Jump to content
Search In
  • More options...
Find results that contain...
Find results in...

reviews

Sign in to follow this  

10 files

  1. Doom WAD file reviews

    These reviews are the opinion of one person - me. If I don't like your WAD, I'm sorry, but don't waste your time sending me hate mail. I do this as a service mainly for my users and for anyone else in the Doom community who doesn't want to sort through the growing number of WADs.

    All the WADs were reviewed only for single player mode.

    0 downloads

       (0 reviews)

    Submitted

  2. The Doom WAD Reviews v0.12

    These are a set of reviews for single play of all the new levels for Doom 1 on ftp.cdrom.com beginning with the numbers 0-9 or with the letters A-B.

    I am aiming to review all the levels on ftp.cdrom.com. I have released those that I have done so far mainly so people can comment, and perhaps reveal any problems with the reviews.

    The reviews are all in HTML. I am no expert, but most of the stuff should work with any browser. I know it works with Internet Explorer 3.0.

    The reviews come are in two ZIP files, which should hopefully be somewhere near this TXT file. These are:

    D1REV0B.ZIP - The reviews themselves. This is all you need to see the reviews. Approx 131Kb.

    D1REV0BG.ZIP - Some screenshots of some of the better levels. If you download these, they appear beside the reviews, to give a real feel to some of the levels. You don't need these. Approx 615Kb. You have to download a copy of D1REV0B.ZIP to get the reviews themselves.

    1 download

       (1 review)

    Submitted

  3. The Doom WAD Reviews v0.12 screenshots

    These are a set of reviews for single play of all the new levels for Doom 1 on ftp.cdrom.com beginning with the numbers 0-9 or with the letters A-B.

    I am aiming to review all the levels on ftp.cdrom.com. I have released those that I have done so far mainly so people can comment, and perhaps reveal any problems with the reviews.

    The reviews are all in HTML. I am no expert, but most of the stuff should work with any browser. I know it works with Internet Explorer 3.0.

    The reviews come are in two ZIP files, which should hopefully be somewhere near this TXT file. These are:

    D1REV0B.ZIP - The reviews themselves. This is all you need to see the reviews. Approx 131Kb.

    D1REV0BG.ZIP - Some screenshots of some of the better levels. If you download these, they appear beside the reviews, to give a real feel to some of the levels. You don't need these. Approx 615Kb. You have to download a copy of D1REV0B.ZIP to get the reviews themselves.

    0 downloads

       (0 reviews)

    Submitted

  4. Doom Deathmatc ratings

    A comprhensive list (over 800 levels). Very subjective please realize that these are only our opinions. This should help you find good levels to play though.

    1 download

       (1 review)

    Submitted

  5. Another 'The Best' PWADs list v3.1

    Review of 38 PWADs with new sounds, graphics, musics and 274 maps for DOOM and DOOM 2, that includes features, requirements, rating, file availability in the Internet, BBSs and CDROMs compilations. From the hundreds of PWADs that were made for id Software's masterpiece, here is info to get some of the greatest.

    3 downloads

       (1 review)

    Submitted

  6. TiC's WAD Reviews #41-#60

    Here they are! The next 20 reviews of Doom, Doom 2 and Heretic WADs. All were posted to rec.games.computer.doom.playing, now you can download them here too.

    Take a look at the WebPage with my reviews, you can download most of the WADs there too. Look out for the first 40 reviews: TICREV01.ZIP and TICREV02.ZIP

    2 downloads

       (2 reviews)

    Submitted

  7. TiC's WAD Reviews #21-#40

    Here they are! The next 20 reviews of Doom, Doom 2 and Heretic WADs. All were posted to rec.games.computer.doom.playing, now you can download them here too.

    Take a look at the WebPage with my reviews, you can download most of the WADs there too. Look out for the first 20 reviews, TICREV01.ZIP.

    0 downloads

       (0 reviews)

    Submitted

  8. TiC's WAD Reviews #1-#20

    Here they are! The first 20 reviews of Doom, Doom 2 and Heretic WADs. All were posted to alt.games.doom and rec.games.computer.doom.playing, now you can download them here too.

    Btw. there will be a WebSite with my reviews soon!

    3 downloads

       (1 review)

    Submitted

  9. The PWAD Reviews

    An ongoing effort to review EVERY PWAD OUT THERE! This file contains about 70 in-depth reviews and 20 short reviews, with a quick reference and overall scores at the front for comparison! This document is still in the making, and new reviewers are welcome! Now 92 Pages!

    5 downloads

       (5 reviews)

    Submitted

  10. Review of OPOST21.WAD

    This is a review (by Frank Stajano, fms@cam-orl.co.uk) of OPOST21.WAD.

    2 downloads

       (2 reviews)

    Submitted

Sign in to follow this  
  • File Reviews

    • By SeanLeal · Posted
      Dear Doomkid,

      I was involved in the design and play-test of each of these levels. Please know these were created from *scratch* and we spent our time making sure the levels were as playable as possible. We were not terribly focused on texturing, other than to give players positional awareness in different parts of each arena.

      Map 6 -- Offices of Death -- Was intentionally designed to be as accurate a representation of the office we worked in as possible. Admittedly, playability was taken as a second priority. We did manage to create working "elevators" and "stairs" to give the illusion you were going up and down floors. I was pretty happy with how we did.

      Considering it was 1996, and no way to simply "Google" different ideas. Your best bet at the time was to jump onto the Usenet and hope you could find a decent board with active members. Other than that, it was pretty much all self-taught.

      I'm glad you enjoyed the other levels. Yes, they are old-school, big arena, style. We spent a LOT of time trying to make sure they were as balanced as possible, with escape routes, and required risks for rewards.
    • By Summer Deep · Posted
      Excellent stuff for the mid-1990s. Lots of action, good layouts, pretty challenging on UV.    9/10
    • By Meril · Posted
      For 1995 design is ok. But is VERY short. 3 min in slow pace.  Map is easy af.
    • By Meril · Posted
      Square rooms, no details, ugly. Secrets aren't flagged as secret. Only for crappy-wad-lovers.
    • By Meril · Posted
      For 1995, not bad. Some ideas, are really cool, but they're mixed with dumb things. Texture misalignments are common. Overall I had nice time with this.
×