difficulty and visual appeal. This is the first appearance of the plasma gun. You're going to need it.

    Map 07, Theatre of Pain - A close quarters fight against Cacodemons, Knights and Arachnotrons. I was sniped by Chaingunners high up on darkened ledges, something which seems to happen with pissing-off frequence. You can fall through the window in the start room, which is annoying and oh, by the way, deadly, especially when you did it over a 1% health bonus. A "new" monster from the Bestiary which I haven't fought before makes an appearance. Hooray, this wasn't your typical Arachno/Manc fight, although both monsters are present.

    Map 08, Pit of Peril - Many ideas from the previous maps appear yet again here. You move from room to room, clearing out waves of monsters so that the next section can open itself up. I felt the traps with monsters beaming in or simply appearing next to the player were cheap. However, the map was dark and sinister, which appeals on a primal level.

    Map 09, Nexus - An exciting battle where you're trapped in a room and waves of monsters attack. An interesting feature is monster-only areas which you can't see into but you can shoot at. Reminds me of the Commodore 16 days when it was common for monsters to attack from "bases" or areas you couldn't access (Pacman, Tutti Frutti and Rockman being examples).

    Map 10, Hidden Complex - A base map which resembles map 02 in appearance. This is based around teleporters whose every sidedef takes you to a different location. I was tired by the time I got here, but I hate teleporter puzzles at the best of times so meh.

    Overall: The early maps are similar to each other in style with darkened rooms and close quarter fighting against minions backed up by Hell Knights. Once you've played map 06, you've seen all the variation in style that this wad offers. Levels are tight with zero wasted space in any of the rooms. There is far more attention to detail than I expected from a crap/mediocre/"great"/fantastic mapset, and the difficulty level should make this challenging to most players on their first runthrough. However, the self-imposed 1024 limit makes for a set of cramped and somewhat predictable maps, especially since the author recycles the same ideas alongside the new stuff.

    Health pickups are at a premium on UV; bring your own medikit. This creates an intimate feel where you face enemies at close quarters with low ammo. You need to husband your resources. Who knew Doom had this intriguing side to it? I did, since I used to play a lot of co-op, but no-one cares about those vanished days of linked Playstations and split-screen Legacy so let's move on.

    The music is well-chosen to fit each map. It's clear the author drew at least some inspiration from the classic Doom maps - and that's the proper classic Doom maps, not the hit-and-miss hodgepodge from 1994 that the Phantom Wad Uploader [TM] sends to the Archives each week.

    The new sky textures are amazing. If you clip to the highest point of the maps the view is just, wow. Visually the maps are interesting and very detailed. This is enhanced by the choice of GZDoom, which looks more than fantastic - it looks "great".

    These maps need to be treated with respect by the player, and each area should be swept thoroughly. Wandering and reinforcing monsters reduce your sense of security by a considerable margin, so even doing a sweep and clear is not always effective. You are never safe.

  • 5till L1 Complex - Lainos
    Doom 2 - Limit Removing + OGG support - Solo Play - 4234547 bytes - (img) (img) (img)
    Reviewed by: MajorRawne
    You need to listen to this while reading this review if you want the right atmosphere!

    "Dark, brooding, tense": three words that immediately spring to mind. How about "creepy, dark, beautiful"? Or "horrid old-school maze", linking to "lines don't show", which unfortunately describe one part of the environment. Back to the good stuff: "Mournful, lonely, quiet".

    The poetically-named 5till L1 Complex (how it rolls off the tongue!) has no story behind it, even though there has been a sustained amount of thought and effort put into the map. Including a story in the text file would have greatly enhanced my enjoyment, and it might even explain why the Doom Marine's bedroom has no ceiling. Perhaps he likes to see the stars at night. See, there's your romance, which will inevitably be re-written to star Ralphis and end up in Post Hell... maybe that's why there's no text file.

    This map is set in and around a country town that has become infested with demons. The map is much bigger than you'd expect and the town itself is very realistic - there's more to it than you see at the beginning.

    All of the weapon graphics have been replaced, although the weapons function normally. The sky is sinister, with a blood moon. There is a lot of dense terrain. This is used to good effect in places, hiding items, while in others it hampers your view. It's handy for blocking Revenant missiles travelling across the map.

    Comments in the archives indicate that less-powerful computers, including a laptop dating from 2006 (amazingly enough), suffer lag due to the terrain. So bear in mind, if you've got six-year-old, single-core laptops running 1GHz processors and graphics cards that are made from stone, you may not be able to run system-intensive, modern, source-port-requiring games. In fairness, if it's possible to be fair to such a remarkable criticism, this map lags badly in ZDoom on my beast of a computer... although not in GZDoom, which makes up for improved frame rate by being pitch black. This is the first level of any game I've played in a year that caused my framerate to drop.

    The "maze" I mentioned earlier is a chore due to your automap being useless in it. I'd rather stick my wangulum into a starving alsatian's kennel than navigate a maze in Doom. My maze resistance test was therefore taken with a -2 modifier. Other players may not be annoyed by this part and it doesn't last very long, so bear in mind this is purely a personal annoyance.

    I didn't find the difficulty to be that high in 5l1c.wad. It mostly came from long-ranged Revenants and Spectres that you can't see in the dense terrain. Some comments in the archive suggest people ran out of ammo, so keep an eye on your counter. There doesn't seem to be a lot of health, so watch that too.

    The music is creepy and suits the map perfectly. For some reason the quiet town - this is when you actually get in there, not run around a few buildings at the beginning - is the scariest part of the map. It just feels dead, yet it's attractive, and the conflict this generates within the player is intriguing. The music really helps.

    Worth a go if your computer can handle it!

  • El Furia! (dIrE fIrE) - Richard Smith Long
    Doom/Doom 2 - GZDoom - N/A - 11177139 bytes
    Reviewed by: MajorRawne
    This is a weapon and monster replacement file. The new weapons are a submachinegun, revolver, knife, hand grenades and some kind of weird fireball launcher that doubles as a heavy body suit. The new weapons are immensely satisfying to wield apart from the knife, which your character wields as if his arms are paralysed and is slower but more powerful than the fist. The fireball launcher slows you down, limiting its usefulness despite its power. Zombies hit by the fireballs burn up and scream disturbingly while they do. I think one of the screams is an un-reversed crabhead man from Half-Life 2, and that really is a horrible sound.

