Doomworld Mega Project 2013

Quality is much lower than the 2012 edition.  There are lots of jokewads or poorly balanced levels (missing ammo or health).  A couple of maps were interesting as mentioned by a previous reviewer.

Maps of interest: 9, 14, 15, 21 in the limit-removing pack; 8, 10 in the Boom pack; none in the ZDoom pack.

I thought most of it was good I cant wait for the 2015 project.

Total Crap I have to say Sorry, The Levels are (Almost) all slaughterfests even the first level I Now the 2012 was also like this but too much but Still Original 1/5

and this is why i have very low faith for modern mapsets. yes i made one (MAP03 of the limit-removing set) but looking at everything, i see, cool maps, okay maps, too ambitious maps, and joke maps. Limit-removing set was okay except for MAP18's horrible flow. Boom set was absolute shit after MAP03 and before MAP08. and the ZDoom set was just ridiculously over-the-top fucked up.

Not all the maps were good. But because I that the most of the maps made by new builders I gave 5/5.

I give this 4 out of 5 stars. It certainly is not perfect; there are a few clunkers (mainly uninteresting "joke" levels, 'meh' levels, and so forth.) HOWEVER, there are a lot of real treasures (such as the maps from: Matt534dog, Obsidian, The_Trigger, Netherstorm, and MrtheJoshmon, among others. Not all of the joke levels are bad, either. Take Kate Stone's, for example. I will warn that the last level is very, VERY R-rated.

I like this wad 5/5

good design but not enough armo

Most of the maps are not so good, but there are gems here and there. Generally they are the maps by the more well-known authors (although some decided to make joke maps). I think the ZDoom wad has the fewest good maps (and I'm sorry to say, Map01 is a total chore), although The Trigger's map is pretty good, as is Eradrop's assuming it's the bug fixed version. It's a big download, and not a huge number of good levels, but I wouldn't call it a complete waste, either - there is some cherry picking to do.

A big shit. The level design is not. beletszünk to hell in a million bars. No idea, no interest. IDDQD, and go. Zero.

There's always a pleasure to contribute to it. Also, the idea itself guarantees 5* for me. - Katamori

Cool and stuff, not all the maps were good. Yeah...

FOA: respect for the effort. Having said that, modern mapsets tend to prioritize monster count far above subtlety. IOW: obviously a map can be made harder by putting in more monsters, but that does not automatically make gameplay more attractive. IMHO usually the opposite happens. Also with these maps: again IMHO a few are good, but most of the maps have gameplay which simply do not give any fun, so overall 2/5. BTW please, PLEASE don't give your own maps 5*, it's foul play and misleading.