Doom monster
Register | User Profile | Member List | F.A.Q | Privacy Policy | New Blog | Search Forums | Forums Home
Doomworld Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.2.5 Doomworld Forums > Misc. > Everything Else > What defines Art?
Pages (2): [1] 2 »  
Author
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:44. Post New Thread    Post A Reply
Liam
the Bard formerly known as the Bard


Posts: 4018
Registered: 08-00


#ZDoom log, cropped a bit:

[20:03] <pr1tchlet> Liam I am worried about you
[20:04] <Liam_the_Bard> why's that
[20:04] <darknation2> HORSE PENIS IS FUN
[20:04] <SoM> haha
[20:04] <pr1tchlet> you are into teh torture
[20:04] <pr1tchlet> your worse than kat
[20:04] <Liam_the_Bard> not into it as in into it into it, whacking off licking my lips into it
[20:04] <Liam_the_Bard> i just think he's a kickass artist
[20:05] <darknation2> is it art?
[20:05] <darknation2> Big question.
[20:05] <Quasar`> not exactly heheh
[20:05] <Liam_the_Bard> what is it if it isn't art
[20:06] <darknation2> Hmmm... depends on your *******ion of art
[20:06] <Liam_the_Bard> what's YOUR definition of art
[20:06] <darknation2> I'd say art was political
[20:06] <Liam_the_Bard> pff
[20:06] <darknation2> And always beautiful
[20:06] <Liam_the_Bard> art cant' always be beautiful
[20:06] <pr1tchlet> heh
[20:07] <Liam_the_Bard> well actually heh there's some uziga stuff that's quite beautiful imo
[20:07] <darknation2> Yeah... I think art should be interesting to look at I guess
[20:07] <Quasar`> just look at it :P
[20:08] <darknation2> What is the point in it?
[20:08] <Quasar`> I made it after the FTC made that stupid report about game companies "marketing violent games to children"
[20:09] * darknation2 is now known as darknation
[20:09] <Quasar`> it used to be on my page ehehe
[20:09] <darknation> no, I was refering to liams pics
[20:09] <darknation> heh
[20:09] <Liam_the_Bard> Well not all art has to have a cleancut purpose or point
[20:09] <Liam_the_Bard> Just make your own interpretation, it's pretty obvious he's trying to say something
[20:09] <darknation> Art has to have thought behind it
[20:10] <Liam_the_Bard> Well how much thought does, say, a doom texture have behind it?
[20:10] <Liam_the_Bard> You need spacebase textures, you make a spacebase texture
[20:10] <Liam_the_Bard> but it's still art
[20:10] <darknation> doom textures are not art
[20:10] <darknation> it's a picture.
[20:10] <Doom-Child> not intrinsically, but when arranged properly
[20:10] <Quasar`> blah
[20:10] <darknation> heh
[20:10] * Quasar` gets mad
[20:10] <Liam_the_Bard> this would be an interesting poll
[20:11] <darknation> WHat: "Are these pictures of mutilated girlies art?"
[20:11] <SoM> heh
[20:11] * Darkstalker has joined #zdoom
[20:11] <Quasar`> hehehe
[20:11] <Liam_the_Bard> I think they are
[20:11] <pr1tchlet> hmm
[20:11] <fragglet> aye
[20:11] <Liam_the_Bard> look at some of the 'non bleeding' versions, it's amazing the effort and detail he puts into his work
[20:12] * pr1tchlet goes to bed
[20:12] <darknation> As a former Student of Art (read as Dundee College) I have to say I find these images of low merit.
[20:12] <Liam_the_Bard> and if he does it because he thinks it's nifty to look at or if he's trying to say something, it's still art
[20:12] <Liam_the_Bard> yeah but you failed every class
[20:12] <Danarchy> ROFLMAO
[20:12] <darknation> No, that was a differnt course
[20:12] * pr1tchlet has quit IRC ("what is art? etc. etc. etc...")
[20:13] <Liam_the_Bard> alright I'm going to make a thread in EE about this
[20:13] <Liam_the_Bard> this is a good discussion topic
[20:13] <darknation> Maybe art means diffent things to differnet people.
[20:13] <Danarchy> no its not
[20:13] <Danarchy> wait
[20:13] <Danarchy> yes it is
[20:13] <darknation> heh
[20:13] <darknation> FLame on!
[20:13] <Doom-Child> for real, yo
[20:13] <Doom-Child> you're damning us all to suffer the opinions of idiots
[20:14] <Doom-Child> but isn't that what free expression is all about?