    As for the monsters, the only ones I spotted are black Satyrs who throw weaving grey balls at you, and evil Marines who carry pistols and submachine guns.

    There are no new levels. The new graphics aren't worth taking screenies of; they fit the game well, but we've seen it all before. An interesting diversion, but it won't make you want to play through the whole of Doom 2 again.

  • 2002 A Doom Odyssey - 10th Anniversary Edition - Various
    Ultimate Doom - Boom Compatible - Solo Play - 4433663 bytes - (img) (img) (img) (img)
    Reviewed by: MajorRawne
    I've never played ADO before, so cannot empathise with those who were irate about another re-release of this megawad. I do wonder why it has needed so many updates though. As far as I know, Alien Vendetta (yeah I'm on about AV again) got one, and some of the other classics didn't have any. Obviously someone cares very deeply about their work!

    The problem is, as these Doomers state, ADO keeps being tweaked and uploaded, where the original product was fine for them. The comments in the /idgames database make interesting reading. The tweaks in this re-release mean new maps, new music, presumably some fixes, plus the moving of E3M5 to E4M9 for some reason. This 10th Anniversary Edition took 8 months of work, impressive for a project that's already so old.

    Some of the maps in this megawad are really looking their age. The difference between this megawad and old maps I have trashed is that ADO plays really well. It doesn't just capture the look of older maps, it captures the flow, the pace, the excitement of Ultimate Doom - something most of id's levels had in abundance. They're heavily inspired by the original maps, not just in visual terms, but in the way map sections interconnect and open up. I can cope with bare rooms and empty views if the maps play well. After all, most people play Doom to play Doom, and any sightseeing is a welcome extra.

    Episode 1 is fast and furious which will bring your old Dooming instincts out of retirement. Episode 2 is the one with the crate rooms. This was always the so-so episode for me, more complex and less visually engaging (despite higher detail) with a semi-industrial feel, and I can't shake that feeling here as the tribute aspect is so on-target.

    Things change by the time you get to episode 3. Hell-themed maps are a personal favourite. You still get the blitzing action of the earlier maps with more detailed, better-looking environments. Individual Hell Barons are put to good use, and they are terrifying in E3M8 if you choose to run rather than fight. Really bring back memories! Episode 4 has a more modern feel with a couple of maps seeming relatively new, albeit visually toned down to keep an oldschool feel. Visually, E4M9 is the standout of perhaps the entire megawad, taking place outside a tomb in an overblown graveyard.

    It's not hard to miss maps that pay tribute to the originals. (For example, three guesses what happens at the end of E1M8, and there's a Tower of Babel map.) It's good to see some genuine originality as well. Overall, 2002: A Doom Odyssey will please fans of the originals and nostalgia hunters, and it might just remind jaded veterans what Doom is all about.

    See, I don't hate old wads.

  • Nitro's Chex Quest - Cory Scott (Nitroactive Studios)
    Chex Quest - Vanilla - Solo Play - 323364 bytes - (img) (img) (img) (img) (img)
    Reviewed by: Gez
    It's not every day that we see an episode replacement for the original Chex Quest. The short length of Chex Quest's episodes (five levels), combined with the rather small size and low difficulty of the typical level, means that you can go through one in less than a half-hour.

    Nitro's Chex Quest is no different in these respects. The levels are easy and provide no real challenge, even on the UV-equivalent skill, except for the very beginning as you run out of ammo with your basic weapon against a herd of demon replacement, and in the last map when running for a key in large caves filled with slime while monsters are blocking your way to make your protective suit run out. Secrets are generally easy to find and generous in ammo, armor, or health. The level design is simple and seems inspired by Wolfenstein 3D mapping practices sometimes, with architectural figures like the Concentric Redundant Corridors, or the Square Spiral of Pointlessness, and differences in elevation are sadly underused. The geometric complexity was left to create semi-realistic structures such as desks, tables, and toilets. Entering a classroom and finding a bunch of flemoids all ignoring you as they apparently concentrate on some science lesson from their professor (until you zap them all away) seemed to invert the narrative, by making you the violent invader and them the legitimate occupiers of the buildings.

    It might be regretted that this add-on wasn't made for Chex Quest 3. The increased variety of enemies, textures, and decorative items could have helped make the levels a bit more interesting to go through. In any case, it's not terrible, but if you are not a Chex Quest fan (or looking for a short mod that looks like it can be reviewed quickly), you have no real reason to check it out.

  • Toxic Darkness 2 - Henri Lehto
    Doom 2 - GZDoom - Solo Play - 5216797 bytes - (img) (img)
    Reviewed by: MajorRawne
    On the one hand we have nutters uploading ancient wads that should, in some cases, be left forgotten. On the other hand we have mad, modern-day geniuses who brings us maps whose thoughtfulness and atmosphere blow you away.

    Unfortunately, genius has its price. While Toxic Dark 2 is downright amazing to look at in places, I got sick of the view as I ran around trying to figure out what to do next. You need to look everywhere and make sure you don't miss a single switch, or a series of small platforms leading upwards, or... well that's it actually, just make sure you invoke the power of ten eagles or your puny human eyesight may be your downfall. At least the 1994 maps are usually clear about where to go next, even the shitty "maze" ones.

    Most times when you hit a switch you get a split-second view of a door opening to another part of the map. Sometimes it's obvious where this door is, sometimes not so much. You need to be awake to see these.

    I almost couldn't complete the map since I ragequit over the stupid red key. This brought back memories of the first time I played The Citadel... and I still don't know how I ever beat THAT nightmare from hell. It finally turns out that I didn't hop over a specific part of a railing, the railings which prevent your movement throughout the rest of the map. Silly me!

    I love the use of ZDoom-only features. This is something we don't see enough. There is a good use of slopes and plenty of raised walkways which you'll be fighting under and over. The map's theme holds together without a flaw. However, the walkways have railings which constrict your movement - not very handy when you've got to head down a long catwalk towards an Arachnotron. The revolving sky will be off-putting to some but came across as an interesting and unusual feature. The use of light and shadow is well thought out. There are also cameras (which I didn't feel are clearly marked, I just randomly clicked a computer display on a wall) showing you different parts of the map. This map must have been a nightmare to put together.

    So, excellent visuals, mind-bending attention to detail, plus music from the ever-awesome Aubrey Hodges, whose PSX music makes the original Doom 2 soundtrack seem laughable in comparison (sorry to tread on PC players' toes over this, but come on). The downside: frustrating gameplay which can leave you stuck and bored, which is the worst possible thing for a Doom level to do.

