DoomGuy Gets a Puppy

Despite working alongside Billy for a few years now, and being a big fan of what he does, I hadn't gotten around to checking this out. Turns out I was doing myself a disservice! This is a lot of fun to explore, with many twists and turns, and some pretty intricate secrets. A very strong start for him, but I can see where he's grown since. In particular, the progression and distribution of weapons can lead first-time players to be quite underpowered for a long time, depending on where they go first, and my initial playing experience suffered as a result. Likewise, the way secrets are woven through the map and partially limited based on progression makes for a great story telling device, but does rather impede your chance to experience everything if you don't know when things are available and what will stop them being so.

Saying all of that, the game play is generally solid, the additional textures, artwork and music choices are all on point and the level looks very nice, so I'm more knocking a star off because of the open-ended progression not working out perfectly for me on my play through, than anything else. Well, that and I know he's gone on to bigger and better things, of course! Great stuff, highly recommended.

Really good, but that blue skull secret...  It kinda ruined what I was doing.  

420/10

I have known a happiness that I haven't known since I adopted my pitbull simply from seeing that good boi

One of the most interesting and fun maps I have ever played. I definitely recommend it! 5/5!

I ran across this randomly and I was not disappointed. 5/5 for heckin' good bois

I remember playing this months back and it's still a fantastic level to me, an easy Cacoward contender if you ask me! It's nice to see a creative level with a small but nice joke that works out in the end. There's also a surprise at the end that wraps up the level very nicely. The level is open and challenging enough to keep things interesting, especially some of the secrets if you can find them. Great level and worth playing!

Fantastic original concept housed in a nice looking, fun to play map. Great stuff, the kind of creativity we need to see more of.

Really really cool!At first i thought the puppy was going to be the mbf helper dog but what you came up with is much better.

it was pretty great, but when I acquired the puppy, it became 5 star material.

Surprisingly neat and intricate level. There were some really nice setpieces, with unique encounters built around them. I specifically loved the dream sequence, as well as the Baron encounter in the cage. The battle for Imelda felt slightly grindy, though, and I think a few Hell Knights in place of Barons could of worked wonders for this encounter. Also felt the forest maze was a bit out of place and visually unappealing. Overall, great map, exceptional detail, and interesting gameplay!

I don't know what kind of idea this is, but it's pretty damn well executed, so have 5 stars.