Xenus:Lost base

"Release date: I don't remember"... You made it on August 05, 2006. At least, you sent it to me at that date. You was making the second map. Then... Nothing! I vote 5* to compensate, because this map deserve to have 3* The design is well done, the playability is correct. Simple, efficient for a first map and, more importantly, for a 1024 map !!!

Maybe, it's already a bad sign when you're thinking you've played this map before while you're knowing for sure that you haven't. The fights are so simple that you don't even care that most of the time you're limited to your pistol. Detail is non-existant and the layout is blocky and primitive. The only interesting scene is the final battle, when suddenly you're confronted with a Baron of Hell in a narrow room and your shotgun only. Meh. 1.5/5 -Milian

I forgot you need zdoom to play this wad because of one place with texture&flat mixing!

Bland and boring, not really worth playing, but just manages to miss the "this sucks" category IMO. 2/5

This is a cute little map that doesn't take long to play. The design is clean and simple. For most players it will be too simple; apart from a Baron of Hell the toughest monsters are imps. The ammo is measured precisely so that you get a bunch of shells just before a fight, and as a consequence it seems a little child-like. It could be improved by giving the player the berzerk pack and nothing else, but even then it wouldn't be too tricky.

its ok: grey themed, needs a better monster variation, not for prdoom 2.5/5 off topic - ah - I think that the above reviewer made a lot of reviews in the recent past which are quite good - you should do some as a guest reviewer for doomworld - just my thoughts

very bad

Monster placement is predictable and light. The layout is clean and simple with no surprises and is fairly short. Pleasant but quick and a little too easy. 3/5 -jb

buggy and awful 0/5

It's the worst 1024 map I've ever seen.

Simple but solid stuff. Lots of pistol work with formes. Little flaw: Too short.