  • Expired License - TimeOfDeath (Chris Balch)
    Doom 2 - ZDoom Compatible - Solo Play - 418974 bytes - (img)
    Reviewed by: MajorRawne
    This is another one of those wads that features a seemingly endless number of levels, all or most of which are variants of one another. You can choose which monsters to fight and you then fight the same monsters over and over in a small, crap-looking arena. It reminds me of playing any Halo after the first where you are basically doing the same thing each time with severe restrictions on where you can go and what you can do but WOW IT'S A DIFFERENT GAME!!!!!!11one

    When you kill the monsters you hit a switch which loads the same or nearly identical map with more monsters and a different weapon. Er, this is something I'd have expected to see in 1994. We know how to fight all the Doom 2 monsters and we know how to use the weapons. Maybe the intent was to lure people away from their Call of Battlefields 4: The Reach too Far. Or maybe it was to waste everybody's time. Who knows, and to be frank, who cares. Next!

  • Entombed - XutaWoo
    Doom 2 - ZDoom Compatible - Solo Play - 232477 bytes
    Reviewed by: MajorRawne
    I recently made a bet with a friend that I, over a period of one month, could sit through the second season of Star Trek Enterprise without crying bile. When I lost the bet after Captain Archer got taken prisoner for the fiftieth bloody time, I decided to play some Doom instead. But not just any Doom. Oh no, that's for ordinary people like you lot. Did I say that out loud? Sorry, I meant... er...

    Anyway, I require a Doom map like ENTOMBED to hold my attention. No more shooting through tech bases that turn into hell, no more scientists whose high IQs and years at university somehow lead them to believe uncontrollable killing machines from hell would make a handy bio-weapon.

    Entombed does something different entirely: It gives you two weapons, the odd combination of a rocket launcher and a BFG, then it sticks you in a dark corridor filled with Imps and Hell Knights. The aim is to run around in the dark looking for ways to get the blue key, then find you're trapped in the blue key area because a) you couldn't find a practically invisible switch which is on a walkway far above the blue key area and b) you can't get out of the blue key area to get back to the switch because one of the ledges is slightly too high.

    There is an optional area with tons of extra rockets. It's guarded by a Cyberdemon you probably won't be able to kill. The area guarded by said Cyberdemon is a dead end, so have fun getting caught in rocket blasts. Oh and there's hardly any health. And when you leg it past crowds of monsters, they follow you and congregate at the bottom of steep staircases. Happy rocket launching!

    Maybe I'm playing this all wrong, maybe I missed something stupidly obvious to someone with more patience, maybe I should stick to maps where "You are enjoying your retirement - never mind the fact that you died, went to hell, saw some shit that would turn people white and gibbed ten thousand demons in an orgy of violence - when suddenly the Army wants to send you back". Any review where the reviewer is talking random crap rather than actually doing a review is not a brilliant sign, I'm afraid.

    This is one for specialty seekers only. Oh and there are no screenies because it's pretty much pitch black and bare walls; I'm sure you can picture that in your head without using Doomworld's bandwidth.

  • Odamex Nitro Deathmatch - Various
    Doom 2 - ZDoom Compatible - Deathmatch - 732058 bytes - (img) (img) (img)
    Reviewed by: MajorRawne
    A series of small and fast-paced Deathmatch maps designed for 12+ players. The maps generally flow well and are attractive for the most part. My apologies for any maps I don't mention.

    Map 7 may be an acquired taste with its eclectic mix of textures, and it has a pacey but somehow unaggressive midi - not sure how well this works with 12 people all screaming and killing one another, but I suppose such a weird map needs weird music if it's going to discombobulate! (One of the later maps also takes this approach. Both maps seem to make it work.)There's a ceiling texture where the sky should be at the start of map 9, and the grey walls are, well, let's say it doesn't follow on well from the good-looking map 8. Map 10 is short but particulary violent. There is a lot of nukage on map 11 which is possibly not ideal for a DM map, this one is more subjective I suppose.

    The music for maps 12 and 13 is awesome.

    Maps 14-16 all remind me of the original Doom 2 maps, which I gather is the intent. Map 17 features lots of annoying crushers which leave you stranded for valuable seconds and break up the flow of play; it will be interesting to see how this works with 12 people playing.

    Finally, Nebula Shrine (the last map) stands out for looking pretty, having a lovely piece of music playing - see the comments for map 7. The almost romantic feel of the starry sky and the music would in this case contrast well with manic slaughter; this is hard to pull off properly, but it works here.

    This megawad was intended for the Odamex DM group but would probably be of some interest to anyone who is looking for some genuinely original maps. Some haunting music, some good looking maps, have a blast!

  • Angry Sympathiser - RV-007
    Doom/Doom 2 - ZDoom Compatible - Solo Play - 145382 bytes - (img)
    Reviewed by: sgt dopey
    Angry sympathizer is a mod that adds a human that stands up for the demons yelling at you to stop shooting them and will try and take your weapons away from you. It gets old and annoying fast, and this is an edit of this.

    I wouldn't be in a hurry to recommend this wad to anyone.

  • Community Chest 4 - Various (see Credits)
    Doom 2 - Boom Compatible w/ SEGS limit increase - Solo Play - 24605251 bytes - (img) (img) (img) (img) (img) (img) (img) (img) (img) (img)
    Reviewed by: MajorRawne
    I've done a lot of bashing of ancient maps (note to avoid a flamewar: I don't mean ALL old maps are bad, I just think SOME of those being submitted are). The fact that they're old makes me ask whether there is any value in uploading ones that don't offer a good SP, Co-Op or DM experience when there are plenty of modern maps flying about. So if you're incensed by my other reviews, please understand I'm not trying to start a flame war over this, and I respect the opinions of people who appreciate those maps which I find unlovable.

    So let's hopefully redeem myself with this epic.

    As someone who takes a sidestep to the drama on Doomworld's forums, it's easy to miss major projects. For example... well I don't know any examples, I bloody missed them didn't I? Yet even lurkers know about the Community Chest projects.

    The first Community Chest megawad was released around 10 years ago. Most megawads seem to divide opinions, and CChest was no exception. Skip ahead to 2012 and our Dooming skills are being lambasted by the fourth megawad in the (hopefully) ongoing CChest series.

