Jump to content
Search In
  • More options...
Find results that contain...
Find results in...
m8f

Doomworld Community Top WADs of All Time (resurrected)

Recommended Posts

This is a continuation of this topic:

 

What are your top WADs of all time? Here you can vote for 10 to 20 of your favourite WADs and you have up to 55 points to allocate any way you wish, with a maximum of 10 points for any particular release. As new WADs are released, you can change your votes at any time in the future (though, please be sure to make a new post rather than editing an old one). Any commentary on your selections or honourable mentions of other WADs or maps within WADs are always welcome.

 

 

An example of voting would be:

 

10 points - favourite WAD

9 points - 2nd favourite WAD

8 points - 3rd favourite WAD

7 points - 4th favourite WAD

6 points - 5th favourite WAD

5 points - 6th favourite WAD

4 points - 7th favourite WAD

3 points - 8th favourite WAD

2 points - 9th favourite WAD

1 point - 10th favourite WAD

 

 

Or perhaps:

 

5 points - a favourite WAD

5 points - a favourite WAD

5 points - a favourite WAD

5 points - a favourite WAD

5 points - a favourite WAD

5 points - a favourite WAD

5 points - a favourite WAD

5 points - a favourite WAD

5 points - a favourite WAD

5 points - a favourite WAD

5 points - a favourite WAD

 

(You don't have to use all 55 points if you don't wish to, as long as you vote for at least 10 WADs.)

 

Current Tally:

1. Scythe 2 [272: 42PercentHealth: 10, Not Jabba: 5, Cynical: 2, Archvile Hunter: 5, Mr. Freeze: 8, ShoDemo: 9, Chamelenoel: 8, Ralphis: 6, HyperLuke: 10, Voltcom9: 10, everennui: 5, Forli: 7, Nate River: 5, fveitsi: 5, justsomemusicguy: 10, darkreaver: 3, Talvi: 5, bonnie: 1, Dragonfly: 10, Greyenko: 10, Lazorinc: 7, SGS Man: 7, Grain of Salt: 4, bemused: 7, Squadallah: 4, dylux: 4, tchkb: 9, tmorrow: 4, Budoka: 6, TheMightyHeracross: 10, Archie550: 9, Ziad EL Zein: 5, pcorf: 6, purist: 5, Gaia74: 10, maxmanium: 10, Polri: 3, Payload4367: 8, Red-XIII: 2, Tartlman: 5, Nazgul9: 3, DJVCardMaster: 10]
2. Alien Vendetta [268: 42PercentHealth: 5, Cynical: 7, Doomkid: 3, Mr. Freeze: 9, NuMetalManiak: 6, Spectra: 3, Malrionn: 2, antares031: 8, Forli: 1, roadworx: 5, WH-Wilou84: 5, fveitsi: 5, justsomemusicguy: 9, JudgeDeadd: 3, T-Rex: 10, darkreaver: 9, Talvi: 1, Paul977: 8, StoneMason: 5, bLOCKbOYgAMES: 10, valkiriforce: 8, soner du: 7, Philnemba: 6, Altima: 10, SGS Man: 5, NaZa: 5, Poncho: 10, Squadallah: 10, dylux: 3, NoisyVelvet: 1, tmorrow: 4, Odal: 10, TheMightyHeracross: 10, Ziad EL Zein: 5, pcorf: 6, STILES: 5, Polri: 4, CinnamonKilljoy: 8, termrork: 5, Payload4367: 4, Red-XIII: 8, Tartlman: 3, joepallai: 1, OniriA: 1, DJVCardMaster: 7, Scorpius: 8]
3. Ancient Aliens [245: 42PercentHealth: 5, Nine Inch Heels: 6, Not Jabba: 6, Archvile Hunter: 5, ShoDemo: 7, Chamelenoel: 4, NuMetalManiak: 8, Spectre01: 4, Ed: 5, antares031: 5, everennui: 8, Forli: 9, JudgeDeadd: 4, Talvi: 5, Dragonfly: 4, StoneMason: 5, GarrettChan: 10, Lazorinc: 8, SGS Man: 8, NaZa: 9, Poncho: 7, tchkb: 6, NoisyVelvet: 10, tmorrow: 4, TheNerdTurtle2: 8, TheMightyHeracross: 3, Lorenz0: 5, guitardz: 10, ReaperAA: 8, Simomarchi: 4, Gaia74: 8, Polri: 4, Payload4367: 10, Tartlman: 10, Worm318: 9, OniriA: 5, Ivory Duke: 9]
4. Scythe [240: 42PercentHealth: 9, Archvile Hunter: 5, Doomkid: 10, Mr. Freeze: 2, ShoDemo: 8, Chamelenoel: 5, Forli: 3, roadworx: 9, 7hm: 4, Dime: 3, Nate River: 10, fveitsi: 5, justsomemusicguy: 6, T-Rex: 2, bonnie: 10, Greyenko: 2, valkiriforce: 1, soner du: 4, Philnemba: 10, Altima: 8, Lazorinc: 5, SGS Man: 6, NaZa: 7, Poncho: 8, tchkb: 3, NoisyVelvet: 1, tmorrow: 4, Budoka: 3, TheNerdTurtle2: 10, Lorenz0: 2, Archie550: 4, ReaperAA: 3, Ziad EL Zein: 5, pcorf: 5, purist: 10, Simomarchi: 8, maxmanium: 8, CinnamonKilljoy: 5, Red-XIII: 7, DJVCardMaster: 5, Scorpius: 4, eharper256: 5, Makedounia: 6]
5. Valiant [227: Nine Inch Heels: 7, Not Jabba: 5, Archvile Hunter: 5, Spectre01: 10, Spectra: 10, MFG38: 8, Ed: 5, Forli: 10, 7hm: 4, Dime: 7, JudgeDeadd: 3, Talvi: 5, GarrettChan: 9, HUNdebLeonidasX: 10, Lazorinc: 9, SGS Man: 10, Bryan T: 10, Poncho: 3, tchkb: 10, Odal: 1, Budoka: 6, TheNerdTurtle2: 6, Lorenz0: 10, Nancsi: 3, ReaperAA: 9, pcorf: 6, Octillion: 4, Simomarchi: 3, 4everDoomed: 5, Gaia74: 9, Payload4367: 7, Tartlman: 8, Ivory Duke: 10]
6. Sunlust [190: Nine Inch Heels: 10, Cynical: 3, Archvile Hunter: 5, ShoDemo: 4, Spectre01: 9, yakfak: 3, Forli: 8, WH-Wilou84: 2, 7hm: 4, Dime: 4, Nate River: 7, fveitsi: 5, JudgeDeadd: 3, Talvi: 5, GarrettChan: 6, Greyenko: 7, Lazorinc: 10, SGS Man: 9, Grain of Salt: 7, Bryan T: 7, Poncho: 2, bemused: 9, Nirvana: 5, tchkb: 8, tmorrow: 2, Odal: 3, TheNerdTurtle2: 5, TheMightyHeracross: 3, Lorenz0: 3, Octillion: 8, purist: 5, Nazgul9: 1, Worm318: 6, OniriA: 6, Ivory Duke: 6]
7. Back to Saturn X E1: Get Out of My Stations [181: Sky: 3, Archvile Hunter: 5, ShoDemo: 10, Malrionn: 8, MFG38: 10, Ed: 5, everennui: 5, Forli: 6, WH-Wilou84: 2, 7hm: 4, Dime: 1, JudgeDeadd: 2, Talvi: 3, StoneMason: 5, Woolie Wool: 2, GarrettChan: 4, Soundblock: 1, TechnoDoomed1: 8, Lazorinc: 3, SGS Man: 4, Grain of Salt: 6, NaZa: 3, Poncho: 6, dylux: 9, tchkb: 5, NoisyVelvet: 1, Apaul27: 10, m8f: 10, TheMightyHeracross: 5, guitardz: 10, purist: 5, STILES: 4, Payload4367: 9, Tartlman: 4, joepallai: 3]
8. Plutonia 2 [144: Archvile Hunter: 5, Mr. Freeze: 6, Spectre01: 5, Spectra: 2, Malrionn: 2, Ed: 5, antares031: 6, Forli: 5, justsomemusicguy: 5, darkreaver: 7, Talvi: 3, Paul977: 10, bLOCKbOYgAMES: 5, Greyenko: 5, valkiriforce: 2, soner du: 3, SGS Man: 2, Grain of Salt: 6, tmorrow: 2, Odal: 9, Archie550: 8, Ziad EL Zein: 5, CinnamonKilljoy: 1, termrork: 5, Red-XIII: 10, joepallai: 1, DJVCardMaster: 9, Scorpius: 10]
9. Going Down [113: Archvile Hunter: 5, NuMetalManiak: 7, Ed: 5, antares031: 5, everennui: 4, roadworx: 1, 7hm: 4, fveitsi: 5, JudgeDeadd: 3, Talvi: 1, Dragonfly: 9, HUNdebLeonidasX: 8, SGS Man: 3, Bryan T: 8, NoisyVelvet: 1, tmorrow: 3, Odal: 5, Simomarchi: 7, STILES: 8, Tartlman: 4, Worm318: 9, Ivory Duke: 8]
10. Sunder [108: Nine Inch Heels: 9, HyperLuke: 3, Ed: 5, Forli: 2, WH-Wilou84: 3, Nate River: 6, Talvi: 4, Outrageous Videos: 10, GarrettChan: 8, Soundblock: 10, Lazorinc: 4, SGS Man: 1, bemused: 10, Nirvana: 8, Archie550: 10, Gaia74: 6, Nazgul9: 9]