The question is, what does a drawing/sculpture/photograph/photoshop/whatever need to qualify as art, or what it is that separates 'low' art from 'high' art, or is there a universal standard to judge a work of art at all?

If you see someone's brains splattered across a railroad track and you decide to draw it because it's cool to look at, is your drawing art? Is it low art or high art or does it depend on who's looking at it? Are textures or models for games 'high' art? Could a crime scene photograph or a photograph of someone's front lawn be art?

Discuss.

Old Post 07-15-02 01:01 #
Liam is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Danarchy
YOU CAN'T CUT BACK ON FUNDING! YOU WILL REGRET THIS!


Posts: 14164
Registered: 01-01


Who the Hell is Uziga?

__________________
-D(A)N

Old Post 07-15-02 01:05 #
Danarchy is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
darknation
Forum Staple


Posts: 3082
Registered: 03-02


Darknation defines Art - Chapter 1

Example 1 - Pollock makes a mess on a page = art

Darknation projectile vomits onto the sidewalk = gross


Now, what seperates these two acts? The end result looks pretty much the same. But one is art and one is vomit. Why?

Pollock's creations are abstract representations of either emotions, feelings or visions. Darknation just had one too many beers last night. Therefore Art should represent something other than poor beer management.


Example 2 - Picasso draws women at weird right angles and deforms their bodies = art

Darknation can't draw a straight line because his crack-addled body convulses into fits of shaking at the smell of paper = crap


Why, when the result looks so similar, is one art and one crap?

Well, Picasso spent years studying previous african art and applying the same techniques to his paintings. The hacked up women in his pantings also have deep meaning linked to psyche and personalities of his sitters. Darknation just can't draw.

The difference here is the intent behind the work and how much thought went into it's production in the painter's head.


Modern Artist shits her bed and displays it at the Tate = art

Darknation shits in his girlfriend's bed and get's it rubbed in his face and soddomized roughly with a pair of curling tongs = whoops


Apparently years at an Art College allows you to call virtually anything 'art' as long as you can justify the thinking behind it.


Michaelangelo paints Cathedral with angels and stuff = Art

Darknation vandalises church wall with a spray can and book of obcenities = Burning in Hell for All Eternity


Art should have either religous or political point, even if it's point is to be pointless.

To be continued later...

Old Post 07-15-02 01:20 #
darknation is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
fodders
OWNS YOU


Posts: 5810
Registered: 05-00


http://www.channel4.com/science/microsites/A/anatomists/images/biggal3.jpg

ART? This is a dead guy skinned, his skin is to the left, it's on exhibition

__________________
Fod's page Son's place De Man's place
You are my opponent, but not my enemy, for your resistance gives me strength. Your will gives me courage. Your spirit ennobles me. And, although I aim to defeat you, should I succeed, I will not humiliate you, instead I will honour you..For without you, I am a lesser man.

Old Post 07-15-02 02:05 #
fodders is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
IMJack
Web Radio Geek


Posts: 3704
Registered: 10-01


http://users.sisna.com/stiflex/sluggyframe.jpg
[Copyright 2000 Pete Abrams, used w/out permission]

__________________
Listen Up!!! http://radio.utdallas.edu/ Monday nights 10-midnight Central

Old Post 07-15-02 04:11 #
IMJack is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Danarchy
YOU CAN'T CUT BACK ON FUNDING! YOU WILL REGRET THIS!


Posts: 14164
Registered: 01-01


Riiight...anyway:

I believe art can be anything. Art, in a way, is the appearance of emotion in anything. If something gives you a feeling like happiness, sadness, or even a 'hey, thats pretty cool' kinda feeling, then its probably art.