    It's a shame some megawads don't get the time or respect they deserve in these reviews. Megawads are too long for someone to review each map thoroughly and people only end up mentioning the same maps anyway. I wish I could give a project like this its real due.

    Anyway, CChest 4 is tough from the onset if played at Ultra Violence. Visually and stylistically it lends comparison more to Alien Vendetta than Hell Revealed or Requiem, and for difficulty it's kind of a beefed-up Requiem. The maps seem designed to play consecutively rather than taking each one from a pistol start.

    The opening maps are original in design with plenty of visual merit; however they play similarly since they use the same monsters and weapons, the curse of opening maps I suppose. They're well thought out for the most part and the authors lavished attention on the aesthetics.

    Map 01 bombards you with blocks of weaker enemies. Map 02 is much more interesting in design, with the stakes being raised every time you complete a section of the map and return to the start area. Map 03 has a well-designed room with a series of raised walkways, but I wasn't too keen on wandering blindly through the hills outside. Map 04 is fraught and dangerous, though the underground cave section may have you running in circles wondering about the effect of the switch you just hit.

    Map 05 is thematically the most interesting so far. It takes place inside a condemned base with interesting and thoughtful touches, including the transparent holographic computer displays, but it seems there are a hell of a lot of people and monsters wandering about for a decrepit building!

    Maps 06 and 07 are similar in that you assault a castle (map 06) and a base (map 07). Map 06 reminds me of some Alien Vendetta maps, while map 07 was either not designed for its slot or was built by someone capable of original thinking - the word "Dead" doesn't appear in its name, for instance. Good show! (It's called "Hoedown" if you wanted to know.) It felt a bit unfair to ride up a lift in map 07 and be gunned down by a chaingunner on the wall above me to my right, while I was being attacked across an entire 180 degree arc by everybody else. Chaingun snipers seem a constant annoyance in this megawad, at least on UV, so check those corners Hudson.

    Map 08 is an expansive and very detailed nukage base set in what appears to be a frozen hillside. It's very atmospheric; I haven't played many winter-themed wads, and despite its familiarity in style to other maps in the wad, this map does feel refreshing. There are icicles hanging in certain parts of the map. You can get a bit lost due to its open nature (a good thing, in many ways - it reminds you of the things that set the "shoot-em-up" Doom apart from the restrictive, shorter modern "shooters") and the crumbling condition of the base is well modeled.

    Map 09 is another hillside base as in maps 4 and 8. There is a non-linear feel, plenty of attractive things to look at, and some secrets that kind of lead from the exploration aspect. Map 10 is another map of Alien Vendetta quality for its attention to detail, and it plays really well, perhaps my favourite of the wad so far, as it bombards you with minion-level monsters rather than Barons and Revenants - these monsters do feature, you just don't get spammed with them teleporting in. It's more rewarding to kill loads of Imps and Zombies than bigger monsters.

    Map 11 is fairly original. It makes effective use of wide open spaces to make you feel like you've exited a base that leads into a series of caverns. As with some of the previous maps, map 11 does have an exploration theme to it. The music is mellow with a slightly haunting feel which suits the idea of being underground, discovering a strange new world.

    Map 12 uses mostly the larger and more powerful monsters such as Knights, Cacos, Mancs, Arachnos and Revenants. There's a fight among half-submerged ruins at the beginning where you can provoke some impressive infighting.

    Map 13 is a big, hellish place, kind of like a subverted temple or fort or something. You rush around this map to quietly intense music killing monsters that largely come from the medium to high end of the difficulty scale. Your objective is to hit skull-wall switches while dodging or killing the monsters. There's a surfeit of rockets and plasma here, which makes it easy to kill the boss monsters; I felt this map would have been better suited to having at least twice as many monsters, though some may disagree.

    Map 14 uses excellent shading techniques, and there are some very impressive views in the map. This contains one of the best easter eggs in a Doom map. Just idclipping around the map is a pleasure all of its own. I think you need to bring your own guns to this one though - a potential problem with some of these maps.

    Another nukage base awaits for those who reach map 15. This being CC4, the map is loaded with visual details. There is a very interesting fight across a nukage pit. Map 16 is a pure battle map; the gameplay is similar to map 13 with a smaller play area.

    In map 17, there are uses of blue and red textures which give areas of the map a bizarre and extremely distinctive appearance. Once again it's a base built into a cave - I don't know what the design brief for CC4 was, but it may have been something like "if there isn't a cave, or a base, or both, we'll kick you in the nuts until you sing like that choirboy who did Walking in the Air". The cave section of map 17 is extremely well-detailed and the blue area in particular is shaded very well.

    Map 18 is a city with the trademark lava canyon cutting you off from the latter part of the map. It plays engagingly and it's good-looking. Map 19 starts with a brutal engagement which you start by shooting a switch to release you from your starting area. Unfortunately you're surrounded by enemies and don't get any guns. This would be interesting to see beaten on UV -fast.

    We get a story and a mission objective in map 20! You're on a space station or spaceship whose AI has gone berserk. You get lots of nice space vistas through the window with the station hanging in the void. No effort has been spared here. The music is jolly and fast-paced. Monsters can shoot through the force fields in some windows - one window near the beginning doesn't have a force field for some reason, probably to allow you a view outside. There are tons of eye-candy details here. Map 21 follows on and features colours we don't usually see in Doom, such as electric purple lights on walls that scroll vertically. Once again there is mammoth detail and a bright, sci-fi tune to enjoy.

    It's back to dark and gritty tunnel-fighting for map 22. I really liked the music for this map. It reminded me of Plutonia due to the combination of texture and colour, although there wasn't any Revenant spam (thank God). Map 23 is (mostly) an outdoors map with large areas to manoeuvre. Chaingunners and Hell Knights feature in a map that once again reminds me of Plutonia maps at some points.

    The start area of map 24 is perhaps the most impressive outdoor area of the megawad so far. Not only does it use the combination of red sky and blacked-out terrain that worked to such sinister effect in Alien Vendetta, it also uses a track that was also used in AV... is it any wonder there are so many references to AV in this review? There are some details that go way beyond what we'd normally see, including a damaged roof with visible reinforcing struts. It's pretty much up there with the best-looking outdoor areas. Inside, the base is in a state of ruin which is superbly modelled.

