Mutiny (A Doomworld Community Project)

Just finished this wad, and I give it 2 stars for the following reasons:

Pos:

* Difficult. It presents a very decent challenge that I really enjoyed.

* Beautiful. Industrial, Dark Tech, Grim environment. A bit a dark, but I loved it.

Neg:

* Sniper-based: 50% of its challenge stems from snipers (hit and non-hitscanners) and their placement in the map, sometimes at the opposite end of the map in a very dark corner. In 2 or 3 maps, it's ok, but when it's in every map it changes from challenging to annoying.

* Although beautiful as mentioned before, it still feels repetitive. Not a lot of variety between the maps. And I don't mean variety in texture, but in setting/feel, etc.

I enjoy and have no problems to play these high-quality maps on UV+fast.

The maps I didn't enjoy were only because of personal taste. This really is a quality set of 16 maps that any self respecting Doom player should consider buckling down and handling the higher difficulty curve. Excellence demands proper respect.

High quality mapset. Well deserved.

Beautifully crafted mapset for the most part, but the combat never quite warms up (until the last map, that is. Wish they had thrown in a few more like that). Difficulty comes mostly from scarcity of resources rather than the intensity of fights, and map layout can be sometimes confusing, which can make the game stall at times

Superb mapset by a lot of great mappers. Highly recommended.

Pretty good tbh. Cool custom assets and some interesting maps. Difficulty kind of jumps around but that's frequently the case with community projects. 3/5

The resource set itself cries for a 5* rating, but the maps are not disappointing either. Absolute masterpiece.

well-made, pretty hard maps overall. glad to have seen this all the way through now.

Excellent community project with high quality maps and strong theme cohesion. It has a rusty look and lots of darkness and follows a semi-realistic approach. Maps are well detailed and layouts are logical. Difficulty is high but usually fair - it's good for survival coop. Another great WAD this year.