⬆️ Doomworld Community Top WADs of All Time (resurrected)

[Makedounia]

On 11/16/2019 at 5:42 PM, Makedounia said:

10. Vanguard

9. Deathless

8. Jenesis

7. Eviternity

6. Scythe 

5. Doom 2 the way id did

4. The Journey

3. Survive in hell

2. Unholy Realms

1. Speed of doom

 

^ old list

Updated:

10. Resurgence

9. Speed of Doom

8. Eviternity

7. Ancient Aliens

6. Valiant

5. Going Down

4. Nova 3

3. Jenesis

2. Crumpets

1. Vanguard

 

 

 

[m8f]

Makedounia, thanks for updating your votes!

 

Tally updated.

[sapphics]

Since this got bumped, i'll toss in some votes. :D

 

10 - Struggle: Antaresian Legacy

10 - Plutonia 2

10- Counterattack

6- NoSp2

5- Sunlust

5- Vanguard

5- Speed of Doom

2- 25 Years on Earth

1- Mutiny

1- The Event Horizon

 

 

 

Edited August 23, 2021 by sapphics : only added 9 WADs LUL, made it 10.

[m8f]

sapphics, thank you for voting!

 

Tally updated.

[PBeGood]

10 - Going Down

9 - Sunlust

8 - Stardate 20x6

7 - Sigil

6 - Plutonia

5 - Eviternity

4 - BTSX E1

3 - Valiant

2 - TNT

1 - Hell Revealed

[msx2plus]

5 across the board to:

 

ancient aliens

gateway to shangri-la

going down

grove

lilith (not-strictly-wad-format things also count, right)

magnolia

saturnine chapel

the egg of human endeavors

the sky may be

struggle - antaresian legacy

[Pixel Fiend]

Can you vote the second time if it's been a year since the vote?

[ReaperAA]

15 minutes ago, game said:

Can you vote the second time if it's been a year since the vote?

 

Yeah, you can change your votes at anytime. Just be sure to make a new comment instead of modifying your old comment or m8f won't know if you changed your votes.

[Pixel Fiend]

Nah, no need to modify. I thought I'd boost some other wads if an extra vote is permitted. But I feel kinda sorry for the person managing those points.

[ReaperAA]

4 minutes ago, game said:

Nah, no need to modify. I thought I'd boost some other wads if an extra vote is permitted. But I feel kinda sorry for the person managing those points.

 

Extra vote points aren't permitted. Only 55 points are allowed and you can allocate them for a minimum of 10 wads to a maximum of 20 wads.

 

If you want to give some points to a wad, you will have to remove some points from one of the wads you voted to in the past.

[m8f]

PBeGood4, msx2plus, thank you for voting!

 

Tally updated.

[nikitsune]

10: Eviternity

9: TNT: Revilution

9: Hell Ground

7: Alien Vendetta

7: THT: Threnody

5: Sunlust

1: Counterattack

1: Struggle: Antaresian Legacy

1: Antaresian Reliquary

1: Valiant

1: The Slaughter Spectrum

1: TNT: Evilution

1: BTSX: E1

1: BTSX: E2

[m8f]

nikitsune, thank you for voting!

 

Tally updated.

[xdude_gamer]

10 points - Eternal Doom [My favorite mapset right now, it's got very long levels but they're just so great looking and the exploration is worth it.]

9 points - Icarus: Alien Vanguard [It's got a nice soundtrack and was very big for 1996.]

8 points - TNT: Revilution [Pretty great maps with nice usage of Evilution bits and pieces.]

7 points - Valiant [Not my taste, but a very nice set of maps that feels clean to run through.]

6 points - Back to Saturn X: Episode 1 [Probably one of the most ambitious WADs I have ever played.]

5 points - Crossing Acheron [Despite the fact that it's now considered a low-detail map, it's fricking amazing]

4 points - Freedoom: Phase 2 [Sorry, it's got the super shotgun.]

3 points - Freedoom: Phase 1 [It's very cool. I like the way the textures are used]

2 points - SIGIL [It's fairly difficult, but the atmosphere is amazing. Plus, it's made by the man himself!]

1 point - Sunlust [It's a beautiful WAD, but it's really hard]

Edited October 17, 2021 by xdude_gamer

[m8f]

xdude_gamer, thank you for voting!

 

Tally updated.

[Hitherto]

 

eternal ____10
epic2 ______ 7
plutonia ___ 5
hr _________ 5
ruinbros ___ 5
crusades ___ 3
mm _________ 3
requiem ____ 3
osiris _____ 3
rekkr ______ 3
mm2 ________ 2
remain1 ____ 2
d2reload ___ 2
curse ______ 2

 

[continuum.mid]

I finally finished something that I liked enough to put in the top 10!

 

10 points to Japanese Community Project - I feel the urge to revisit this again and again, a lot more than I do with Ancient Alienṡ, even though I can't justify that objectively. As such, this deserves full marks from me.

9 points to Eviternity.

8 points to Valiant.

7 points to Going Down.

6 points to Freedom: Phase 1.

5 points to Sigil.

4 points to The Plutonia Experiment.

3 points to Freedom Phase 2.

2 points to Atmospheric Extinction - because why not get something new on the board. Really impressive architecture, excellent full-quality music, great use of Boom features. I enjoyed every minute of it.