    Map 25 uses music that goes beyond creepy and builds such suspense; if the map were slightly darker in places, we would have had a real frightener here. There's a nod to the House of Pain in this map, plus a rewarding secret near the beginning. I was reminded throughout of the PSX version of E2M5, not quite sure why, perhaps due to the restrained (spartan is not the word for anything about this megawad) visuals. Save some of that plasma - there's a Cyberdemon blocking the way that you need to fight, and you will also need a rapid-firing gun after that!

    Map 26 is a highly atmospheric journey through a corrupt cathedral. Maps 25 and 26 could have swapped music. The lighting, the consistency of the theme, everything is spot on. There's a wide outdoor area to contrast the shadowy interior.

    There's a section of map 27 that makes the start of AV's Firewalk With Me (AV map 29) look like Santa's Grotto. It's another map that can only be described as stunning; CChest 4 really raised the bar with its hell maps. This seems to be a common theme among megawads. While I may seem somewhat enthusiastic, I can tell you there is no compromise in how highly I view the map's appearance.

    As for map 28, Crucifix Held Close: that is possibly my all-time favourite map title (over AV's Firewalk With Me, Whispering Shadows and Bulls on Parade), though there are so many fantastic map titles out there. The music is amazing (Castlevania?) which adds incalculably to the map's appeal, never mind the eldritch, hellish theme, with some outdoor sections that gave me an eyegasm. This map is dedicated to Espi. You cannot round off a map more perfectly than that.

    You may expect map 29 to be a lava-drenched cave crawl, and you'd be right. This map appears to be where Arch-Viles come from. There's a sinister soundtrack, and you are forced to confront some powerful baddies right at the start. Visuals are once again way beyond competent. It's not too big for a map 29 either - some are massive, or super-hard. It's some of the battles that provide the scale.

    I'll give you three guesses how map 30 ends. While the visuals are detailed and attractive, I don't do Icon of Sin battles. Up 'til that point it's a good level. Map 31 didn't seem "special" in the way most secret maps are, and you can run through a good deal of it. Maxkill purists will enjoy the battles, as there is plenty of room to run around and a decent number of monsters to blast. Map 32 is an Ultimate Doom-style base battle with lots of blank walls, but a clever blast shield secret that raises walls to protect you from a surrounding ambush. Map 32 is a lot bigger than you'd expect and features an interesting area where the detail is all up in the air rather than on the ground.

    The overall colour scheme for the first 20 or so maps is a series of muted browns, greys and greens, where AV was far more colourful, so AV generally pips CC4 in obvious, immediate appeal. That is, until the Hell maps, many of which are superb to look at.

    You need to really explore these maps to appreciate the work done, as the lack of colour in some maps means the highlights don't jump out at you. I tend to start geeking out at the later maps in megawads so don't take it as a bad sign if I go on about music and appearance rather than playability! I am happy just cruising through maps with IDDQD and IDCLIP, listening to the music and gawping at the view!

    If you find this review tl;dr, fine, disrespect me for writing all of this, but don't disrespect the Community Chest crew for this megawad which, at times, borders on epic - and then crosses the border.

  • Tellerstein - Ericson Willians (Tellerstein)
    Doom 2 - Vanilla - Solo Play - 12209853 bytes - (img) (img) (img)
    Reviewed by: Dragonsbrethren
    Tellerstein is a modern 1994 wad that requires ZDoom [Ed: text file just says "tested with ZDoom"]. It has everything you'd expect from an early Doom wad: boxy and/or over sized flat rooms, inescapable areas, nonsensical, wallpaper-style texturing, low quality graphic edits, and it's even based directly on the iwad, containing a bunch of unneeded resources. The gameplay, while it's pretty average, is uninteresting due to taking place in boring spaces. The difficulty should be high for the number of hitscanners used, but it never really felt that tough. There's good ammo, health, and armor balance.

    The music is all new, and it's not that bad, actually. A bit generic, but it's pretty much the high point of the wad.

    Removing the unneeded resources, using the new textures better, and giving the maps some major clean up would definitively go a long way towards making this into an appealing project. A few areas almost get it right, but they're not worth downloading the wad for.

  • Sparta - Matt "cannonball" Powell
    Doom 2 - Limit Removing - Solo Play - 881697 bytes - (img) (img) (img) (img)
    Reviewed by: MajorRawne
    Sparta is a 3-level mapset for Doom 2 which is based on the scene from the film 300 where one of the characters goes into space to fight demons from hell on a stricken Earth colony. Since it features ogres, mutants and daemons of Nurgle, 300's historical credibility has already been called into question by others, so let's see what our underpant-wearing hero gets up to with a chaingun.

    The first thing that boiled my wee is how the maps replace levels 19-21. I know map authors have their reasons for doing this, it just leaves me wanting to chase them with a sharpened serving tray while screaming EEEEE!

    Weird annoyances aside, I enjoyed playing the maps, and they won't be getting deleted from my trusty C-drive, unlike half the wads I review. The maps are all fairly big and contain plenty of things to look at. The city level, map 19, was clean and spacious with lots of buildings to explore and tantalising views of horrors to come. The maps flow well, though there is some of the panicked racing around wondering where the hell you're going which leads you into the middle of a firefight you can't win. Since the maps are big, you need to keep a clear head and watch where you're going; as in the good old days when we first played Doom, "if you lose it out here you're in a world of hurt".

    I don't know if I am simply a bad shot, but I ran out of ammo a few times during my first playthrough of each map (pistol starts). Also, I couldn't tell any difference between UV and HMP. The difficulty level is fairly challenging. Anyone who can dodge a shot should be OK (that's why I kept dying), although there are plenty of times that you may feel overwhelmed or outmatched. I suppose that's how Doom should be, though. Doom was scary as much as fun back in the day, and Sparta definitely makes you feel like you're in trouble.

    So, very good visuals, tough gameplay, a question mark over ammo balance at certain spots in each map, and the ability to get lost. This is a wad that people who enjoy exploring or who want more than a five-minute rampage will love to strip to their underwear and fight elephants (and ogres, and mutants, and daemons of Nurgle) to. THIS IS SPARTAAAA!!!

Let me guess; one of those reviewers doesn't know how to properly appreciate a WAD that you liked this week. Want to do something about it? Instead of complaining in the comment thread like you always do, perhaps you can make a difference and write some better reviews than those idiots up there. The /newstuff Review Center is the place to do so. Put that Doomworld Forums account to constructive use, because you need one to submit reviews.