11. Memento Mori [105: 42PercentHealth: 4, Doomkid: 10, Chamelenoel: 9, Vorpal: 5, roadworx: 10, justsomemusicguy: 1, T-Rex: 2, StoneMason: 5, Soundblock: 4, valkiriforce: 10, Altima: 1, NaZa: 10, Poncho: 4, tmorrow: 2, Odal: 8, Red-XIII: 5, joepallai: 2, DJVCardMaster: 8, Scorpius: 5]
12. Hell Revealed [100: Cynical: 9, Mr. Freeze: 10, antares031: 1, Grazza: 10, roadworx: 7, WH-Wilou84: 4, fveitsi: 5, T-Rex: 9, bonnie: 1, Altima: 10, NaZa: 8, Squadallah: 3, tmorrow: 4, Budoka: 2, TheMightyHeracross: 3, maxmanium: 4, Red-XIII: 5, Nazgul9: 2, Scorpius: 3]
13. Hell Revealed II [82: 42PercentHealth: 7, Mr. Freeze: 1, NuMetalManiak: 1, WH-Wilou84: 5, fveitsi: 5, justsomemusicguy: 2, darkreaver: 6, Roofi: 3, Outrageous Videos: 7, bLOCKbOYgAMES: 7, Greyenko: 6, Philnemba: 4, Altima: 3, Lazorinc: 2, Squadallah: 2, tchkb: 7, maxmanium: 6, Nazgul9: 8]
14. Resurgence [76: 42PercentHealth: 9, Not Jabba: 6, Cynical: 4, Archvile Hunter: 5, Spectre01: 1, fveitsi: 5, JudgeDeadd: 2, darkreaver: 2, Talvi: 2, StoneMason: 5, GarrettChan: 3, Bryan T: 4, NoisyVelvet: 10, tmorrow: 2, Budoka: 8, Nazgul9: 8]
15. Speed of Doom [73: Not Jabba: 2, Archvile Hunter: 5, WH-Wilou84: 5, darkreaver: 8, Outrageous Videos: 6, StoneMason: 5, Grain of Salt: 4, bemused: 5, Squadallah: 6, tmorrow: 3, Budoka: 6, Ziad EL Zein: 5, Polri: 4, Nazgul9: 8, Makedounia: 1]
16. Hellbound [69: Not Jabba: 2, Spectre01: 8, Malrionn: 7, bLOCKbOYgAMES: 9, HUNdebLeonidasX: 7, Bryan T: 9, Odal: 6, Archie550: 2, Octillion: 10, Polri: 1, OniriA: 8]
17. Memento Mori 2 [68: ella guro: 3, Dime: 2, justsomemusicguy: 4, T-Rex: 2, bLOCKbOYgAMES: 6, valkiriforce: 10, Altima: 1, Squadallah: 5, Budoka: 3, pcorf: 5, Octillion: 1, STILES: 10, Polri: 1, joepallai: 2, DJVCardMaster: 4, Scorpius: 9]
18. Deus Vult II [64: Cynical: 10, NuMetalManiak: 10, justsomemusicguy: 7, JudgeDeadd: 2, Talvi: 4, Greyenko: 8, Philnemba: 9, bemused: 1, NoisyVelvet: 3, Archie550: 7, Polri: 3]
19. Requiem [59: ella guro: 1, roadworx: 2, WH-Wilou84: 4, justsomemusicguy: 8, T-Rex: 9, Woolie Wool: 7, valkiriforce: 6, NaZa: 6, tmorrow: 2, pcorf: 5, DJVCardMaster: 3, Scorpius: 6]
20. Kama Sutra [58: Grazza: 7, fveitsi: 5, T-Rex: 5, Roofi: 4, StoneMason: 5, Philnemba: 7, Grain of Salt: 6, tmorrow: 3, purist: 5, Scorpius: 7, eharper256: 4]
21. Doom the Way id Did [57: Mr. Freeze: 4, Malrionn: 2, MFG38: 4, WH-Wilou84: 1, Woolie Wool: 5, Greyenko: 9, Altima: 6, ReaperAA: 1, Ziad EL Zein: 5, purist: 5, Polri: 4, CinnamonKilljoy: 7, eharper256: 4]
22. Eviternity [55: JudgeDeadd: 4, ReaperAA: 10, pcorf: 6, Gaia74: 7, Polri: 5, Tartlman: 8, Worm318: 8, Makedounia: 7]
23. Pirate Doom [54: Jaws In Space: 10, Dime: 5, Phobus: 6, Dragonfly: 7, Soundblock: 2, Archie550: 6, Rince-wind: 5, CinnamonKilljoy: 7, Payload4367: 6]
24. No End in Sight [53: Not Jabba: 5, Vorpal: 5, ella guro: 6, yakfak: 9, Woolie Wool: 1, NoisyVelvet: 1, STILES: 6, Polri: 5, Tartlman: 6, Worm318: 9]
25. Back to Saturn X E2: Tower in the Fountain of Sparks [50: Malrionn: 6, JudgeDeadd: 3, Talvi: 4, StoneMason: 10, dylux: 10, m8f: 10, Polri: 5, Ivory Duke: 2]
25. No Rest for the Living [50: Vorpal: 5, Woolie Wool: 3, Nancsi: 9, ReaperAA: 6, Diabolución: 10, 4everDoomed: 7, STILES: 7, CinnamonKilljoy: 3]
27. Vanguard [49: Cynical: 5, Spectre01: 3, 7hm: 4, GarrettChan: 5, Poncho: 9, Nirvana: 4, Budoka: 2, Lorenz0: 1, guitardz: 5, Makedounia: 10, Ivory Duke: 1]
28. Epic 2 [47: ShoDemo: 6, NuMetalManiak: 9, Spectre01: 7, yakfak: 2, Talvi: 2, HUNdebLeonidasX: 9, TheMightyHeracross: 5, Archie550: 5, OniriA: 2]
29. Doom II the Way id Did [46: Dime: 8, NoisyVelvet: 5, ReaperAA: 2, pcorf: 5, purist: 10, Polri: 3, CinnamonKilljoy: 8, Makedounia: 5]
30. Suspended in Dusk [45: Sky: 2, WH-Wilou84: 3, bLOCKbOYgAMES: 8, Woolie Wool: 10, soner du: 9, m8f: 5, termrork: 5, joepallai: 3]
31. The Adventures of Square [44: Sky: 9, ShoDemo: 5, Ed: 5, JudgeDeadd: 5, Woolie Wool: 8, Squadallah: 7, termrork: 5]
32. Community Chest 4 [43: Malrionn: 10, Phobus: 3, HUNdebLeonidasX: 4, Ziad EL Zein: 5, Simomarchi: 5, STILES: 9, Polri: 2, eharper256: 5]
32. Eternal Doom [43: Vorpal: 5, 7hm: 5, T-Rex: 5, Woolie Wool: 6, Greyenko: 1, valkiriforce: 6, Octillion: 6, Polri: 3, CinnamonKilljoy: 3, joepallai: 3]
34. Plutonia: Revisited Community Project [35: Nine Inch Heels: 3, Paul977: 10, bLOCKbOYgAMES: 3, Altima: 5, NoisyVelvet: 3, Odal: 7, Polri: 3, Scorpius: 1]
35. A.L.T. [34: Not Jabba: 7, Spectre01: 2, ella guro: 10, yakfak: 10, Rince-wind: 5]
35. Knee-Deep in ZDoom [34: Graf Zahl: 6, Voltcom9: 7, tchkb: 2, Apaul27: 7, 4everDoomed: 5, Rince-wind: 5, Jaromir Bergmann: 2]
35. The Ultimate Torment & Torture [34: HyperLuke: 8, Talvi: 4, Greyenko: 4, TechnoDoomed1: 2, TheMightyHeracross: 3, ReaperAA: 4, Ziad EL Zein: 5, Ivory Duke: 4]
38. Cyberdreams [33: 42PercentHealth: 3, ShoDemo: 1, 7hm: 7, justsomemusicguy: 3, bonnie: 7, NoisyVelvet: 4, TheNerdTurtle2: 3, termrork: 5]
38. Icarus: Alien Vanguard [33: Ralphis: 6, Grazza: 8, roadworx: 3, T-Rex: 3, StoneMason: 5, valkiriforce: 8]