Art can be found in nature, weather it being the intrecate systems within the human anatomy, the call of a bird, a warm pink sunset, or the symmetrical shape of a leaf.

Then there is also conventional art, such as sculptures, paintings, or photography. Art can be made to capture the beauty or grotesqueness of a person, object or lanndscape (realism). Or it could be used to interpret how such a thing appears in the artist's eyes (impressionism), or it could just be the expression of the artist's feelings (abstract).

Art can be auditory as well. Music is a great way to convey emotions to others. A slow, sad piece can darken one's mood. A happier, lighthearted piece could cheer a person up.

Also, there is experimental art. Some artists like to find new ways and methods of art. For example, the impressionists who dared to make paintings which were less than realistic (under much scorn). Or Andy Worhol who took photographs and converted them into mockeries of life and popular culture. Or Jimi Hendrix who showed us all the gret things you can do with a guitar. Or Kraftwerk, who showed us that electronic noises can be put together to make music. Or Frank Zappa who experimented personaly with many different types of music and combining them while poking fun of the way everyone lives their lives. Or Picasso, who decided that realistic porportions and angles aren't really neccesary in portraits. Or M.C. Escher who showed us just how freaky our visual perseption can be.

Basicaly, art can be almost anything.

__________________
-D(A)N

Old Post 07-15-02 06:16 #
Danarchy is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Naked Snake
HAHA I AM A FAG AND I CAN'T CHANGE THIS TITLE ANYMORE


Posts: 11313
Registered: 05-01


You really could consider a lot of things art or an art. George Carlin is comedian, but is he an artist? In a sense, yes he is. Words to him are like a painters pallete which he can string together a fantastic routine. He talks about a lot of stuff, mainly about society, the government, people and other bullshit. Could you consider the band KoRn artists? Yes, they use music to express feelings, wether it be rage, insecurity or insanity. A person took a copy painting of the Virgin Mother Mary and splattered it with cow dung. Some people consider this art. But how is this considered art? He did not even make the painting, he simply lobbed bovine shit at it. However, the person who made the painting I could consider an artist. A painting of the Virgin Mother Mary, mother to Jesus Christ, represents many emotions. Peace, tranquility, innocence, motherhood and other such feelings. Art comes in many different forms and can be done by anybody. Even stick figure drawings little kids create could be considered art, though you probably wouldn't see one hanging in a mueseum.

__________________
DOOMWORLD All your favorite ports and map editors
DooM DM!!
3057 reasons to keep on dooming

Old Post 07-15-02 06:32 #
Naked Snake is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Julian


Posts: 2677
Registered: 04-75


Art is the intent. Face it: there is no way to define art from its form.

Old Post 07-15-02 08:53 #
Julian is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
spank
I'm afraid of Americans


Posts: 1888
Registered: 06-00


You fucking art fags! :p

__________________
lord
tear the system down
fortune -o

Old Post 07-15-02 13:47 #
spank is offline Profile || Blog || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
VileSlay
Senior Member


Posts: 1591
Registered: 05-02



bigbadgangsta said:
A person took a copy painting of the Virgin Mother Mary and splattered it with cow dung. Some people consider this art. But how is this considered art? He did not even make the painting, he simply lobbed bovine shit at it.


if you are talking about the painting that appeared in the sensation exibit in the brooklyn museum of art, then the guy did paint the figure of mary and he used elephant dung, not cow. and the contoversy over it was retarded. according to his african culture elephant guano is a symbol of fertility and renewal. the artist used that "medium", if you will, in most of his works. some people, including the former mayor of NYC, were to closed minded to see that it was not a desecration of mary but an way of honoring her. not many could see past that though and went to that exhibit just to see the one painting, not realizing that there were many fabulous works of art dispalyed along with it.

