The Rebirth

Great stuff! -apdoshell

definitley not a total conversion, two enemies looked different, few sound effects and some flats, that's it. Great maps and all dont get me wrong but definitley not a tcwad

Good traps and surprises.

Basically nice set of levels with one big problem: there are only two themes, and all maps except 31 & 32 are small variations of those. Therefore overall gameplay feels like playing two very large levels, after some maps there aren't any surprises anymore, so while playing it out I had to fight against boredom. Also monster placement @ UV tends to feel more and more uninspired. As-is: solid 4/5, but no way legendary, as I won't play it again.

This is so much better than the Zdoom stuff Vader eventually went on to make. 5/5

Awesome for chocolate doom coop

THAT'S how you implement difficulty levels without placing hordes of enemies! Here, they are strategially placed throughout the usually small to medium-sized maps. Gameplay is great and the new monsters fit in nicely - wouldn't have needed the new weapon sounds, though. Secret levels are also rewarding since they offer unique design, something often forgotten in megawads. Still great nine years after its release. Recommended! 5/5 - NightFright

This rocks!

this is a true classic. -denizen

Very well done

great great WAD, very impressive for a one-man WAD. I'd put this one in the best 2003 wads and even as an all time classic. Great gameplay, nice looking maps, and coop is just pure fun ! - PerOxyd 5/5

Whoah, simply amazing. Not the best, but it's definitely worth playing, you gets teh *****!

100% perfection. Kinda sucks that some maps will make the game crash out, but I suspect those are VPOs and nothing can be done about them. *****! ~Cson

No. Boring, cramped and sometimes even ugly. Though this author had vastly improved his skills after a while and brought to us mortals some really impressive works, this wad is below average and feels like it was crafted by different man, not that Vader we all know (different nickname is an omen, haha!) 2/5 - Demonologist

one of the best megawads

very good wad, most maps are really good. Only weak point : coop support (not enough ammo and health and map18 is lacking player 2 start)

This is a cracking back-to-basics wad. Love it!

Simple yet beautiful, it's the way Doom should go on. There's some problems with ammunition if you play the maps from pistol start, so I guess author didn't tested them that way. So, 4/5.

Vile Flesh has aged poorly. However, this wad has not.

fuck SOPA! 5/5

Five stars just for the headless zombie alone.

Yet another impressive megawad for Doom II. Once again, great layouts and challenge. 5/5

good stuff! **** -sargebaldy

Awesome oldschool action right here. - 5/5

Nice one. Nice in the same way DOOM feels nice compared to DOOM II when going back. Maybe this feeling is related too some overly complex PWADS Ive seen. Like when makeing music, all things u throw in has to have some sort of function - otherwise its useless.