1 point to Ancient Aliens.

[Pixel Fiend]

-10 / Ancient Aliens

+10 / Judgement

 

-4 / Back To Saturn X Episode 1

+4 / Literalism

 

-6 / Sunlust

+6 / Funnelcake Apparitions

 

-4 / Back To Saturn X Episode 2

+4 / AUGER;ZENITH

 

Leave me listed as "<<Rewind"

 

edit:

@m8f Of course JudgMENT by Rayziik, as ReaperAA pointed out.

Edited October 24, 2021 by game

[m8f]

Hitherto, thank you for voting!

 

northivanastan, game, thank you for updating your votes!

 

Tally updated.

 

@game, did I find the right Judgement?

[ReaperAA]

9 minutes ago, m8f said:

 

@game, did I find the right Judgement?

 

Likely not. Pretty sure they mean Judgment

Edited October 24, 2021 by ReaperAA

[m8f]

Fixed.

 

By the way, 2021 is a good year for Doom WADs. It isn't even over yet, but it has already beaten 1994, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2002, 2004, 2006 by points.

[Pixel Fiend]

40 minutes ago, m8f said:

Fixed.

 

By the way, 2021 is a good year for Doom WADs. It isn't even over yet, but it has already beaten 1994, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2002, 2004, 2006 by points.

 

I have a chart of my favourites alone. It's a staggeringly good year. The chart is already much outdated and yet the number doubles the previous year's.

 

[Ezepov]

8  Vanguard
8  AUGER;ZENITH  
7  CPD
6  Doomed in SPACE
5  Running Late 2
3  SINERGY

3  Favillesco Alpha Episode 2: Desecration on Thebe

2  Favillesco Alpha Episode: Apostasy on Amalthea
2  Harmony
2  Ashes 2063 TC

2  Struggle - Antaresian Legacy

2  Lunatic

2  Rowdy Rudy II: POWERTRIP!

2  Violence

1  Pinochestein 3D

 

PIRATE DOOM not 2013 but 2014

Edited October 27, 2021 by Ezepov

[akolai]

10 - Finely Crafted Fetish Film
10 - Magnolia

8 - Disturbia

6 - Abandon

4 - The Event Horizon

3 - Frog and Toad

3 - Sunlust

2 - Entropy

2 - Miasma

2 - Swim With the Whales

1 - Axolotl

1 - Bloodstain

1 - Experiencing Nirvana

1 - Stardate 20X7

1 - Swift Death

[fran]

On 10/26/2021 at 6:58 PM, Ezepov said:

1  Pinochestein 3D

 

chilean?

[Ezepov]

2 hours ago, fran said:

chilean? 

Yes

[fran]

33 minutes ago, Ezepov said:

Yes

 

WENA, LO MÁS GRANDE LA MADRE PATRIA

[Doomlover77]

Here’s my top ten wad files of all time. My all time favourites since 1995. 
10 - 007ltsd.wad for ultimate Doom (2004)

9 - Super Sonic Doom for Doom2 (2004)

8 - School Doom 2 by POCD (1996)

7 - Hsfc.wad For Doom2 (1996)

6 - Dmuhs061.wad For Doom (1996)

5 - Island.wad For Doom2 (1995)

4 - Townhouses For Doom2 (1995)

3 - Fragport.wad For Doom2 (2002)

2 - Ghouls Forest 3 for Doom2 (2007)

1 - Dawn Of Reality for Gzdoom (2011)

Edited October 29, 2021 by Doomlover77 : My favourite Wadfiles

[m8f]

Ezepov, akolai, Doomlover77, thank you for voting!

 

Tally updated.

 

Doom Wiki says that the first release of Pirate Doom was in 2013. I put the year of the initial release to the list. Also, I fixed Fragport release year, which is 2001, according to the wiki.

[m8f]

Top 10 by game, filtered from the tally. Inspired by Doomworld Community Heretic / Hexen Top WADs of All Time.

 

Doom (from ~59 entries)

• SIGIL
• No End in Sight
• Doom the Way id Did
• Knee-Deep in ZDoom
• 2002: A Doom Odyssey
• Tech Gone Bad
• Phobos: Anomaly Reborn
• Nihility: Infinite Teeth
• Phobos Mission Control

• Castle of Evil

Doom II (from ~373 entries)

• Ancient Aliens
• Alien Vendetta
• Valiant
• Scythe 2
• Eviternity
• Sunlust
• Scythe
• Back to Saturn X E1: Get Out of My Stations
• Going Down
• Speed of Doom

Final Doom (from 12 entries)

• Plutonia 2
• TNT: Revilution
• The Plutonia Experiment
• Plutonia: Revisited Community Project
• Plutonia AD
• TNT: Evilution
• Plutonium Winds
• Urania
• Lunar Outpost 359
• SkePLand

Heretic/Hexen (from 5 entries)

• Faithless
• Shadows of Chronos
• Elf Gets Pissed
• Heretic - Curse of D'sparil
• Serpent: Resurrection

Standalone (from 11 entries)

• The Adventures of Square
• REKKR
• Urban Brawl: Action Doom 2
• Harmony
• Rise of the Wool Ball
• Freedoom: Phase 1
• Freedoom: Phase 2
• Urban Brawl: Dead of Winter
• Action Doom
• Return of the Triad