QDOOM - Quake Done DOOM Style

You soundtrack rocks!, this was fun to play.

I was disappointed with this. Perhaps it is an impressive technical feat - the credits are certainly very lengthy. But the (sprite-based) baddies look terrible and pixellated, and they zip around like frantic ants; the soldiers are scaled wrong and seem to tower over the player, and the E1 boss looks ridiculous. The first episode is drab and empty and bland, and although it gets better, the architecture is uniformly browny-greeny-purple . And it's not much fun to play.

Simply awesome, and one of the best mods ever released for EDGE. A must download! 5/5

5/5, lots of work put into this. A little dark in some places. Lots of cool Edge effects.

Seriously, Romero and the boys could have released this instead of Quake (even with the vanilla Doom engine instead of the Edge source port - it is better than 75% of the levels in registered Quake)

excellent, a serious mod that shows you EDGE can hang with the big boys.

whats so great about this? I'll admit, the 3d bridges and water were great. However the levels made my eyes bleed. I didnt feel this captured any of the mood QUAKE made. I couldnt play it because I couldnt see shit. I know quake was a dark game but the darkness in this mod is rediculous. The levels werent even reminiscent of QUAKE, other than the weapons and HUD. Im not saying I could do any better, my mapping sucks horribbly, but I know this is crap.

I love this Quake wad. it's the best one I've ever played. 5/5.