Old Post 10-11-12 23:10 #
Bloodshedder is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
TimeOfDeath
Forum Regular


Posts: 2754
Registered: 06-06


UH, I submitted a neutral review for Expired License, but it got rejected in favour of MajorRawne's clearly better review.


  • Expired License - TimeOfDeath (Chris Balch)
    Doom 2 - ZDoom 2.4.1 - Solo Play - 418974 bytes - (img) (img) (img) (img) (img) (img) (img)
    Reviewed by: eternal slumber
    Put on some pants and bring your wallet with two pieces of ID because it's time to renew your Dooming license. This wad starts off in a crowded DMV. Behind the first door, you can practice your fighting skills with different weapons against each of the Doom2 monsters in identical undetailed rooms. There's also an extra level where you practice your BFG skills against a cyberdemon by trying to maximize the amount of damage you deal to him.

    Behind the second door, you begin your final exam. The exam is 37 very short (and sometimes tough) scenarios you may find yourself in while playing various pwads, such as wallrunning, fighting hordes, pressing switches, jumping, aiming, etc., and is designed for ZDoom physics. The design of the exam is also undetailed.

    The goal of the wad is to finish the final exam without cheating or saving with 100% kills. Post a demo of your successful completion of the final exam and your new Dooming license will be mailed to you within 4-6 weeks.

    Here's a playthrough video:
    Part 1: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XsJ8_Ud6x50
    Part 2: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNDxEYmWl04

Old Post 10-11-12 23:46 #
TimeOfDeath is online now Profile || Blog || PM || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Bloodshedder
Spellchecker


Posts: 5533
Registered: 03-02



TimeOfDeath said:
UH, I submitted a neutral review for Expired License, but it got rejected in favour of MajorRawne's clearly better review.
Doesn't matter, you can't review your own stuff. And trying to do it under an alternate account is even worse.

Old Post 10-11-12 23:47 #
Bloodshedder is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
The Green Herring
Community Chest 4 Leader


Posts: 1245
Registered: 05-07


The Odamex Nitro Deathmatch review seems to have suffered a glitch. It seems to cut off in the middle of its review, which is followed by a repeat of the review for Deimos Carnage. What happened?

__________________
- The Green Herring

Get Community Chest 4 here!

Old Post 10-11-12 23:52 #
The Green Herring is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
TimeOfDeath
Forum Regular


Posts: 2754
Registered: 06-06



Bloodshedder said:
Doesn't matter, you can't review your own stuff. And trying to do it under an alternate account is even worse.
I reviewed tom19 without incident.

Old Post 10-11-12 23:59 #
TimeOfDeath is online now Profile || Blog || PM || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
The Green Herring
Community Chest 4 Leader


Posts: 1245
Registered: 05-07


That's because nobody at the time knew that "orbot" was you. Thanks for letting everyone know, though.

Old Post 10-12-12 00:04 #
The Green Herring is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Phml
Forum Staple


Posts: 3427
Registered: 06-09



Bloodshedder said:
Doesn't matter, you can't review your own stuff. And trying to do it under an alternate account is even worse.


Can't be worse than letting a single troll review 4 wads out of 5.

...I bet it's coming, so let's get this out of the way: "if you don't like it, do it yourself" is not a valid retort here, as I'm criticizing the *rules* behind /newstuff chronicles here. So if anyone wanted me to "do it myself", in other words, to redefine the rules, I'd make it so reviews from authors would be fine as long as they are suitably objective, and so no single person can claim more than half of the wads reviewed. I'd probably kick out most trollish reviewers, for that matter. Trust me, you don't want me to do it myself.

Old Post 10-12-12 00:08 #
Phml is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
j4rio
Forum Staple


Posts: 2655
Registered: 07-10



Phml said:
troll...


Not every prosperous member of society with knack for making quarterassed (I hope to get some bonus points for being the first to use the term in universe) reviews of doom wads has to be a troll. I think I hate the term from now on. With a burning passion. Eh, whatever.

Old Post 10-12-12 00:19 #
j4rio is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Dragonsbrethren
Senior Member


Posts: 2475
Registered: 03-09


A lot of Rawne's screenshots are identical. It also looks like his Deimos Carnage review got attached to NitroDM and a chunk of Titan1024 is under there.

Old Post 10-12-12 01:01 #
Dragonsbrethren is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
rsl
Mini-Member


Posts: 93
Registered: 01-10


Heh, thanks for the review of rslfuria! I wasn't expecting very much from this one, but I'm glad that the reviewer has found some value in it anyway.

However, I think MajorRawne totally missed :-P on the main gameplay feat of the mod: the rage system. That is, the mod character has a rage meter that increases when he gets repeatedly injured within a short period of time; when the gauge is filled up completely, he goes into a special "rage" status for a few seconds and gains special powers/special weapon attacks.

Granted, I tuned the rage meter on my not-so-skillful style of play, so it might not work perfectly for many others. It would be interesting to see how balanced it feels to more experienced players, even if tried on one or two large/topic levels only.

Also, the superweapon that MajorRawne refers to ("heavy body suit") is basically a cannon-equipped jetpack - provided you have enough fuel, altfire lets you switch reactors on and off, thus allowing you to fly.

Just a couple missing details I still wanted to highlight on the mod... ;-) Also, I am planning an upgrade that adds an extra player class, with more weapons.

Old Post 10-12-12 01:05 #
rsl is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Grazza
Let's try Caesium


Posts: 12496
Registered: 07-02



j4rio said:
quarterassed (I hope to get some bonus points for being the first to use the term in universe)
Sadly not. The cool kids are already onto "sixteenth-assed" and beyond.

Old Post 10-12-12 01:18 #
Grazza is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
BloodyAcid
Senior Member


Posts: 1301
Registered: 09-11


#418 already!? Feels like #417 was born yesterday.

I also disagree with reviewing your own wads. While it might not be the case, should this instance be let go, it could serve as self-advertising and deter from the real spirit of "review."

Old Post 10-12-12 01:45 #
BloodyAcid is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
lupinx-Kassman
Senior Member


Posts: 1409
Registered: 10-06


Every image link for 2002 ADO and Titan 1024 goes to the first screenshot of the 2002 ADO review.

Also as previously mentioned, something strange happened to the Odamex Nitro review.

