E2MWalter

Not quite legendary, but very, very good.

I have to agree with the above reviewer, this seems to be an overlooked modern day classic. An incredible map!

I'm surprised this wasn't mentioned for a 2014 Cacoward - got to be the best single map of the year for The Ultimate Doom!

a wonderful gift

Pretty good

great job!

Legendary. After a couple of minutes I stopped being on edge in fear of crass texturing and lighting errors and began to relax and enjoy myself. The weird thing is that anyone could make a map like this is they weren't unimaginative, talentless, tasteless, careless or malicious. I didn't miss the Doom 2 monsters or weapons at all. I'm only sad because this is probably the best Doom 1 map I'll ever play. Certainly better than most of Id Software's.

not bad for a wad that was made in 17 hours,good job

Pretty damn good!

Classic "The Shores of Hell" mapping at it's finest!

Remarkably nice birthday present! I didn't miss the DooM 2 monsters at all, so James showed the importance of proper gameplay. Absolutely worth a play.

Good, classic shit.