38. Japanese Community Project [33: Not Jabba: 6, Archvile Hunter: 5, antares031: 5, ella guro: 7, JudgeDeadd: 2, Soundblock: 1, Payload4367: 1, Tartlman: 6]
38. SIGIL [33: Diabolución: 10, 4everDoomed: 4, Jaromir Bergmann: 10, STILES: 2, termrork: 5, Worm318: 2]
38. Swim With the Whales [33: WH-Wilou84: 2, Nate River: 9, Soundblock: 3, Lazorinc: 6, Nirvana: 10, NoisyVelvet: 3]
43. Congestion 1024 [32: Mr. Freeze: 5, HyperLuke: 7, Voltcom9: 5, bonnie: 4, Dragonfly: 6, Philnemba: 5]
43. Jenesis [32: Not Jabba: 2, Altima: 7, NaZa: 2, Poncho: 1, dylux: 5, Ziad EL Zein: 5, Scorpius: 2, Makedounia: 8]
45. Hell Ground [30: Cynical: 8, Chamelenoel: 7, antares031: 5, WH-Wilou84: 2, darkreaver: 1, Budoka: 5, Polri: 2]
46. Disturbia [29: Sky: 7, darkreaver: 10, Roofi: 6, Paul977: 6]
47. Lunatic [28: Cynical: 6, Dime: 9, Nate River: 4, Poncho: 5, Budoka: 1, Gaia74: 3]
47. Winter's Fury [28: Dragonfly: 5, TechnoDoomed1: 10, Octillion: 7, OniriA: 3, Ivory Duke: 3]
49. Stardate 20X6 [27: MFG38: 6, WH-Wilou84: 3, Talvi: 1, GarrettChan: 7, bemused: 3, Nirvana: 6, Nazgul9: 1]
49. STRAIN [27: Grazza: 6, ella guro: 4, roadworx: 6, JudgeDeadd: 1, T-Rex: 1, Squadallah: 9]
51. Chillax [25: Nine Inch Heels: 4, AnonimVio: 5, fveitsi: 5, Outrageous Videos: 3, Simomarchi: 2, Gaia74: 5, maxmanium: 1]
51. DWANGO 5 [25: Doomkid: 10, Ralphis: 7, antares031: 8]
51. Violence [25: Chamelenoel: 10, everennui: 4, Nate River: 2, Lorenz0: 9]
51. ZDoom Community Map Project II [25: Graf Zahl: 10, Phobus: 9, TechnoDoomed1: 6]
55. Arcadia Demade [24: Jaws In Space: 9, Vorpal: 5, soner du: 5, guitardz: 1, Nancsi: 4]
55. Breach [24: Jaws In Space: 7, Dime: 10, guitardz: 2, Nancsi: 1, Jaromir Bergmann: 4]
55. Brutal Doom: Hell on Earth Starter Pack (Extermination Day) [24: TechnoDoomed1: 9, Squadallah: 8, ReaperAA: 7]
55. Newgothic Movement 2 [24: Nine Inch Heels: 8, ShoDemo: 2, Outrageous Videos: 9, Nazgul9: 5]
55. Tech Gone Bad [24: Jaws In Space: 5, guitardz: 5, Nancsi: 8, Diabolución: 5, Jaromir Bergmann: 1]
55. Unloved [24: MFG38: 1, everennui: 8, bonnie: 10, TechnoDoomed1: 3, Payload4367: 2]
55. Zone 300 [24: Voltcom9: 8, Soundblock: 3, Bryan T: 2, purist: 3, maxmanium: 8]
62. Eternal Slumber Party [23: Roofi: 10, Outrageous Videos: 8, Grain of Salt: 4, Simomarchi: 1]
62. TNT: Revilution [23: Spectra: 9, bLOCKbOYgAMES: 2, GarrettChan: 1, dylux: 6, tmorrow: 2, Polri: 3]
64. 2002: A Doom Odyssey [22: soner du: 8, Philnemba: 8, tmorrow: 2, Red-XIII: 3, joepallai: 1]
64. Batman Doom [22: yakfak: 8, JudgeDeadd: 4, soner du: 10]
64. Slaughterfest 2012 [22: HyperLuke: 1, Outrageous Videos: 1, bemused: 2, Apaul27: 8, tmorrow: 3, Simomarchi: 6, maxmanium: 1]
64. ZPack [22: MFG38: 5, Voltcom9: 3, TechnoDoomed1: 4, Ziad EL Zein: 5, Octillion: 5]
68. Threshold of Pain [20: Malrionn: 7, MFG38: 7, 4everDoomed: 6]
69. Deathless [19: TheMightyHeracross: 2, ReaperAA: 5, Worm318: 3, Makedounia: 9]
69. Equinox [19: Sky: 5, Grazza: 9, ella guro: 5]
69. Nuts [19: Chamelenoel: 6, AnonimVio: 9, roadworx: 4]
72. Bauhaus [18: ella guro: 9, 7hm: 5, Grain of Salt: 3, NoisyVelvet: 1]
72. Demonfear [18: roadworx: 8, soner du: 6, Philnemba: 3, NaZa: 1]
72. Slaughterfest 2011 [18: Outrageous Videos: 5, tmorrow: 3, Simomarchi: 10]
72. Stardate 20X7 [18: yakfak: 6, Grain of Salt: 8, bemused: 4]
72. The Plutonia Experiment [18: guitardz: 5, purist: 5, termrork: 5, Tartlman: 1, Worm318: 2]
77. Dark Encounters [17: Bryan T: 6, dylux: 8, Octillion: 3]
77. Ultimate Simplicity [17: Dragonfly: 8, Simomarchi: 9]
79. Castle of Evil [16: bzzrak: 10, joepallai: 6]
79. Hurt [16: Jaromir Bergmann: 9, OniriA: 7]
79. Mutiny [16: Jaws In Space: 6, Doomkid: 3, everennui: 2, NoisyVelvet: 1, m8f: 4]
79. Perdition's Gate [16: Vorpal: 5, Nate River: 1, bonnie: 10]
79. Rise of the Wool Ball [16: JudgeDeadd: 3, Squadallah: 1, Apaul27: 9, TheMightyHeracross: 3]
84. Arch-Vile Jump [15: termrork: 5, Red-XIII: 10]
84. Foursite [15: Budoka: 2, Nancsi: 7, 4everDoomed: 5, Gaia74: 1]
84. The Darkening Episode 2 [15: Graf Zahl: 4, Woolie Wool: 9, joepallai: 2]
84. Urban Brawl: Action Doom 2 [15: Chamelenoel: 1, JudgeDeadd: 4, Phobus: 10]
88. Bloodstain [14: NuMetalManiak: 5, everennui: 5, Forli: 4]
88. Deus Vult [14: Mr. Freeze: 7, WH-Wilou84: 5, joepallai: 1, DJVCardMaster: 1]
88. UAC Ultra [14: Malrionn: 10, Budoka: 4]
91. Doom 64: Retribution [13: guitardz: 5, 4everDoomed: 8]
91. Elysion [13: Sky: 8, darkreaver: 5]
91. Miasma [13: WH-Wilou84: 1, Soundblock: 2, Nirvana: 9, NoisyVelvet: 1]
91. Revolution! [13: Not Jabba: 1, Grazza: 3, Altima: 4, termrork: 5]
91. Sacrament [13: ella guro: 8, yakfak: 5]
91. Unholy Realms [13: Dime: 6, Bryan T: 1, dylux: 2, tmorrow: 2, Makedounia: 2]
91. ZDoom Community Map Project: Take 1 [13: Phobus: 8, Ziad EL Zein: 5]
98. Extreme Terror [12: Nine Inch Heels: 5, everennui: 5, Nancsi: 2]
98. Newgothic Movement 1 [12: everennui: 2, Outrageous Videos: 4, Nazgul9: 6]
98. Swift Death [12: Nine Inch Heels: 1, fveitsi: 5, StoneMason: 5, NoisyVelvet: 1]
