Doomworld Community Top WADs of All Time

10p: Back to Saturn X Ep.1

9p: Torment & Torture Ep. 1

8p: Valiant

7p: Threshold of Pain

6p: Stardate 20X6

5p: ZPack

4p: Doom The Way id Did

3p: Legacy of Suffering

2p: Stronghold: On The Edge of Chaos

1p: Unloved

OP has been updated with a new-look tally and everyone's votes to date. :)

Sky: I gave your 10 points for The Mucus Flow to Community Chest 2. Please let me know if you wish to do otherwise.

Jaws In Space: Monster Hunter Ltd Part I and Part II are two WADs, so I've split your 8 points evenly for them both.

5 points - Going Down

5 points - Plutonia 2

5 points - Space DM9

5 points - Ancient Aliens

5 points - BTSX E1

5 points - Phobos: Anomaly Reborn

5 points - Valiant

5 points - UAC Dead

5 points - Sunder

5 points - Adventures of Square

5 points - Greenwar 2

ZDoom Community Map 2: 10 points

Hi-Tech Hell 2: 9 points

Nimrod: 8 points

Cold as Hell: 7 points

KDiZD: 6 points

Gene Tech: Before the Storm: 5 points

The Darkening 2: 4 points

Awakening: 3 points

Scythe X: 2 points

Phobos: Anomaly Reborn: 1 point

[Singleplay]
8 Points - Alien Vendetta
6 Points - Plutonia 2
5 Points - Ancient Aliens
5 Points - Going Down
5 Points - Hell Ground
5 Points - Japanese Community Project
1 Point - Hell Revealed

[Deathmatch]
8 Points - DWANGO 5
6 Points - Judas23_
6 Points - SSL2

2 hours ago, savagegrant said:

OP has been updated with a new-look tally and everyone's votes to date. :)

 

Sky: I gave your 10 points for The Mucus Flow to Community Chest 2. Please let me know if you wish to do otherwise.

Yea, that'll be more accurate since The Mucus Flow is part of CC2.

10 - WOW.WAD

9 - nuts.wad

8 - cybie.wad

7 - Mock 2

6 - UAC Military Nightmare

5 - Chillax

4 - Imp Encounter

3 - Sky May Be

2 - 30000 Levels

1 - Grezzo 2

Are you sure you posted to the correct thread? :P

And where's do-tims on that list? That will always take the cake for me because it's an intentionally bad jokewad that ultimately turned out to be just bad, not funny.

Wow, where is 2002 A Doom Odyssey?

1- Community Chest 3 10 pt

2- Community Chest 4 10 pt

3- Scythe 8 pt

4- ZPack 8 pt

5- Doom Odyssey 8 pt

6- Hellbound 7 pt

7- Plutonia 2 7 pt

8- Town Infiction 7 pt

9- Twilight Zone 2 5 pt

10- Valiant 5 pt

19 minutes ago, Graf Zahl said:

Are you sure you posted to the correct thread? :P

 

And where's do-tims on that list? That will always take the cake for me because it's an intentionally bad jokewad that ultimately turned out to be just bad, not funny.

 

Maybe it's just me, but I'll always find the "waiting in line to download a file at FilePlanet" level hilarious.  Also, the "404" levels cracked me up every time.

Unloved - 10(it's such a cool concept)

Ancient Aliens 10

Scythe 2 5

Violence 5

BTSX 5

Extreme Terror 5

Mutiny 2

NGM 2

Going Down 5

The Golden Souls 1

Bloodstain 5

10 points: Hell Revealed

9 points: Equinox

8 points: Icarus

7 points: Kama Sutra

6 points: STRAIN

5 points: Hacx

4 points: Vile Flesh

3 points: Revolution (TVR!)

2 points: System Vices (aboosysv)

1 point: Extremal Doom

This is such a great idea! There's some I haven't even heard of!!

4 points - Speed of Doom

4 points - Hell Revealed II

4 points - Alien Vendetta

4 points - Deus Vult

4 points - Hell Revealed
3 points - Requiem

3 points - Stardate 20X6

3 points - Sunder

2 points - Suspended in Dusk

2 points - Swim With The Whales
1 point - Vela Pax (unfinished at the time of this writing, but what we've seen so far is outstanding)
1 point - Grime (by Death-Destiny)
1 point - Back to Saturn X E1 : Get Out Of My Stations
1 point - Sunlust

1 point - Back to Basics (by Espi)

1 point - Hell Ground (by Eternal)

1 point - Doom The Way id Did

1 point - One Bloody Night (by Erik Alm, and yeah I actually prefer this one to Scythe II)

1 point - Miasma (by tourniquet)

1 point - Combat Shock (by dannebubinga)

1 point - Valiant
1 point - Ancient Aliens

1 point - Back to Saturn X E2 : Tower In The Fountain Of Sparks
1 point - Resurgence

1 point - UAC Ultra

1 point - Scythe II

1 point - Claustrophobia 1024 2 : The Mystery Of Too Many Maps

1 point - Plutonia Revisited Community Project

1 point - Community Chest 4

1 point - Kama Sutra

1 point - Epic 2

1 point - SkePLand (by skepticist - I usually loathe ammo starvation wads but this one is masterfully done)

Too many great PWads to choose from - not that it's a bad thing.

