The Great Urban Battle

Cool map. Staring in a subway before you enter the city. I have no idea why it was slammed so heavily at idgames and ensured pcorf wouid never make another city map again. Cool Doomcute traffic lights, lots of little secrets and generally fun to explore. Great how a map with high enemy count like this exists without being slaughtery. Navigation is probably slightly cumbersome, but this was lots of fun. 9.2/10

I don't see this wad is bad at all, I have fun and actually found the secret #12345 linedef and go to the secret level. The final battle on normal exit just a little annoying since I hate those imps on higher positions, when I try to fight Cyberdemon and have to dodge their shitty fireballs. Overall, I think it can be 5/5, but the final battle just ruined it a little. :P 4.5/5 -playerlin

This is a huge and epic map for Doom 2... i don't found a key that opens the last section so i had to cheat a little... anyway is a pretty cool map. I don't get the hate for this.

Pretty cool, but the addition of an underground cavern and castle after the city seemed unmotivated. The secret level also wasn't exactly superb, and could've been placed on MAP31 to allow non-ZDoom ports to play it, but still, all in all, it's pretty good. 4/5 - ZZ

Not very original, no spectacular scenery, and no wonderful adventures. However, gameplay is solid for this huge map and gave a lot of fun, so 4/5.

Come on, it deserves more 4 than 3 stars.

Solid map, looks nice with neat little added extras throw in, music is decent. Whilst not being speedrun friendly, it's a good adventure. 4 stars

Not a bad wad, but also not a good wad. The Blade Runner 'rip-off' music made me want to kill someone! 1/5

5/5 stars. It's alright I guess, pretty boring though.

I was kind of disappointed. The map's layout reminded me of Plutonia's "Oddessy of Noises", but in a bad way. It's very easy to get lost. Monster placement seemed more dense than logical, and trying to hunt down every straggling zombieman felt like a chore at times (lest they shoot ye in the arse later!). The music was probably the only thing I liked. Still a big P.C. fan though! 2/5 -Aenima

This is cool, this is really cool. ~5/5

I like this very,very much!More like this,please?

I thoroughly enjoyed this map, some great battles and chaos going on and loads to explore. Cool secrets too. Definitely worthy of 4 stars

I thought the map was quite good-looking in an old-school way. The gameplay was a bit bland but the layout does give you clues about where to go next. About 2 minutes in, the music sounds like a poor man's porn track. I was haunted by visions of a young Ross from friends giving it to an equally unattractive young Phoebe.

Epic! But a bit too big. 4.5/5 - Optimus

I don't usually go for big cityscape maps, but this one was done quite well.

This is boring Paul, make another New Adventure. 2/5

This is a must have for everyone's Doom 2 wad collection. 5/5

Meh, too hectic and haphazard. Just feels random and half finished.

^ Sorry guys. But to be honest I am hopeless at the gameplay and enemy placement and not many people were even interested in doing the play testing. Sorry for disappointing you guys. No more city maps from me again. - P

Map's quite fun.

This is a very good map! I played it a few times. Plays well!! Game play is what you could expect in a city. You can be hit from anywhere so you have to stay alert! It's an epoch battle!! So don't start it unless you have about an hour & a half on your hands. This is one I rate at 9 out of 10. The only draw back is the very ending seems quite anti-climatic.