101. Aliens TC [11: yakfak: 4, soner du: 2, Payload4367: 5]
101. Claustrophobia 1024 [11: m8f: 5, DJVCardMaster: 6]
101. Comatose [11: yakfak: 7, m8f: 4]
101. Community Chest 2 [11: Sky: 10, tchkb: 1]
101. Crumpets [11: everennui: 2, Nate River: 8, Nirvana: 1]
101. Harmony [11: Not Jabba: 5, Sky: 6]
101. Legacy of Heroes [11: dylux: 7, eharper256: 4]
101. Phobos Mission Control [11: Nancsi: 6, Diabolución: 5]
101. Survive in Hell [11: Spectra: 8, Makedounia: 3]
101. Urban Brawl: Dead of Winter [11: Ralphis: 6, Phobus: 5]
101. Vela Pax [11: WH-Wilou84: 2, TheNerdTurtle2: 9]
101. Whispers of Satan [11: Woolie Wool: 4, tmorrow: 2, eharper256: 5]
101. Wow [11: AnonimVio: 10, Apaul27: 1]
114. Avactor [10: JudgeDeadd: 2, OniriA: 8]
114. Chainworm Kommando [10: Rince-wind: 5, eharper256: 5]
114. City of the Damned: Apocalypse [10: TechnoDoomed1: 5, Rince-wind: 5]
114. Doom Zero [10: maxmanium: 2, CinnamonKilljoy: 8]
114. Dooms Day of UAC [10: Jaws In Space: 2, Ed: 5, joepallai: 3]
114. Grime [10: WH-Wilou84: 2, darkreaver: 4, Paul977: 4]
114. Hell to Pay [10: bonnie: 10]
114. Redemption Of The Slain [10: Nancsi: 10]
114. Reverie [10: Octillion: 9, joepallai: 1]
114. Tangerine Nightmare [10: guitardz: 10]
114. The Journey [10: Spectra: 6, Makedounia: 4]
125. Base Ganymede [9: maxmanium: 9]
125. Beyond Reality [9: Talvi: 3, HUNdebLeonidasX: 6]
125. Brotherhood of Ruin: The Lost Temple [9: Vorpal: 5, joepallai: 4]
125. Dead Air [9: HyperLuke: 2, Lorenz0: 7]
125. Doom 2 In Name Only [9: Odal: 4, CinnamonKilljoy: 5]
125. Doom: Damnation [9: bzzrak: 9]
125. Dump Episode 1: Fuck Time Limits [9: Voltcom9: 9]
125. Dump Episode 3: BFG Edition [9: HyperLuke: 9]
125. Eternal Slumber Party 2 [9: Roofi: 9]
125. Hellrun [9: Doomkid: 3, joepallai: 6]
125. Hi-Tech Hell 2: Alien Tech [9: Graf Zahl: 9]
125. Lost civilization [9: OniriA: 9]
125. Shadow Of The Wool Ball [9: Apaul27: 9]
125. Stronghold: On the Edge of Chaos [9: MFG38: 2, Dragonfly: 2, termrork: 5]
125. Struggle - Antaresian Legacy [9: Jaromir Bergmann: 6, Payload4367: 3]
125. Torment and Torture [9: MFG38: 9]
141. 50 Monsters [8: tmorrow: 2, Worm318: 6]
141. 50 Shades of Graytall [8: Nine Inch Heels: 2, Voltcom9: 2, JudgeDeadd: 1, NoisyVelvet: 3]
141. Come eat The Mapwich [8: Jaromir Bergmann: 8]
141. Disjunction [8: Lorenz0: 8]
141. Doom: The Golden Souls [8: everennui: 1, TheNerdTurtle2: 7]
141. Doomguy's Pimp Ventures [8: AnonimVio: 8]
141. Dystopia 3: Re-Birth of Anarchy [8: Soundblock: 3, valkiriforce: 1, joepallai: 4]
141. Holy Hell [8: Outrageous Videos: 2, bemused: 6]
141. Italo-Doom [8: bemused: 8]
141. Mangle [8: bzzrak: 8]
141. Monster Hunter Ltd Part I [8: Jaws In Space: 4, m8f: 4]
141. Monster Hunter Ltd Part II [8: Jaws In Space: 4, m8f: 4]
141. Nimrod: Ixnay on the Hombre [8: Graf Zahl: 8]
141. Scythe X [8: 42PercentHealth: 2, Graf Zahl: 2, Talvi: 3, bLOCKbOYgAMES: 1]
141. Skulldash [8: everennui: 2, Lorenz0: 6]
141. The Beesong [8: Roofi: 8]
157. Alienated [7: Jaromir Bergmann: 7]
157. Back to Basics [7: WH-Wilou84: 2, joepallai: 5]
157. Brigandine [7: guitardz: 2, Jaromir Bergmann: 5]
157. Castle Heng [7: 7hm: 7]
157. Chex Quest 2 [7: bzzrak: 7]
157. Cold as Hell [7: Graf Zahl: 7]
157. Community is Falling 3 [7: NuMetalManiak: 3, Voltcom9: 4]
157. Dimension of the Boomed [7: Ivory Duke: 7]
157. Doom City [7: Jaws In Space: 4, Doomkid: 3]
157. Doom: One [7: HyperLuke: 4, Greyenko: 3]
157. Eden [7: Nirvana: 7]
157. Flashback to Hell [7: GarrettChan: 2, eharper256: 5]
157. Insanity's Edge [7: TechnoDoomed1: 7]
157. Mock 2: The Speed of Stupid [7: AnonimVio: 7]
157. No Chance [7: Roofi: 7]
157. Odessa 1 [7: 7hm: 7]
157. Plutonium Winds [7: Spectra: 7]
157. Shadows of Chronos [7: Grain of Salt: 7]
157. The Classic Episode [7: pcorf: 5, purist: 2]
157. Waterlab GZD [7: Phobus: 7]
177. Frozen Time [6: Budoka: 6]
177. 20 Monsters Community Project [6: Voltcom9: 6]
177. Assault on Tei Tenga [6: Ralphis: 6]
177. Castle of the Damned [6: bzzrak: 6]
177. Demon Eclipse [6: Soundblock: 1, Lazorinc: 1, tchkb: 4]
177. Double Impact [6: Ralphis: 6]
177. Echelon [6: Sky: 1, bzzrak: 5]
177. Elf Gets Pissed [6: Ralphis: 6]
177. End Game [6: pcorf: 6]
177. Fava Beans [6: Philnemba: 2, NaZa: 4]
177. Five Rooms of Doom [6: HyperLuke: 6]
177. Judas [6: antares031: 6]
177. NeoDoom [6: OniriA: 6]
177. Nuke Mine (Come Get Some) [6: Soundblock: 6]
177. Phmlspd [6: maxmanium: 6]
177. Phobos: Anomaly Reborn [6: Ed: 5, Graf Zahl: 1]
177. SSL2 [6: antares031: 6]
177. The Adventures of MassMouth [6: Ralphis: 6]
177. Thy Flesh - Turned into a draft-excluder [6: 4everDoomed: 6]
177. UAC Military Nightmare [6: AnonimVio: 6]
177. Unidoom Deathmatch X [6: Ralphis: 6]
177. Urania [6: Spectre01: 6]
199. 2048 Unleashed [5: eharper256: 5]
199. Alpha Accident: Terra Nova [5: Rince-wind: 5]
199. Birthday Bash [5: eharper256: 5]
199. CH Retro Episode [5: Diabolución: 5]
199. Crusades [5: joepallai: 5]
199. Dante's Gate [5: Soundblock: 5]
