Jump to content
Search In
  • More options...
Find results that contain...
Find results in...
  • NOTE: There is a known issue with the most recent entries having screwed-up information and links. Some databases are out of sync and we haven't been able to fix it yet.

Imperfection Has Its Charms

   (18 reviews)
Sign in to follow this  

Guest

4 Screenshots

About This File

Since I am waiting on a few people before the Speed of Doom megawad project can be continued any further, I've decided to spend my time dusting off my old maps. The mapset used to be for zdoom, now it is playable on any limit-removing port with the Plutonia Iwad. These are very very early maps of mine, including my first map which is on map03. I fixed it to make it more compatible with most ports, made it more playable and fun, added shortcuts here and there. The design is very old school, and occasionally primitive, hence the title 'Imperfection has its charms.' Some of you may recognise the designs of several maps or played them before. Partial layouts of Map02 and Map07 is remade in Speed of Doom. A spruced up version of Map04 occupies the Map13 slot in NewDoom Community Project 2. There is no difficulty settings unfortunately, I would consider these maps to be challenging and not exactly for the faint of hearts. Enjoy!


User Feedback

Create an account or sign in to leave a review

You need to be a member in order to leave a review

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Guest

  
Played this with BrutalDoomv2.0.It was a lot more fun that way,but the maps them selves were cool as well.

Share this review


Link to review
Guest

  
It is NOT playable with ANY limit removing port. Just level one had inoperable switches and bridges that can't be walked under.

Share this review


Link to review
Guest

  
Pretty good, if a bit flawed. Worth playing if you're a fan of Joshy's mapping style, but his later works in Speed of Doom and Resurgence are more impressive.

Share this review


Link to review
Guest

Unknown date

  
The first six maps aren't bad at all, maybe 3-3.5 star quality, but I'm giving this 5 stars because I just loved the final three. From a good challenge to basic yet sufficient architecture, those maps really showed the meat of what oldschool dooming was about to me. Map08 at times even reminded me of the midsection of AV, and Map09 was a good ending. That being said, the only map I didn't like at all in the whole set was 05; it was too dark. Good work, can't wait for SOD!

Share this review


Link to review
Guest

Unknown date

  
That was awesome! 5/5

Share this review


Link to review
Guest

Unknown date

  
note: actually it's a "boom-compatible" wad. no just "limit-removing"! (so it's unplayable in doom+ or jdoom). and I found here nothing "oldschool" - it looks and plays like all these common shitty maps from various community projects. meh.

Share this review


Link to review
Guest

Unknown date

  
Grand!

Share this review


Link to review
Guest

Unknown date

  
This mapset feels oldschool... In both qualities and flaws, unfortunately. Many maps are cramped, too dark, involve pointless switchhunting and backtracking without any new monsters to fight or changes in the architecture. Note quality vary a lot between different maps so it's worth checking them all if you like classic doom gameplay. 3/5

Share this review


Link to review
Guest

Unknown date

  
map design, difficult is as good as plutonia. but I found elevator error in map 04. it is not lifted.

Share this review


Link to review
Guest

Unknown date

  
Very old school and fun. Good stuff. 4/5

Share this review


Link to review
Guest

Unknown date

  
looks like ass plays like dicks

Share this review


Link to review
  • File Reviews

    • By P41R47 · Posted
      I struggle to replay this one for a long time. I didn't remember much of this so its was like a first time. Strain is a different beast to anything from the same time. It uses dehacked to great extents adding new enemies and changing the behaviour of some of the weapons.
      Well, first episode is pretty solid, with neat maps and really awesome ideas as the authors of the wad start to unfold their dehacked trickery all around. Second episode its not that good, with some cryptic maps with not so clear progression, but well overall.
      Third episode has some maps like the second, but they are a little more fleshed out and with a lot better visuals also. The end map was somewhat anticlimatic, but anyway, a really great experience through and through.

      Now what i don't liked much is that most ports have to use the Strain Fix to properly been able to play this mapset, and the authors of that fix, don't know why, changed the sky textures of the different episodes.
      Its nothing really bad, but well, it strange that they didn't respected the authors original choice.

      Dystopya 3 maps really stands out from the mapset, or maybe i remember them more as i have fresh memories from a recent replay.   The mood of the megawad is greatly achieved through the use of neat textures and map tricks. I really miss that there are no fake 3D bridges anywhere in the megawad, and i really love them when they are given good use.   The story of is somewhat mixed bag: theres a new invasion, you are the only marine that survived to the Invasion of earth, and they government made some experiments with you. Now you are a bloodthirsty machine that only wants the destruction of the invaders.
      The text screens during game are strange, with a snarky humor and poking fun of some common tropes. Not bad, but i would prefer something more serious as the megawad has really cool details everywhere, like revisiting zones and fully developed reactor areas, etc. making the storytelling side of the maps really awesome to follow. But again, some maps has poor progression hindering the experience a little.   Anyway, this is something that needs to be played and replayed, just to see those dehacked tricks and for theose awesome good maps. I had better memories of this than what i actually play, so i was expecting something more and better, but thats my problem, the megawad is amazing as it is.
    • By vdgg · Posted
      This mapper did create good stuff, pazuzu, diabolos and odyssey. This is way, way below these WADs. I am the first reviewer to mention massive (but massive) HOMs on MAP10! 2 stars for: - awesome grey blocks area in motion in the middle of MAP08 - some occasional decent moments, I guess MAP03 is fine, MAP04 is okayish. - visually it is not bad for 1996. But come on. One motif is: "press switch A to lower a lift, press switch B that opens a door somewhere far, but press it a bit later, just to get in time to the lift, not too early as the door will shut". After that door you often have a wall of monsters, so sometimes you retreat and repeat. This motif is used over and over and over again. You also experience cramped mazy hallways quite a lot and lots of damaging floors. Some of these damaging floors are used for extra spice during combat, but most of them are there to make you think faster about the puzzle solution :) It is not easy for me to pick the worst map, MAP05, 07 and 09 set the bar quite high. And it is me who is writing this, I enjoy cleim20, odessas, some cryptic stuff, but I just can't stand >80% of this creation.
    • By chlef · Posted
      Not the prettiest maps, but very nice to play. Old school goodness.  
    • By chlef · Posted
      Yeah, this is what Doom is supposed to be. Basic and enjoyable, no gimmicks or stupid sound/graphic mods. Just pure Doom. This is a keeper.
    • By Never_Again · Posted
      Another day, another stolen map.   E2M1 of IMMLEV is a ripoff of ARENA, a tutorial WAD David Bruni designed and wrote detailed tutorials for in the 3D Alchemy book. Walbert's edit of it was so incompetent that four times out of five it will crash vanilla seconds into the level with a "P_CrossSubsector" error. Crispy and prboom-plus crash every time.   Oddly enough, Choco loads the map without complaints but you get stuck early on due to the "author" apparently using a paper bag over the head as a map-editing tool.   The second map is largely a barebones crate maze. A secret door next to the first key leads to an unmarked exit that dumps you on the stock secret level. Too bad, as the third level finally shows a glimpse of promise, albeit somewhat marred by HOM and mislabeled key doors. This, too, is apt to an abrupt end with another unmarked exit switch.
×