Eclipse

An admirable exercise in good level design. Some areas are overpopulated, but the rest is good.

Good old-style mapset. If you can get into it it's pretty easy to play large portions at once. Repetition may be an issue for some but I enjoyed it anyway. And I actually liked the later maps the best. Map07 and 09 were frustrating because thing placement needed lots of prior knowledge.

nice Doom1 style map set! - 5/5 - Arch

Some levels are worth 3/5 stars and some only 2/5. That is why I give 2,5/5... I'm not the old-school fan :-P ! Also: there are much better megawads out there...

Unremarkable, really. Most of this could have been pulled off in vanilla. The only ZDoom features really used are MAPINFO and hi-res titlepics. The architecture is very boxy and uninspiring, and E1 had more detail than this. The gameplay is decent but really only average.

^ An unremarkable fairly average review.

Missing textures in map15 (behind the start door) and map19 (several places); major bugs in map17. Otherwise, quite nice, especially map01 to map06. :) 4/5

Reviewer #1, your an arse! The author said it was 100% oldschool or can you not read? Deadwing, this is very good indeed. Some nice battles and plenty of in-fighting spots (I like watching them bash eachother :) if you feel the need to conserve what I though had too much ammo (played UV -fast). The levels flow well to. Nice work and well worth the download. 4.5/5

When I played this mini TC, this did have that old school feel :P Nice set of maps. I will give this a 4/5!-Candle M

Actually, this was pretty average. I haven't found any ZDoom features at all in this wad. The gameplay was'nt all perfect, but also not bad at all. Ehh, 3/5. - Moti

the doom1 seting was refreshing but the levels were far too easy for me 2/5

A cool oldschool maps at all. 4/5 - playerlin

Not bad. Some of the maps are a bit bland, but it's supposed to be in the old-school-style so I'll forgive the author. 4/5