Marble Halls

I can see if u find it not very good compared to today's standards but its only my second map and i hope i will get better. /author

Not going to lie it was a bit bland, if you put some hight variation in there and spent a little more time detailing it would have been a lot more impressive- 2/5 Stephen Whittaker

Previous reviewer scored 1/5. Seems he's not having a good day as again he slated an albeit borderline average wad (see id=15474) instead of giving some encouragement or positive criticism. Nothing special here I agree. Haphazard style but with some tough battles, which I like. Keep trying Daniel. 3/5

Well, you lot need to remember that detailing heavily on maps can be counter-productive. To use an example, I think Doom 2 has better gameplay than Doom 3 (and there are MANY things I can point to), but of course Doom 3 is better detailed, more atmospheric, and took !much! longer to make. So which is better? The point is I gladly welcome the retro-styled mapping approach. I think visually speaking the author should strive for more consistency.

it's not pretty but the gameplay is fairly good.narrow pathways in the cavern spice it up a bit and I left a couple of mancubi in the lava pit. I 'll take gameplay over looks any day.4/5-d.d.koop

Bland, boring, not fun. I know this is just the authors second map, but this is still bad. 2/5 stars.

Not a bad wad for a second attempt, this did had that old school 1994 map feel to it, but overall it was simple to play with a few tough battles thrown in. 3/5.-Candle M

It definitely isn't horrible, but there's room for plenty of improvement as well. 3/5