10. A.L.T.

9. Bauhaus

8. Sacrament

7. Japanese Community Project

6. No End In Sight

5. Equinox

4. Strain

3. Memento Mori 2

2. Bloody Steel

1. Requiem

Gotta admit, I'm quite surprised to see that I gave a first vote to as many WADs as I did. But oddly pleased at the same time.

26 minutes ago, ella guro said:

10. A.L.T.

Great taste! Your stream of the wad was also very good.

The tally in the OP has been updated. Scythe 2 maintains a good lead over Ancient Aliens.

Voltcom9: Based on your chosen voting pattern it appears that you're missing your 8 points vote. ;)
sincity2100: Your current votes haven't been accepted because you've gone over the 55 points maximum. ;(
WH-Wilou84: Your current votes haven't been accepted either because you've voted for more than 20 WADs. ;(

10pts: ALT

9pts: Epic 2

8pts: BTSX E2

7pts: Comatose

6pts: Sunlust

5pts: No End in Sight

4pts: Aliens TC

3pts: Trinity College wad

2pts: Sunder

1pts: BTSX E1

honorable mentions to Mars War, Nefertiti, Talosian Incident, buncha stuff I'm forgetting, and SIRENS.WAD the porno conversion which gives you 600 health

I was so close to voting for MarsWar as well. It really does deserve a mention!

18 hours ago, everennui said:

Unloved - 10(it's such a cool concept)

Ancient Aliens 10

Scythe 2 5

Violence 5

BTSX 5

Extreme Terror 5

Mutiny 2

NGM 2

Going Down 5

The Golden Souls 1

Bloodstain 5

Unloved - 10 (-2)

Ancient Aliens 10 (-2)

Scythe 2 5

Violence 5 (-1)

BTSX 5

Extreme Terror 5

Mutiny 2

NGM 2

Going Down 5 (-1)

The Golden Souls 1

Bloodstain 5

The Devilz Work 1

Spicy Evil Spaghetti 1

Skulldash 2

Crumpets 2

I was not sure if I should vote since I have not played as many wads as most people here, but I'll do it anyway:

Valiant - 10pts
Ancient aliens - 9pts
Sunlust - 8pts
Scythe 2 - 7pts
Back to Saturn X E1 - 6pts
Plutonia 2 - 5pts
Bloodstain - 4pts
Scythe 1 - 3pts
Sunder - 2pts
Alien Vendetta - 1pt
 

10 - Memento Mori

9 - Scythe

8 - Demonfear

7 - Hell Revealed

6 - STRAIN

5 - Alien Vendetta

4 - NUTS

3 - Icarus - Alien Vendetta

2 - Requiem

1 - Going Down

17 hours ago, savagegrant said:

WH-Wilou84: Your current votes haven't been accepted either because you've voted for more than 20 WADs. ;(

 

All right :)
 

5 points - Speed of Doom

5 points - Hell Revealed II

5 points - Alien Vendetta

5 points - Deus Vult

4 points - Hell Revealed
4 points - Requiem

3 points - Stardate 20X6

3 points - Sunder

3 points - Suspended in Dusk

2 points - Swim With The Whales
2 points - Vela Pax (unfinished at the time of this writing, but what we've seen so far is outstanding)
2 points - Grime (by Death-Destiny)
2 points - Back to Saturn X E1 : Get Out Of My Stations
2 points - Sunlust

2 points - Back to Basics (by Espi)

2 points - Hell Ground (by Eternal)

1 point - Doom The Way id Did

1 point - One Bloody Night (by Erik Alm, and yeah I actually prefer this one to Scythe II)

1 point - Miasma (by tourniquet)

1 point - Combat Shock (by dannebubinga)

The tally in the OP has been updated.

On 16/04/2017 at 2:07 AM, Forli said:

I was not sure if I should vote since I have not played as many wads as most people here, but I'll do it anyway:

You can always change your votes anytime in the future as your WAD knowledge increases. ;)

7 - Castle Heng

7 - Odessa 1 (I'd vote for the entire series, but I'll just pick my sentimental favorite, which is the first one)

7 - Cyberdreams

5 - Bauhaus

5 - Eternal Doom III

4 - Scythe

4 - Going Down

4 - Sunlust (even though I've never played it on harder than HNTR, it's just so pretty)

4 - BTSX Episode 1

4 - Vanguard

4 - Valiant

I'd like to point out that my vote for Hacx is for the original freeware release, and definitely not the "1.2 iwad" version. So this would be the most appropriate link to give. Or just the whole directory.

If you have a "latest versions only" policy, then please reassign these points (1 each) to Alien Vendetta, Eternal, Osiris, Aliens TC and H2H-Xmas. Because this is serious business, after all.

On 14/04/2017 at 10:30 AM, Memfis said:

Wow, where is 2002 A Doom Odyssey?

Well, you could always vote for it.

The tally in the OP has been updated.

16 hours ago, Grazza said:

I'd like to point out that my vote for Hacx is for the original freeware release, and definitely not the "1.2 iwad" version. So this would be the most appropriate link to give. Or just the whole directory.

 

If you have a "latest versions only" policy...

The link change has been made. A link to the latest version of a WAD is usually chosen unless/until the voter states otherwise. :)

16 hours ago, Grazza said:

and definitely not the "1.2 iwad" version.

May I ask why?

If so, why?

(damn, new page.)