__________________
"I only wish that you, the peons, the lowly zit ridden scum of outcast prepubescence so recklessly misspending the treasure of youth could truly understand my utter disdain for you as I look out from my lofty perch of immeasurable fame and opulence." beefcake the mighty of GWAR

Old Post 07-18-02 08:40 #
VileSlay is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Shaviro
Team Future Chief


Posts: 8849
Registered: 06-00


Don't we have some beatnicks we can ask? =)

For me art can be everything. From a movie to a level in DOOM. From a picture to a piece of music.

__________________
Ybbx sbe hcqngrf fbba.

Old Post 07-18-02 09:23 #
Shaviro is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
læmænt
BAND


Posts: 3801
Registered: 11-00


http://library.thinkquest.org/20868/ico/gal/s410.jpg
Kazimir Malevich, Black Square

__________________
signature edited for sake of insanity

Old Post 07-18-02 09:49 #
læmænt is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
JavaGuy
Member


Posts: 479
Registered: 02-02


Art cannot be defined. Art is simply the act of a thing, the being of thing. The world is art, and everything thing you do is an art. Our lives are each an art.

Ohhh yeah. Cool Beads man.
*whips out the bongos and dark sunglasses*

__________________
My mind is an empty shell. Other's thoughts enter, bouncing off the walls an' echo. Never thinking for myself or but for myself I think. So now I've left it all behind finished 'least with a good deed. A long road awaits, and I'm on my own.... I feel pretty good.

Old Post 07-18-02 19:15 #
JavaGuy is offline Profile || Blog || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Spike
Team Future has a new Giger-esque in the works


Posts: 2562
Registered: 04-02


Time for that wonderful, all-purpose answer :

The quality of art depends on the personality of the viewer.

I can't stand half the shit in the Tate gallery. As for Mr. No-skin pictured above, i don't see that as art - interesting, yes - but not art.

__________________
I Love the Dead. Frequently.

Old Post 07-18-02 20:20 #
Spike is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
pritch
Super Moderator


Posts: 6135
Registered: 11-01


wtf is art?

__________________
I'm the magic man. I got magic hands.

Old Post 07-18-02 21:03 #
pritch is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
spank
I'm afraid of Americans


Posts: 1888
Registered: 06-00


If you are pretentious you can be an artist.

__________________
lord
tear the system down
fortune -o

Old Post 07-18-02 23:32 #
spank is offline Profile || Blog || Email || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
IMJack
Web Radio Geek


Posts: 3704
Registered: 10-01


hahamadeyoulook.png
Dan Lemcke, 404 Image Not Found

__________________
Listen Up!!! http://radio.utdallas.edu/ Monday nights 10-midnight Central

Old Post 07-19-02 04:04 #
IMJack is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Danarchy
YOU CAN'T CUT BACK ON FUNDING! YOU WILL REGRET THIS!


Posts: 14164
Registered: 01-01


I hate those primary color paintings by that one guy. What a waste of space. Its like 'Yay...I can paint red, blue, and yellow rectagles'.

__________________
-D(A)N

Old Post 07-19-02 04:13 #
Danarchy is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
999cop
Constrained Owing to Lot


Posts: 3180
Registered: 12-00


Whatever is beautiful is considered as art.

__________________
.dronF

Old Post 07-19-02 07:08 #
999cop is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
nxn
meephead


Posts: 5398
Registered: 09-01



999cop said:
Whatever is beautiful is considered as art.

I know plenty of art that portrays things a normal person would find hideous (sp?) and revolting. Most of the art I like comes in that form aswell.

__________________
What once was moose is now all meep.

Old Post 07-19-02 07:13 #
nxn is offline Profile || Blog || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
darknation
Forum Staple


Posts: 3082
Registered: 03-02


There is the answer. Art has to move you emotionally.

Old Post 07-19-02 11:03 #
darknation is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
nxn
meephead


Posts: 5398
Registered: 09-01


If the thing I'm looking at is making me think of what it means, represents, shows, or how it relates to me I'll call it art.

Like that pic of the skinned guy above, I don't consider it art because there was nothing to it, there was nothing you could pick up from it. It was just your plain ol human model. Now if the thing had 3 dicks (which at first I thought it did) and a ball hanging from it's forhead I'd consider it art.