199. Doom Barracks Zone [5: HUNdebLeonidasX: 3, TheMightyHeracross: 2]
199. Doom Center [5: HUNdebLeonidasX: 5]
199. Doomish Den of Design [5: Rince-wind: 5]
199. Drip Feed [5: Vorpal: 5]
199. e1contest .wad [5: Diabolución: 5]
199. Eternal DOOM IV: Return from Oblivion [5: m8f: 5]
199. Execution [5: Doomkid: 5]
199. Faithless [5: Rince-wind: 5]
199. Freedoom: Phase 2 [5: Spectra: 1, Voltcom9: 1, TheMightyHeracross: 3]
199. Gene-Tech: Before the Storm [5: Graf Zahl: 5]
199. Good Morning Phobos [5: Bryan T: 5]
199. Greenwar II [5: Ed: 5]
199. Hacx [5: Grazza: 5]
199. Innocence X2 [5: Spectra: 5]
199. Mars War [5: Roofi: 5]
199. Mordeth [5: Vorpal: 5]
199. Nihility: Infinite Teeth [5: ]
199. One Doom's Day [5: Apaul27: 5]
199. Osiris [5: Vorpal: 5]
199. Paranoid [5: termrork: 5]
199. Project Uber [5: Rince-wind: 5]
199. REKKR [5: ]
199. SELFISH5 [5: Diabolución: 5]
199. Shadows of The Nightmare Realm [5: 4everDoomed: 5]
199. Simply Phobos [5: Diabolución: 5]
199. SpaceDM9 [5: Ed: 5]
199. The Slayer [5: Vorpal: 5]
199. The Ultimate Doom II [5: ]
199. Vulkan Episode 1 [5: HyperLuke: 5]
199. Way 2 Many Dead Guys [5: Nancsi: 5]
199. Zen Dynamics [5: Phobus: 4, TechnoDoomed1: 1]
236. Action Doom [4: Dragonfly: 1, Gaia74: 2, Worm318: 1]
236. Chord 2 [4: Paul977: 4]
236. Coffee Break Episode 1 [4: eharper256: 4]
236. Combat Shock 2 [4: Cynical: 1, Nate River: 3]
236. Crimson Horizon [4: Paul977: 4]
236. Crucified Dreams [4: Soundblock: 4]
236. Earth [4: ShoDemo: 3, TheNerdTurtle2: 1]
236. Empyrion [4: Gaia74: 4]
236. Imp Encounter [4: AnonimVio: 4]
236. Jiffy Bag [4: TheNerdTurtle2: 4]
236. Khorus [4: NuMetalManiak: 4]
236. Mapgame [4: m8f: 4]
236. Nova II: New Dawn [4: Not Jabba: 3, dylux: 1]
236. Sine Die [4: bLOCKbOYgAMES: 4]
236. Slaughterfest 3 [4: Nazgul9: 4]
236. The Enigma Episode [4: T-Rex: 3, valkiriforce: 1]
236. The Ultimate NMD [4: eharper256: 4]
236. Tribute [4: Lorenz0: 4]
236. UAC Ultra 2 [4: Sky: 4]
236. Valhalla [4: 4everDoomed: 4]
236. Vile Flesh [4: Grazza: 4]
236. Vrack [4: bzzrak: 4]
236. Vrack 3 [4: Spectra: 4]
259. 1993 [3: Apaul27: 3]
259. 2castles [3: Soundblock: 3]
259. A Boy and His Barrel [3: Dragonfly: 3]
259. Absolutely Killed [3: NoisyVelvet: 3]
259. Awakening [3: Graf Zahl: 3]
259. Botanic Biosphere [3: Jaromir Bergmann: 3]
259. Chord 1 [3: Paul977: 3]
259. Chord 3 [3: Paul977: 3]
259. Chord G [3: Paul977: 3]
259. Community Chest 3 [3: Mr. Freeze: 3]
259. Crapi [3: Archie550: 3]
259. Dark Covenant [3: NuMetalManiak: 2, bonnie: 1]
259. Disciples of Darkness [3: Nirvana: 3]
259. Freedoom: Phase 1 [3: Chamelenoel: 3]
259. Invasion UAC [3: Red-XIII: 3]
259. Legacy of Suffering [3: MFG38: 3]
259. Phobos [3: Jaws In Space: 3]
259. Pizza Steve [3: Bryan T: 3]
259. Plutonia MIDI Pack [3: Diabolución: 1, DJVCardMaster: 2]
259. Serpent: Resurrection [3: TheMightyHeracross: 3]
259. Somewhere in Time [3: STILES: 3]
259. T3ST [3: bzzrak: 3]
259. The Lost Episodes of Doom [3: Diabolución: 3]
259. The Sky May Be [3: AnonimVio: 3]
259. Unidoom DM 3 [3: Doomkid: 3]
284. 1 Monster Megawad [2: TheNerdTurtle2: 2]
284. 3 Heures d'agonie 3 [2: Roofi: 2]
284. 30,000 Levels [2: AnonimVio: 2]
284. Aeternum [2: 42PercentHealth: 1, Budoka: 1]
284. Area 51 [2: Doomkid: 2]
284. Bloody Steel [2: ella guro: 2]
284. City of the Damned [2: HUNdebLeonidasX: 2]
284. Cleimos 2 [2: valkiriforce: 2]
284. Doom 2 Reloaded [2: Odal: 2]
284. Heretic - Curse of D'sparil [2: JudgeDeadd: 2]
284. Ice Rage [2: Chamelenoel: 2]
284. Jagermorder: Chemical Lab [2: Soundblock: 2]
284. Khorus' Speedy Shit [2: Phobus: 2]
284. One Bloody Night [2: WH-Wilou84: 1, T-Rex: 1]
284. Rf 1024 [2: JudgeDeadd: 2]
284. Rocket Space Jumping [2: Red-XIII: 2]
284. Rush [2: Nirvana: 2]
284. Sector 666 [2: bzzrak: 2]
284. Super MAYhem 17 [2: Octillion: 2]
284. System Vices [2: Grazza: 2]
284. The Unholy Trinity [2: Soundblock: 2]
284. THT: Threnody [2: Doomkid: 2]
306. Bermuda Triangle [1: Doomkid: 1]
306. Big Chungus' Symphony [1: Archie550: 1]
306. Castle of Eternal Carrot in the Sky [1: Jaws In Space: 1]
306. Cleimos [1: Soundblock: 1]
306. Combat Shock [1: WH-Wilou84: 1]
306. Crossing Acheron [1: joepallai: 1]
306. Cygnus IV [1: Philnemba: 1]
306. Doom 64 for Doom II [1: Roofi: 1]
306. dtwidmus.wad [1: Diabolución: 1]
306. Endless Torture [1: soner du: 1]
306. Eternity [1: bonnie: 1]
306. Extremal Doom [1: Grazza: 1]
306. Gothic DM [1: Soundblock: 1]
306. Green War [1: joepallai: 1]
306. Grezzo 2 [1: AnonimVio: 1]
306. LithE2M1 [1: bzzrak: 1]
306. Mini-Level Megawad [1: Phobus: 1]
306. Nefertiti [1: NoisyVelvet: 1]
306. Obituary [1: T-Rex: 1]
306. Reelism [1: HUNdebLeonidasX: 1]
306. Spicy Evil Spaghetti [1: everennui: 1]
306. SQUARES [1: STILES: 1]
306. The Devilz Work [1: everennui: 1]
306. The Rebirth [1: Malrionn: 1]
306. The Troopers' Playground [1: T-Rex: 1]
306. The Twilight Zone [1: T-Rex: 1]
306. The Ultimate Icon of Sin [1: Soundblock: 1]
306. UnAligned [1: yakfak: 1]
306. Vispire [1: NoisyVelvet: 1]


