E1M5: Reincarnated

great!

stealth monsters = teh sux

Stealth monsters ruin everything.

Not as good as the original

Indeed, it is not as good as the original : (

Oh noes he used 3 stealth monsters in teh hole map and now it sux :( Seriously, are they really that bad? I'm not going to hate a map just because there are a couple of stealth monsters. I don't see that many people complaining about that "Point of No Return" map Job made with masses of stealth monsters.

This map just doesn't capture what made the original E1M5 (and the whole of E1) great. Some important points of the original, like the final dark room and the window in the yellow key room are ruined. I'll admit that I loved Simplicity, but that "Spork touch" just doesn't work here. The stealth monsters don't even really bother me. On the other hand, I hated those traps that hold you until everything is dead. Still, it's not a bad map, but as a remake of E1M5, it falls short in every respect.

i swears to god the only angles used in the layout of this entire map are 45 degrees and 90 degrees. can someone please tell the entire doom modding community that this makes for hugely mediocre boring uninteresting levels?? oi, we've seen a million other WADs that look like this one. 1/5

It's not as good as KDIZD because it doesn't have a zillion sectors :'(

Average. 3/5.

I much preferred the e1m5 remake. It's not too hard to add some detail to a map, but it's not good that all the gameplay changes are for the worse. I don't think I need to mention the traps. I'd like to see something more original 3/5

BUG: The switch that lowers the stairs after the yellow door can be pressed multiple times (and the stairs will lower again and again). Still, very good.

Really nice, of course... although I must protest at the use of the hellknights; except for the first battle with them in the pit, every other use of them only proved annoying (a stealth knight... two appearing ones in your face... a drop down to two of them with no way out...). Anyway, I hope to see more of these. -NetNomad

Very nice!

Just as good as the original, however, I do wish you wouldn't use those damned stealth monsters :P