Phocas Island 2

When I played this, I was tense, and I thank the awesome music for that. The music and the lack of the nmber of enemies (on easy) made me jump so many times. It's actualy a pretty scary game if you're in the right mind. And this was done with levels that had blue skies if you know what I mean. Story could have used more journal entries for more depth. It could have used more variety in types of areas. On the map it looked like I would eventually be exploring a volcano, but it was something else.Inspring

A Doom masterpiece. Definitely takes you back to the era of point-and-click adventure games, but this time it's not point-and-click; it's in first person. 5/5 stars.

wonderful

Even though I may not be patient enough for a wad like this, I did try to get as far as I could. I kept playing for days to find out how to beat it even with the walkthough, which was no help at all because it only loosely described things. It kind of reminds of those old video games where there is no possible way to beat it. Besides, the endings I hear about would destroy any feeling of accomplishment.

Pretty good, I think the idea is worthwhile and your implementation was mostly excellent. Unfortunately I encountered a bug in the GLOAM map where all the ambient sounds start playing simulanteously at full volume; it disappears when you leave the map, but persists when you return to the map, or even restore from a save point if you made the mistake of saving when the ambient sound problem occurs. Restarting and playing with options menu didn't help.

Reminds me of Hexen II mixed with Lost. 4/5

Painful painful painful. Clearly a lot of effort and innovation has gone into this wad, but those two things do not a fun time make. The gameplay is boring as all hell, and the combat is an exercise in frustration with no supplies to back you up. I realise it's not Doom, but that's not an excuse to make a dull boring "Guess the next gimmick to advance" fest.

This is just a fucking hunk of unplayable crap. This was not made in Doom spirit. Doom is a FPS, is not a fucking RPG. 0/5

The Myst of Doom WADs. Whether you consider this a good or bad thing is up to taste. You have to admire it for what it achieves, though.

Architechture Masterpeice ^_^

Legendary. Just like this vote. Everyone who gives it lower than a 3 problably doesn't know the difference between a good and a bad wad. - T.U.A

WOW!~ Definantly a very wel;l build map. Good storyline, and very challenging puzzle gameplay. One of the best constucted map i've seen in a while. 5/5 -r_rr.

this is in my top5 favorite wads. i love everything about it. great design, great music, great story, etc. ***** -lag

one of the greatest wads ever made.5/5-mohaa555

Looks good but can be pretty damned boring, like most adventure games.

"First off, this mod isn't doom. So don't expect it to play like doom." 4/5 for the wad and +1 star for the downvoting by that guy. :)

This is definitely not doom, however this doesn't mean that this wad is 'bad'. With its unique theme, great scripting, and compelling gameplay, I highly recommend playing this wad so you may find out yourself.

OMG!!!!!!11 YOSHI'S ISLAND LIKE TITLE SCREEN!!! 5/5 - GhostlyDeath

For me, the best wad of 06. Loved it. 5/5

This damn thing needs a walk through. Awesome wad though 5/5 --Captain Red

The wad is pretty darn good, but if there were any needed changes, i'd say it needs new music. What is up with the dark, creepy music anyway? tropical islands aren't supposed to be dark and scary! Besides that, once you consume 5 hours of your life playing it, the ending is lame. But all in all, a very good wad. 4/5 Oh, and F.Y.I. to the guy who said the rock formations need more slopes: You can't put slopes over water in GZdoom for some reason.

huge non linear gameplay, with lots of puzzles, had great fun wandering and exploring the world in this game.

Beautiful WAD...simply beautiful. It's one of the most attractive Doom WADs I've ever seen, and the use of ambient sounds instead of music really amps up the atmosphere. However, it's really just "beauty over brains." The gameplay is ridiculously confusing, and I found myself lost not even half-way through. There's no...linear structure to the gameplay; it just feels like a jumbled mess. So, you really feel like you're just wandering around, hoping to get lucky. 2/5

Pretty adventure wad. I prefer Junko, but 5/5

I enjoyed this. It reminded me of the old dinosaur game Trespasser, or the first Tomb Raider game, or Indiana Jones and the Infernal Machine, or one of those old graphic text adventures. I can envisage an alternative world where someone licensed the Doom engine in 1994 and made this instead of (for example) Chex Quest. It's a bit slow-paced although in the light of Hellcore 2.0 it doesn't seem so bad in this respect. Someone hire this man now.