WADs: 334
Voters: 110

 

Also, there are similar topics for gameplay mods and source ports.

Edited by m8f

Share this post


Link to post

10 points: nerve.wad. As far I’m concerned, my gold-standard of limit-removing episode.

 

10 points: sigil.wad / sigil_compat.wad. A limit-removing episode by John Romero which features Jimmidis. Enough said.

 

5 points: e1m8b.wad. The first level for Classic Doom created by John Romero after 21 years...

 

5 points: e1m4b.wad. And the second one...

 

5 points: selfish5.wad. If I were told this is a lost level by Dr. Sleep, I would believe that.

 

5 points: e1contest.wad*. Interesting compilation of levels in the E1 style reportedly reviewed and rated by John Romero in the summer of 2001.

 

5 points: retroeps.wad. Excellent remake of E1 by Chris Hansen. Somehow this is related to the previous one, according to its author.

 

5 points: pe1_phob.wad + pe1_pmus.wad. Another yet remake of E1 by Paul Corfiatis, with a bonus level by Kristian Aro.

 

3 points: jptr_v40.wad. A megawad for Doom Registered released on Dec, 1994 or Jan, 1995, if I remember correctly. The Ultimate Doom wasn’t a thing back then... I have the book and I’m considering purchasing another one in pristine condition with the floppy. Fucking IHC tags...

 

2 points: plutmidi.wad. It enhances heavily the atmosphere of plutonia.wad and, as bonus, John Romero helped me to choose two Jimmidis from this release to accompany e1m4b.wad and e1m8b.wad: Fire Hive for e1m4b.wad and Stealth Mode for e1m8b.wad, for the curious.

 

*Downloads (both files are identical):

http://www.doom2.net/mykdoom/misc/113434_e1contest.zip (113434 was its file id or something within the doomcenter.com website)

http://www.doomwadstation.net/doom_reviews/e1contest.zip (according to the HTTP headers: Last-Modified: Wed, 05 Sep 2001 22:03:38 GMT. Nostalgia...)

Share this post


Link to post
2 hours ago, Diabolución said:

John Romero helped me to choose two Jimmidis from this release to accompany e1m4b.wad and e1m8b.wad: Fire Hive for e1m4b.wad and Stealth Mode for e1m8b.wad, for the curious.

When was this? Could it be what lead to him picking Jimmy for Sigil's midi soundtrack?

Share this post


Link to post

Good and clever question. In spoiler the answer, because it’s off-topic.

 

Spoiler

 

That was via e-mail, between 08/04/2019 and 21/05/2019. Basically, I asked him for suggestions about stock MIDIs from either doom.wad or doom2.wad for the e1mxb maps and he told me I should forget them (for these new-fangled maps) and go for new-fangled Jimmidis. Then I asked Jimmy about suggestions and he suggested me his MIDIs from plutmidi.wad, because he had tried to emulate Robert Prince and the TNT soundtrack with some of those tracks. Knowing this, because Jimmy has composed hundreds and hundreds of MIDIs and I had to delimitate the number of songs to choose from to a reasonable amount, I asked John Romero again for suggestions delimited to the five Jimmidis of plutmidi.wad. He also suggested me music from Buckethead. Ghoul 1 from Ghoul and Endless Experiments from Fourneau Cosmique, for e1m4b and e1m8b, respectively.

 

However, however... I have rechecked my e-mail and recalled that I mentioned him indirectly in the second e-mail I have written in my life to John Romero, 18/12/2018, concerning Sigil. This may or may not have influenced him somehow / somewhat. Most likely not, because he would have noticed Jimmy anyway, as, come on, Jimmy is famous and well known in the scene.

 

Quote

 

At any rate, certain member of the Doomworld forums has insinuated his intention of creating a custom music pack for this future release. [1]

 

[...]

 

[1] https://www.doomworld.com/forum/post/1943360

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post

Not played enough wads to give a top 10 yet. But this list is useful as a guideline for me as to which wads should be on my hitlist

Share this post


Link to post

Diabolución, thanks for voting!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

Share this post


Link to post

So many to choose from. If I could pick 50 different wads I would.

 

6 points - Eviternity

6 points - Scythe 2

6 points - Endgame

6 points - Valiant

6 points - Alien Vendetta

5 points - Scythe

5 points - Classic Episode

5 points - Memento Mori 2

5 points - Requiem

5 points - Doom 2 The Way id Did

Edited by pcorf

Share this post


Link to post

1 point: dtwidmus.wad*. A music PWAD created by Mr. Freeze for the DTWiD project which overrides every music lump of Doom Registered / The Ultimate Doom, except for D_INTROA, the title screen music when using OPL playback. It even imitates the original layout of duplicated songs, so to speak, of the original (D_E2M9 = D_E3M1, D_E1M7 = D_E2M5 = D_E3M5, D_E2M3 = D_INTER...), except for D_E1M6 and D_E3M6, they are different songs now. But the DTWiD project deemed it didn’t fit the atmosphere of the game, so it wasn’t included in the final official release of the megawad. Anyway, the point is because I’ll use this to accompany retroeps.wad and, perhaps, jptr_v40.wad.

 

Of course, substract 1 point from plutmidi.wad to accommodate the new inclusion.

 

*Downloads:

 

https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/dtwid/dtwidmus.zip (official download)

 

https://web.archive.org/web/20171223013613/http://ionline.vectec.net/doom/dtwid/DTWID_X.zip (it contains the pristine MIDIs, not downgraded to MUS)

Share this post


Link to post

Damn... Choosing 10 wads only is not enough considering the amount of creativity this community produced. This will be hard but here goes...

 

10 Points - Hellbound. (Mainly because this brought me back to Doom.)

9 Points - Reverie. 

8 Points - Sunlust.

7 Points - Winter's Fury.

6 Points - Eternal Doom.

5 Points - ZPack (If you get over the jump/crouch issue. You will find it entertaining.)

4 Points - Valiant.

3 Points - Dark Encounters.

2 Points - Mayhem 17. (My favorite Mayhem.)

1 Point - Memento Mori 2.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post

pcorf, Octillion, thanks for voting!

Diabolución, thanks for the update!

 

Ancalagon, sorry, I cannot accept your vote until there is at least 10 WADs.

Share this post


Link to post

10 Scythe

10 D2TWiD

5 DTWiD

5 BTSX E1

5 Scythe 2

5 Kama Sutra

5 Sunlust

5 Plutonia Experiment

3 Zone 300

2 Classic Episode

 

Share this post


Link to post

purist, thanks for voting!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

Share this post


Link to post

10 Slaughterfest 2011

9 Ultimate simplicity 

8 Scythe

7 Going Down

6 Slaughterfest  2012

5 Community Chest 4

4 Ancient Aliens 

3 Valiant

2 Chillax

1 ESP

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post

That's quite easy: 

 

DOOM.WAD -> 25 pts.

