simplicity vs colourful

I just finished up my second try at the new design for my site, can't really decide which one is better so I'm asking you people. Just go on both of them and tell me which one is better at stimulating your eyeballs. Feedback (such as error reports, and ideas) is welcome.

EDIT: since the url tags don't work in the poll answere try this:

Design 1
Design 2

THE FIRST ONE THE FIRST ONE

If you ever chuck my AIM name round again with retards I'll skin you :P

YES I SAW POST HELL!!!!!11&^*&%*^(%%(%((^)()^$

lmao!

this poll is useless now, I made a 3rd design, and this one staying.

I'll have it uploaded soon.

Yup, checked it for errors, none, works with all browsers as far as I know, and look great:
NXN - tada

Oooooooo, pretty "redisign" :)

Oooooooo, pretty "redisign" :)

don't be concerned with spelling mistakes

but thanks =]

Bah, I prefered it when it wasn't two-tone.

The DOLT hath spoken, the question is, what does the MoOoSe think?

Am I the only one getting 404's?

No, dan, you're not. I keep getting them too, and it's getitng really annoying. THE PAGES WON'T LOAD UP!!!

To those getting the 404's I made a post below giving a new addy, you must have not seen it, anyway here it is:

http://www.doomworld.com/demise/nxn/
I got all of the page done, I'll upload it once I make some cool Photoshop pics for the entrance and exit.