1 Monster Megawad

Map 5 music is horrible.

What a stupid idea. The community needs to stop wasting time with retarded ideas like this.

No varity is a good thing

I likeed the short maps like 01, 03... and more. 3.5/5

Fighting hundreds of the same monster is a chore. Most levels are boring.

Great concept, and very enjoyable to play. It's not perfect though, and is let down somewhat by some of the stupidly oversized maps (MAP17 and MAP19 made me want to murder someone for the absolutely hideous repetition and time taken -- they look great and have some very memorable designs, but at that size they are 100% wasted on a gimmick WAD no matter what). However, generally speaking it's very well-made and great fun. MAP15: Spookhouse is an excellent example. A strong 4/5 for 1Monster.

The semi-HR style Map19 alone (Cacophony) is worth waiting to play through the rest of this megawad. I didn't like the hitscanner maps that much though (ugh, ~310 Chaingunners), but the rest of it was pretty good, had no trouble with health and ammo for the most part. The concept works pretty good in most of the maps, which is why this wad gets 4 stars and a reccommended play out of me.

Good maps but the concept gets old. 4/5

So cool !

The Concept seems simple a monotonous. But the maps quality makes it a very good megawad though the restriction. Map 22 with only three monsters is a masterpiece. 4/5

the game can be broken on map04. by that it means I can get to a point where I got stuck in an area of the map and was unable to get out of it without using ways which the original doom games were not meant to. the only way to get out of that area was to strafe-run... and since strafe-running wasn't an intended design of the game, i had to deduct some points. Some of the musics were horrible, and i got bored sooner than expected. I didn't enjoy this.

This had some good ideas that were stifled by the rule of the wad. This proves that these dumbshit themed projects keep great maps from ever being actually great. Best played with a monster randomizer, or not played at all. Map14 is obviously the best one in the set, it's got Holy Smoke as the background music after all.

A lot of fun to play through

lvl 1 and 2 are great but lvl 4 and 5 i cant complete. best Doom to run it under?

Actually pretty cool given the concept. I'm gonna go with a safe 3/5 here. --Ceeb

It works with Boom, ZDoom, and I think Skulltag but I am not sure. Good set but some maps were kinda annoying.

The levels were good, but they were completely ruined by this 1 monsters concept. 3/5

4/5 For the most part, I enjoyed it, but there were a couple of maps which just really sucked, such as map04 (What kind of idiot makes 95% of his map a series of hall ways that are 64 units wide anyway?)

THE community project released in 07. Or maybe it's the only one? Bleh, it's great anyway so don't give a damn about my semantics and play this instead.

I didn't like it at all. I thought the maps were goinng to be short and creative, not long and repetitive. Oh well.

Excellent. Map 11-14 are my favourite ones. 5/5 -Glassyman

1 Monster type for each map gave this wad zero stars. Why can't you people just make NORMAL maps anymore?

Its adequate.

This, as a set of regularly populated levels, had so much potential. Which incidentally was wasted on the rigid theme of the project. Hell, you could have preserved the general theme and made the maps more fun by changing the rule to the main monster takes up 50% or more of the monsters while at the same time allowing some other monsters to spice it up. This should be remade (or at least repurposed since the maps are architecturally sound in and of themselves).

I love this!!! I liked the Demon map, the Cacodemon map, the first imp map, the chaingunner maps and several other ones. 5/5 - Optimus