CHALLENJ.WAD

Nothing special, but I liked it. 3/5

This is a very basic wad. I can tell you are new at creating wads, and it's not terrible; however, it feels way too rushed. Besides that, it's very boring. Long rooms, a few monsters, and oh, "secrets" that aren't very secret. As for the Star Wars theme... yeah... not seeing it. 3/5

I enjoyed it no matter it's preety basic. 3/5 - Optimus

Hey I just played your map, got to get you on a doom builder makes it so much easer to align texture. I liked the layout and gameplay a lot, visually it was a little lacking but overall it was interesting. I really liked the big open area with the lava bottom and all the cacodeamons. Gave it a 3/5 By the way I'm assuming from you email you go to michigan tech, if thats true hit me up my email is sdwhitta@mtu.edu Stephen Whittaker.

This is a large but bare STARTAN reactor techbase from May 1994. It was recently remade as id=15514, which is far far better. The level starts off almost totally undetailed, but gets slicker as it goes on; the author was obviously learning on the job. By the last quarter it reaches a level of below-averageness, although the final battle comes out of nowhere and is rubbish. Overall I have played much worse, but without the remake I would have ignored this.

While playing this catalogue of errors, I wondered if this was actually a 1994 map, or just an idiot builder. I was right, it's 1994 typical crap. 2/5

^ I agree whole-heartedly; raced through this after playing NJ's remake(id=15514).