__________________
What once was moose is now all meep.

Old Post 07-19-02 11:10 #
nxn is offline Profile || Blog || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
fodders
OWNS YOU


Posts: 5810
Registered: 05-00


Although it's not a model, that's why the guy thinks it's an art form, it's an actual human body, donated, then skinned.

__________________
Fod's page Son's place De Man's place
You are my opponent, but not my enemy, for your resistance gives me strength. Your will gives me courage. Your spirit ennobles me. And, although I aim to defeat you, should I succeed, I will not humiliate you, instead I will honour you..For without you, I am a lesser man.

Old Post 07-19-02 12:58 #
fodders is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
nxn
meephead


Posts: 5398
Registered: 09-01



fodders said:
Although it's not a model, that's why the guy thinks it's an art form, it's an actual human body, donated, then skinned.

Then why does he take credit for it? He didn't design it. It's like me stealing the monalisa, taking off the frame and saying it's mine.

__________________
What once was moose is now all meep.

Old Post 07-19-02 21:26 #
nxn is offline Profile || Blog || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
darknation
Forum Staple


Posts: 3082
Registered: 03-02


It's more to do with the pose of the bodies.

Old Post 07-19-02 21:54 #
darknation is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
Danarchy
YOU CAN'T CUT BACK ON FUNDING! YOU WILL REGRET THIS!


Posts: 14164
Registered: 01-01


Yes, like there is one body that is in a running position and all of its muscles are steaming out behind him to help emphasise the motion.

__________________
-D(A)N

Old Post 07-19-02 23:59 #
Danarchy is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
nxn
meephead


Posts: 5398
Registered: 09-01



the_Danarchist said:
Yes, like there is one body that is in a running position and all of its muscles are steaming out behind him to help emphasise the motion.

That's an example of something I wouldn't consider art. What's the point of it?

__________________
What once was moose is now all meep.

Old Post 07-20-02 00:29 #
nxn is offline Profile || Blog || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
darknation
Forum Staple


Posts: 3082
Registered: 03-02


What is the point in the Mona Lisa?

Ultimately all art is pretty useless.

Old Post 07-20-02 00:44 #
darknation is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
fodders
OWNS YOU


Posts: 5810
Registered: 05-00


Orion: To warn you not to chase cabs in Harlem NY?

__________________
Fod's page Son's place De Man's place
You are my opponent, but not my enemy, for your resistance gives me strength. Your will gives me courage. Your spirit ennobles me. And, although I aim to defeat you, should I succeed, I will not humiliate you, instead I will honour you..For without you, I am a lesser man.

Old Post 07-20-02 00:44 #
fodders is offline Profile || Blog || PM || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
nxn
meephead


Posts: 5398
Registered: 09-01



darknation said:
What is the point in the Mona Lisa?

Ultimately all art is pretty useless.


Well, actually no point to it. But it did make me wonder why the hell she has that dumbass look on her face. Everyone who sees it wants to know why in hell is she smilling like that, and yet no one can know for sure.

I don't think you can find something like that in the skinned dude, there's nothing that I can see that would make you think of what's going on or what happened outside of the scene you see. If there were clues or a reason to maybe why his skin isn't on him or some thing else that would make you think of what happened in the scene that you can't see, maybe then it would be considered art, atleast for me.

__________________
What once was moose is now all meep.

Old Post 07-20-02 00:56 #
nxn is offline Profile || Blog || Email || Homepage || Search || Add Buddy IP || Edit/Delete || Quote
All times are GMT. The time now is 05:44. Post New Thread    Post A Reply
Pages (2): [1] 2 »  
Doomworld Forums : Powered by vBulletin version 2.2.5 Doomworld Forums > Misc. > Everything Else > What defines Art?

Show Printable Version | Email this Page | Subscribe to this Thread

 

Forum Rules:
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is OFF
vB code is ON
Smilies are OFF
[IMG] code is ON
 

< Contact Us - Doomworld >

Powered by: vBulletin Version 2.2.5
Copyright ©2000, 2001, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.