Extreme Weapon Pack

I'm giving it three stars, because if nothing else, you have to admire the sprite work that went into it.  Also the weapons effects - the way the super shotgun spins you around, the way the BFG powers up, complete with animation, and the hairbrained projectiles that come out of it.

But...

Playing with the mod dulls pretty swiftly.  The game is virtually unplayable in any real sense with it.  Unless god-mode and the weapons cheat are used, in which case, it becomes a testament to eye-rolling and not snickering.  Continued play starts to build toward a sense of frustration.

At first, it is funny, though.  The broken nail when punching, the OCD care of the pistol especially, lend themselves to a sense of irony, one no doubt the developer aspired to convey.  But they're also like a bad circus act; after you've seen them once, they grow quickly stale with further viewings.

It is a novel mod, but one whose novelty runs very thin very quickly.

While a lot of laughs were had with this silly weapons mod, the joke dies off pretty quick once you used all the weapons that are available, most likely through cheating as playing this legitimately isn't the most fun thing you can do. While you can go and make a bet with your friends on how far you can go in a WAD, official or not, there isn't much of a reason to continue playing this mod beyond the novelty of being a joke mod. The OP poopy toothbrush can only go so far without things getting dull.