Old Post 10-12-12 01:53 #
lupinx-Kassman is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Bloodshedder
Spellchecker


Posts: 5533
Registered: 03-02



lupinx-Kassman said:
Every image link for 2002 ADO and Titan 1024 goes to the first screenshot of the 2002 ADO review.
That's one reason to name screenshots exactly as the reviewing page gives you. In both cases, the filenames were off by one letter and I missed it.


Also as previously mentioned, something strange happened to the Odamex Nitro review.
Opera seems to be randomly screwing up display of the contents of <textarea> fields with a large amount of information in them. I guess I won't be using it to compile these anymore.

Old Post 10-12-12 02:07 #
Bloodshedder is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Herculine
Member


Posts: 277
Registered: 06-10


What? We can review our own wads?

*starts hurriedly typing...*

Old Post 10-12-12 02:07 #
Herculine is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Bloodshedder
Spellchecker


Posts: 5533
Registered: 03-02



Phml said:
Can't be worse than letting a single troll review 4 wads out of 5.

I'd probably kick out most trollish reviewers, for that matter.

Why is MajorRawn (aka NoPoet) a troll reviewer? Who would you kick out? What constitutes a "troll reviewer"? (Disagreeing with you is not a good reason.)

Old Post 10-12-12 02:08 #
Bloodshedder is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Dragonsbrethren
Senior Member


Posts: 2475
Registered: 03-09



BloodyAcid said:
#418 already!? Feels like #417 was born yesterday.

Looking at the number of approved reviews, #419 might be out soon too.

Old Post 10-12-12 03:21 #
Dragonsbrethren is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Doomguy 2000
Banned


Posts: 162
Registered: 02-11


Yeah it seems to be that way since reviewing crappy 90s wads doesn't take much time since there's so little in content. Well I have submitted a fourth review and the other 3 have been approved for publishing.

Old Post 10-12-12 04:04 #
Doomguy 2000 is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
NiTROACTiVE
Forum Regular


Posts: 890
Registered: 03-11


Thank you Gez for reviewing my second WAD Nitro's Chex Quest (it's a different version though). It lacks elevation because it was said that the original Chex Quest WADs barely have elevation, and I'll admit the final level was pretty complex and silly. As for making it a Chex Quest 3 add-on, I might do that someday but there's different textures and sprites so I'll have to work around that when I get the chance. With not too many Chex Quest fans anymore, it won't be easy ro get a lot of people to play this WAD I made. Once again, thanks Gez for the review, and thanks for not being too harsh about the problems it has.

__________________
Radioactive & Explosive | YouTube | deviantART | Twitter | Project: Illuminatus (32-level Megawad) [Beta Testers Wanted]
Previously Known as NitroactiveStudios

Old Post 10-12-12 04:12 #
NiTROACTiVE is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
glenzinho
Forum Regular


Posts: 737
Registered: 09-11


The problem I have with the Expired Licence review has got nothing to do with reviewing your own wads or whatever, but the fact that the reviewer totally glossed over a huge portion of the wad or didn't exactly know what he was reviewing. It just seems he is talking about the "training" part of the wad and not the "final exam" section. While this wad isn't going to make anyone's top ten lists, it was an interesting and unusual concept done not too badly. Besides that, props to the reviewer for this edition of the MajorRawne Chronicles.

Old Post 10-12-12 04:37 #
glenzinho is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
XutaWoo
Newbie


Posts: 9
Registered: 07-08


@MajorRawne: Well, I can tell you one thing you missed: ZDoom has a jump button. :V

The ideal way of playing through it is to not ignore too many encounters despite your state, yet make every rocket count and dodge as much as possible. Since the monsters have free movement through almost all the map, avoiding them will just cause them to congregate, as you said.

Of course, the Archviles will still cause trouble, but at least then tend to not revive everything, at least. :P

So yeah, I'm not going to argue about it being for everyone, because it clearly isn't. I really is for those who are agile in combat and can aim rockets well, which comes naturally if you keep play resource conservative.

Also, can I get some screenshots of what it looks like on your computer? It was dark when I was testing it, but it seems like an entirely different magnitude of darkness for you.

Old Post 10-12-12 07:27 #
XutaWoo is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
j4rio
Forum Staple


Posts: 2655
Registered: 07-10



Bloodshedder said:
Why is MajorRawn (aka NoPoet) a troll reviewer?


He missed 95% of content of a wad he was reviewing. If you pull off some conspiracy shenanigans, you could potentially call it trolling. I still hate that term.


Grazza said:
Sadly not. The cool kids are already onto "sixteenth-assed" and beyond.


Aw. Dammit!

Old Post 10-12-12 09:54 #
j4rio is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
cannonball
Senior Member


Posts: 2275
Registered: 07-11


Most of the reviews on here seems fine, the expired license one is the exception really to this as it does looks like he missed a major part of the wad. Personally I thought expired license was a great concept reasonably done, I would be the first to admit that TOD mapping style doesn't exactly appeal to me, but that's not to say that it is the same for everyone and unlike other map makers at the moment. TOD does put a lot of effort into his maps to extract the gameplay he wants it to be and I am fully respectful of that. In the end this wad probably would have been more popular if produced by a more "mainstream" mapper but in the end maybe that's the reason why it wasn't....because it's something different.

Anyway on to the wad I made which was reviewed. I did have some playtesting help from someone to balance the maps. I would personally encourage trying to push ahead rather than face fights one at a time. In the end this was just a mapping experiment at creating larger maps. As for the map numbering.....well simple map19 is a city map, map20 is a map19/20 doom 2 mash up and map21 is hell themed and I couldn't be bothered to add new sky textures so used the stock doom2 ones. Plus I could add a silly intermission text between map20 and 21 :P

Old Post 10-12-12 10:20 #
cannonball is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Phobus
Forum Staple


Posts: 2880
Registered: 10-06


MajorRawne is clearly a white boy, as he can't jump :P

Otherwise, reasonable reviewing effort. Could have benefitted from less tangential moaning about early '90s maps, but the on-topic stuff told me enough to make an informed decision, judging from .WADs I'm already familiar with in this set of reviews.

Old Post 10-12-12 10:33 #
Phobus is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
MajorRawne
Senior Member


Posts: 1340
Registered: 04-10


Wonderful, another weekly case of "hate the reviewer, fear the reviewer, kill the reviewer" - which I was completely expecting. I wasn't expecting to become the leading figure in some weird conspiracy theory. Thanks j4rio, I knew I'd be famous one day.

