Incineration

Pretty damn good Hell episode for Doom. Difficulty is kind of all over the place though, no real progression of it, but maybe that wasn't the intention.

Maps I liked: E3M2(shorter more fun Erebus tribute), E3M3(Pandemonium tribute, good gameplay), E3M5(good gameplay, a bit too easy with bfg though), E3M7(good gameplay, has the best fights in it, although I'd have put less shotgun/baron fights in it) and E3M6(it's way too easy if you like to hunt down secrets). E3M1 was kind of weird, not really memorable. E3M4 was kind of hard, but in a bad way, loads of places to get stuck on, while the cacos munch your face off, I just might have been unlucky though. E3M9 - I suppose it's a mix of styles, did not like the ending though, too overdone. E3M8 - Kind of meh, not very memorable. Overall these maps are definitely worth the play, had fun. 4/5 stars.

Excellent 5/5

Map design and gameplay walk the satisfying line between oldschool and source port, modern style, with nothing looking out of place compared to id's original classic but with far more challenging monster ambushes and traps than ever devised by the original team - although never too difficult as I didn't die more than a few times on skill four. In summation, if you like your Doom classic styled, rather than too modern, then this is a can't miss.

fun to play

A live proof that it's possible to create a decent, classic Doom 1 WAD that doesn't feel tedious. Good, fast paced action and simple but not bad visuals.

-4

Fun e3 replacement. Fast gameplay and a decent mix of linear and nonlinear maps. Neither too easy nor frustrating.

Very good episode replacement. Authentic feel ultimate doom

Pcorf maps = Sexual explosion

Generally a good set of maps - but, again, ruined by throwing lost souls at you at every turn. Why do people insist on doing this? Makes an enjoyable experience highly annoying.

Great stuff as usual from Paul. 5*****

Just finished playing this and it is outstanding! It looks like an original E3 from id, real nostalgic feel to it. Combat was fun and never got stale. Lots of monsters and Romero style monster waves from previously explored areas that you have to return to. High replay value like the original iwads.

I liked this. Good D1 mapset. Many unusual texture combinations, "classic" looking, while not ugly. Gameplay mostly flows well, and there's an enjoyable exploration factor. 5/5

Pure gold. - Katamori

Great mapset except E3M8. That was rather meh. If you're looking for some vanilla action that should be an obvious choice.

A very good E3 replacement. The difficulty is in a good place, not to hard but not to easy. Lots of good traps and the city maps are really good too. I give this a 5/5

A very fun mapset with strong E3 overtones. Not too difficult, not overly difficult. Gameplay was quite good and the aesthetics of the maps gave a late 90s/early 2000s feeling.