DOOM2.WAD -> 30 pts. 

 

Nah...just kidding, give other projects a chance...

 

1. D64 Retribution__________________8 pts. 

2. No Rest for the Living_____________7 pts.

3. Threshold of Pain________________6 pts.

4. DraftExcluder___________________6 pts.

5. Valiant________________________5 pts.

6. Shadows of the Nightmare Realm___5 pts.

7. Knee-deep in ZDoom_____________5 pts.

8. Foursite_______________________5 pts.

9. SIGIL ________________________4 pts.

10. Valhalla______________________4 pts.

 

These ten wads are probably my most played ones (so far), so I thought to pick'em for that list. 

 

Share this post


Link to post

trying to guess what I voted for last time :3 rate my efforts

10 pts - ALT

9 pts - No End in Sight

8 pts - Batman Doom

7 pts - Comatose

6 pts - Stardate 20x7

5 pts - Sacrament

4 pts - Aliens TC

3 pts - Sunlust

2 pts - Epic 2

1 pts - Unaligned

 

0 pts honorable mentions giggle:
Eternal Doom
Bloody Steel

Nefertiti
Bury My Heart Knee Deep
DTWID
BTSX E2
Sunder
Vanguard
Base Ganymede
Saturnine Chapel
Hell Revealed
Whitemare 2
Redline
tree3.wad

Share this post


Link to post

10 Scythe 2

9 Valiant

8 Ancient Aliens

7 Eviternity

6 Sunder

5 Chillax

4 Empyrion

3 Lunatic

2 Action Doom 1

1 Foursite

Share this post


Link to post

Simomarchi, 4everDoomed, Gaia74, thanks for submitting your votes!

yakfak, thanks for updating your points!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

 

In other news, we've reached the 300 WADs mark in the list. You're great, keep it up!

Share this post


Link to post

+5 points

A.L.T.

Pirate Doom

City of the Damned: Apocalypse

Faithless

Knee Deep in ZDoom

ZPack

Alpha Accident: Terra Nova

Doomish Den of Design

Project Uber

Strange Aeons

Chainworm Kommando

Share this post


Link to post

10 Sigil.wad (Romero's episode) megawad

9 hurt.wad (best hell themed map, tends to lag even on gtx970 tho)

8 mapwich_v0.8.pk3 (maps Baphomet's..., Technical... and A Nation...)  megawad

7 alienated_rc1.wad (colorful palette) megawad

6 STRG.wad (detailed maps + adds hammer, drill, uzi...) megawad

5 brigandine.wad

4 breach.wad

3 bbv11.wad

2 Knee Deep in ZDoom megawad = Doom 1 Episode 1 remake. huge, ultra detailed levels (lots of key hunting tho)

1 E1M8b.wad (Romero's map, Sigil-like details)

0 chnworm.wad (cramped detailed levels)

 

Edited by Jaromir Bergmann

Share this post


Link to post

Rince-wind, Jaromir Bergmann, thanks for voting!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

Share this post


Link to post

10: Scythe 2

9: Base Ganymede

8: Zone 300

8: Scythe

6: phmlspd

6: Hell Revealed 2

4: Hell Revealed

2: DASI-I's Doom Zero

1: Chillax

1: Slaughterfest 2012

Share this post


Link to post

maxmanium, thank you for voting!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

Share this post


Link to post

10: Memento Mori II

9: Community Chest 4

8: Going Down

7: No rest for the Living

6: No End in Sight

5: Alien Vendetta

4: Back to Saturn X: Episode 1

3: Somewhere in Time

2: SIGIL

1: SQUARES

 

Shout outs: Scythe 2 (Would rate this really high if the last quarter of the maps weren't so unfair), Mutiny, Hell Revealed II, Brotherhood of Ruin, DemonFear, Zone300, The Unholy Trinity, Eviternity, Extermination Day, Fragport, Mars War (purely nostalgia), Realm of Chaos, Coffee Break Episode 1.

 

Gonna play Speed of Doom today.

Share this post


Link to post

STILES, thanks for voting!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

Share this post


Link to post

6 pts -- Castle of Evil

6 pts -- Hellrun

5 pts -- Back to Basics by Espi

5 pts -- Crusades

4 pts -- Dsytopia 3

4 pts -- Brotherhood of Ruin

3 pts -- Back to Saturn X - Ep. 1

3 pts -- Suspended in Dusk

3 pts -- UAC_Dead

3 pts -- Eternal Doom

2 pts -- Memento Mori 

2 pts -- Memento Mori II
2 pts -- The Darkening Ep. 2

1 pts -- Plutonia 2

1 pts -- Alien Vendetta

1 pts -- Greenwar

1 pts -- Reverie

1 pts -- 2002 A Doom Oddysey

1 pts -- Deus Vult

1 pts -- Crossing Acheron

 

Edited by joepallai : fixed count

Share this post


Link to post

5 pts -- Back to Saturn X Ep. 2

5 pts -- Eviternity

5 pts -- No End in Sight

4 pts -- Ancient Aliens

4 pts -- Alien Vendetta

4 pts -- Speed of Doom

4 pts -- Doom The Way id Did
3 pts -- Eternal Doom
3 pts -- TNT Revilution
3 pts -- Plutonia Revisited Community Project
3 pts -- Doom 2 The Way id Did
3 pts -- Scythe 2
3 pts -- Deus Vult II
2 pts -- Hell Ground
2 pts -- Community Chest 4
1 pts -- Hellbound

1 pts -- Memento Mori 2

 

Share this post


Link to post

Alien Vendetta: 8
Doom Zero: 8

Doom 2 the Way Id did It: 8

Pirate Doom: 7

Doom the Way Id did It: 7

Doom 2 in Name Only: 5

Scythe: 5

Eternal Doom: 3

No Rest for the Living: 3

Plutonia 2: 1

3 * 8 + 2 * 7 + 2 * 5 + 2 * 3 + 1 = 24 + 14 + 10 + 6 + 1 = 55. :D

Shoutout to @
DASI-I for blowing my mind with secrets creativity the last week. That earned your WAD quite some delicious points. <3

 

(Granted that's basically my scope of reputable WADs, e.g. Scythe 2/Hell Revealed/Memento Mori whatnot is still on my to-do list.)

Edited by CinnamonKilljoy

Share this post


Link to post

Ok I'm playing through Speed of Doom for the first time right now since a week or so ago and I'm REALLY loving it.  I had no idea Josh Sealy co-authored this Megawad.  He partly made one of my favorite levels of all time "The Grotto" from CC4.  I may rescind my vote later if I keep enjoying this WAD this much.

Share this post


Link to post

joepallai, maximum number of WADs to vote for is 20.

CinnamonKilljoy, minimum number of WADs to vote for is 10.

 

Polri, thanks for voting!

 

The tally in the OP has been updated.

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×