I Give Up On Trying to Map 1

Looks very good, better than what I would do.

Excellent map! I haven't played something this good in a while! Love the style and the architectual detail! 5/5 - Kirby

This is a nice, short map. It's done in an E1 style, although it has Doom 2 monsters, and the detail is up to modern standards. The only problem is that, after playing's this week's Cheogsh, it seems very simple and easy in comparison; you have loads of health (the soul sphere is silly) and plenty of ammo, and the "boss monster" is a single baron of hell. There are some mancubuses but they are behind doors, so you can dodge 'em easy.

It's not that great. 3/5

You say you are giving up on trying to map? This thing is better than most of the stuff we see here. Make another! Please!

looks very good and plays well 4/5

Your average "Simplicity: Because Complexity Sucks" wannabe, complete with symmetry, crampedness, linearity and overdetailing (luckily, mostly on the ceiling). It's just a series of small rooms connected with doors and most fights are uninteresting. Mehhhhhhh.

not bad, rounded up to 4*

Damn man, I wish I could map in that feel.

Not legendary, but still... 5/5

You should make more maps. But try to stray away from making a detailed box and then connect it to another detailed box. Make larger areas, you have potential.

Really Nice. Not a classic but still 4/5 -Stalker George

Well, no wonder you gave up on trying to map... this is overdetailed. If you want to make something really pretty then map with the doom 3 engine. Otherwise you're not showcasing your creativity as a map designer. Also, this was way too easy (finishing with 160 cells and 190 health is pretty tame, don't you think?)

Mega, you've got a nice wad there. 5/5 -ymb

Damn good. -Macro11_1

Loved the look, gameplay was fun. Was a tad tight space-wise and would've loved this map to be longer. Even so, I enjoyed it very much. 4/5

Sweet little map. 5/5

Unplayable in vanilla, due to visplane overflow in starting room (grab chainsaw, turn around...) and also when going through the first door.

To play this in vanilla, one needs to rename FF_END to F_END and use Doom-plus (at the PrBoom-plus site). This level is not entirely bad but I think its cramped architecture is not very good looking and ruins play (which is arguably easy, as someone noted above.) Too much clutter and too much junk detailing to walk over. At least the guy could sense he wasn't doing something great, unlike some people commenting. [2/5] ~Chain Mail (07/2011)

Limit-removing maps go in Ports. How many times I gotta repeat this? Now go sit in the corner and make more maps, nobody is allowed to quit Doom...