Can I firstly point out that I am not NoPoet any more, I am MajorRawne. I have put in enough hard work to atone for the dark days. So I'd appreciate no more references to that era please, it ended ten years ago.

The reviews and screenies were correct when uploaded unless I somehow made a massive FUBAR. (EDIT: Apparently I did with the picture names - sorry!) I wrote seperate reviews for each wad and took way more screenshots than was sensible to upload, though I am prepared to provide them if required.

TimeofDeath: I can see you and I having problems. You criticise me for not liking your wad which YOU sneakily created a new account to promote - this level of behaviour is so far beneath most honest Doomworlders I can't believe you aren't embarrassed. The wad I reviewed was not excellent, it was not impressive to me alongside some of the other wads I reviewed, it was a speciality map with limited appeal and there is no WAY I was going to play dozens of maps that were slight variations of the same theme. I actually did play more than a score of them including the "final exam".

By omitting the "final exam" I was failing to mention another fight against Doom 2 monsters in other bland environments. I didn't like the wad, I'm sorry but that's LIFE - and nobody else was willing to review it apart from you. Perhaps THAT is more telling than my omission. Maybe you can explain to us what's so game-changing about what I left out?

Phml: I'd better not reply to you since you invoked the "no backchat" rule in accordance with the Junior School Playground Act of 1957. Don't worry though, I and all the other reviewers are so scared of you we'll do as you say and not as you do.

XutaWoo: I usually don't use jumping in maps, sorry, I didn't realise it was allowed in yours. I don't actually configure a jump key any more, it makes me feel like cheating on some maps.

This may come as a surprise to some people but I dislike hurting others' feelings and do not like offering negative feedback UNLESS I feel the wad was either some kind of jokewad or a waste of time, or if I simply didn't like it. I guess I still have my sense of sarcasm which occasionally takes over, so I will try to reign it in a bit more for the future.

I worked my arse off on these "quarter-assed" reviews (what insulting B.S.) and I apologise if I missed things about the many, many wads and maps I played through. Doomworld is a tough crowd and mistakes get punished immediately - however someone had to do the reviews as NOBODY was doing them (no disrespect intended to those who actually have submitted reviews). EDIT: If my reviews were that bad, why was the only rejected review one of TimeofDeath's - wouldn't mine be rejected if they were biased, wrong or just plain crap? It's not going to destroy my self-esteem if a review got rejected, no melodrama, I'd simply do better next time!

There were wads like CChest4 which were frankly never going to get the feedback or review they deserved. So maybe some of the complainers can show some balls and put their opinions up for others to read, and maybe put in a fraction of the effort I did. EDIT: I respect that people have now started doing this - thank you.

My apologies for the rant and for the "Major Rawne Chronicles" but ffs, maybe it turned out this way because I gave a shit. I'm not trying to be a martyr, I'm just sick of the whining and the unreviewed megawads.

Last edited by MajorRawne on 10-12-12 at 13:27

Old Post 10-12-12 12:56 #
MajorRawne is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
j4rio
Forum Staple


Posts: 2655
Registered: 07-10


Blah blah blah :))

Old Post 10-12-12 13:26 #
j4rio is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Phml
Forum Staple


Posts: 3427
Registered: 06-09



Why is MajorRawn (aka NoPoet) a troll reviewer?


You answered the question yourself by including his old alias, really. His decade-old crusade against gameplay-oriented wads is hard to miss, unless you're purposefully looking the other way.

Beyond that, he has been repeatedly picking wads he knows he'll hate just so he can make antagonizing reviews with factually wrong claims. Genuine incompetence can explain one or two mishaps, but not an entire history of doing such things over the years.

Seeing as you publish every /newstuff Chronicles and (I assume?) review the reviews, there is really no excuse for you not to know this.


He missed 95% of content of a wad he was reviewing. If you pull off some conspiracy shenanigans, you could potentially call it trolling. I still hate that term.



It takes at least two people to form a conspiracy. Such things also tend to be low-key. Here, there's really just one dude taking a dump in plain view on a particular genre, and people choosing not to care about it because they don't care for that genre either.

Old Post 10-12-12 13:57 #
Phml is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
Phobus
Forum Staple


Posts: 2880
Registered: 10-06



Phml said:
Beyond that, he has been repeatedly picking wads he knows he'll hate just so he can make antagonizing reviews with factually wrong claims. Genuine incompetence can explain one or two mishaps, but not an entire history of doing such things over the years.

Butthurt and bullshit. He's just reviewing everything that's there because not many other people are doing it. Your problem is that he's just not liking what you like and not saying as much about the things he doesn't like to avoid trampling on other peoples feelings quite so much.

Old Post 10-12-12 14:12 #
Phobus is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
j4rio
Forum Staple


Posts: 2655
Registered: 07-10


He hasn't reviewed vast majority of content within a wad. I mean, it's like, he completely failed at reviewing. The only excusable action he could do was to apologise to author, but instead you see this absurd rant wall few posts above. It doesn't matter jackshit whether he liked it or not.

Old Post 10-12-12 14:21 #
j4rio is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
MajorRawne
Senior Member


Posts: 1340
Registered: 04-10


Sorry about the rant, I couldn't help it ;)

Phml - you seem to be describing someone else. It's tantamount to character assassination, or would be if I cared. Don't read my reviews if they are so bad. Perhaps Bloodshedder has moved on from stuff that happened years ago and you haven't?

J4rio - your posts are what trolling looks like. Have you got anything mature and relevant to say? Why don't you write some reviews then and teach me the error of my ways? EDIT: And it DOES matter jack shit if I like it or not, as I was the only person who could be bothered to review it.

EDIT: Phobus gets it, so why don't Phml and J4rio?

Who knew reviewing a wad could break so many hearts!

Last edited by MajorRawne on 10-12-12 at 14:56

Old Post 10-12-12 14:49 #
MajorRawne is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit || Quote
All times are GMT. The time now is 01:45. Post New Thread    Post A Reply
Pages (4): [1] 2 3 4 »  
Doomworld Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.2.5 Doomworld Forums > Misc. > Doomworld News > The /newstuff Chronicles #418

Show Printable Version | Email this Page | Subscribe to this Thread

 

Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF
vB code is ON
Smilies are OFF
[IMG] code is OFF
 

< Contact Us - Doomworld >

Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.2.5
Copyright ©2000, 2001, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.