Requiem

This is one of the greatest megawads ever created! 5/5

A legend in its time.

The first half or so of this megawad is top notch, well designed, atmospheric and generally a lot of fun. It's a real shame that many later levels taper off into cheap and outright lame territory at times. 4/5. Worth playing through but I wouldn't care to play through the later levels again.

Good, good, good!

well of course i'm going to vote 5 stars... what else am i going to vote, a billion stars?

Lots of good and great maps, but there are some maps that makes me withdraw one star, so 4* It`s a classic though.

tihs is good

Playing through this as a level designer was a humbling experience, as it still destroys most wads made in 2010. And to think these guys did this in '97! Definitely a must-play! 5/5!!!

For it's time, a pretty nice set of levels one of the few 32 replacements worth playing throughout. That is if you overlook map 20, 32 or other fillerish crap... I'd say it's objectively deserving of 4/5 for it's quality. -Giullietta

This is a great wad! This is what wad making is all about!!!! Overall- 9.5/10 (5/5)

Good. But not one of the all time greats.

Just compare this with any wad made in 1997 and you will see this is by far the best. Now compare it to some of the great wads of today and it still beats most of them hands down. This is possible because of the team of dedicated people who made it - Doom lovers that know what is required to satisfy the Doom lovers need, and my needs were, and still are fulfilled with this great timeless masterpiece. 5/5 all day long.

Excellent wad!!!!!!!!!!!!

Pretty darn good. 4/5

Excellent wad. Recommended for everyone as a way to spend time and for inspiration. 5 stars -Nmn

thank you

The first megawad I ever played. It's possibly starting to look its age, but really AV is the only megawad which plays better than this. Gameplay is preferable to the Hell Revealeds/Scythes as it is not quite as monster spammy so people can get into it and enjoy it without being stressed. Co-op is almost totally broken in some maps, not a problem these days but back in the day it was a pain in the arse. A wonderful introduction to Doom and a reminder of where the Doom Community came from.

I find the overall standard to be above the first Memento Mori, and yet again, you've got to honor its age and you can't just rate this type of stuff like it came out from 2013. Most of the filler isn't necessarily that bad; it just seems out of place due to shortness, bu it's not unforgivable. I'm torn between a 4 or 5 (elevated from a 3 or 4 due to its age, and rightfully so), but it has more maps I found quite interesting compared to MM, so I'll give it 5. Again, you have to play it at least once.

A good megawad, but very irregular. There are very good maps (e.g. 13, 15, 24), but there are horrible too, and at the end of the set, which is worse (20,25,26). Final map is a too short and easy icon of sin, inappropriate. Funny, but not a masterpiece 4/5

Very solid mapset. Recommended. ~vf

I think half the people that posted here neglected to look at the date of release, aka 97. This wad was legendary when it came out, introducing all sorts of things to people and I , for one, was dually impressed. I give it 5 stars, and honestly, if you are going to flame this was, at least leave your name you f**ktards 5/5 - Kirby

Legendary wad

I'd personally recommend the Memento Mori's over this. Requiem is cool and all, but the filler maps prevent this from being a favourite of mine. 4/5

I think its the best megawad ever. Better than av.wad. 5 stars

pretty goodd :]