F_Episode 2

Fun and challenging E2 replacement. Good gameplay that get's better with each level. Sure it's nothing new, but who cares if the record's not broke...

E2 clone #1234567. As such, copying the architectural style as well as the gameplay was done well. But does it have additional value? IMHO: about near zero. No new architecture, decoration, traps, or even better adventure feeling / gameplay. So overall, considered as a playable mapset, this is (again imho) completely overhyped, and 5* legendary is ridiculous, compared with other maps. 3* mostly because of the effort of a mapset not worth a replay.

I'm not sure what the hype is all about. This felt almost like speed-mapping to me. The visuals are subordinate to Ultimate Doom, the layouts are boring, the game play is repetitive, and there is far too much ammo. My biggest complaint is the Z-axis being almost non-existent (everything is on a flat-plane), and there are barely any exteriors or large open areas. It almost feels like randomly generated rooms with monsters and dull traps added. Nothing like UD at all.

Great WAD! love it

Very good E2 style with only a limited amount of true homages. Definitely less than Deja Vu or Slight Return. Almost seems like a rough copy of some maps that could have been in DTWID, though they are probably just short of being *that* authentic in style. But it's on par with stuff like NMD Episode 2, etc. With that said I easily recommend it.

good

Doom1 is boring, but 5 stars.

nice E2 repalcement - worth playing

great wad man!

Nice wad for DooM 1 episode. nothing to say more. 4.5/5 -playerlin

Good stuff

nicely done 4/5

Very nice E1/E2-style episode. Has at least two points where you can get stuck without jumping (invisibility secret in E2M2 and caco trap in the sludge area in E2M5). E2M8 is underwhelming, but the rest of this won't disappoint. 4/5

Really fuckin' good. 4/5 - DoomGeek101

Really easy. UV felt like hey not too rough.

well very nice