The best DooM pwad mapper is [up to four] and their best released map is [up to three per author]

[FrancisT218]

Other qualifications/guidelines:

 

-Cannot be or include yourself.

 

-Single player only. 

 

-Must have released a large fraction of their work since 2005. Basically...post HR2 and post CC2...Erik Alm, Agent Spork, Gusta, and Kaiser are probably the oldest ones that may qualify. Mappers who did a lot pre-2005 but also a lot 2005 or later do qualify.

 

-'Best map' is either a single level wad or a particular level from a multi-level wad.

 

-A collab map can go under any author who made at least a quarter of it.

 

-One or more of your favorite maps CAN be from pre 2005 if their career goes back far enough.

 

-Cannot list more than half of all maps they made (if they made six or fewer), unless they only made one.

 

-And...can list fewer mappers or faves if desired...fire away!

Edited May 13, 2020 by FrancisT18

[Dexiaz]

John Romero.

 

The OLDEST and the BEST Doom mapper ever.

[vdgg]

There's too many to choose

*thinking*

Ribbiks, sunlust MAP19

NokturnuS, crfe_pe1 MAP01

skepticist, skepland MAP02

 

I am tempted to put The Flange Peddler, who's maps I adore but his best works are pre 2005 I think. Why 2005?

[FrancisT218]

2005 because this thread is meant more modern-aimed and it is around some 'modern' DooM influences like Scythe II. Though I could make an exception for AV, probably. Flange Peddler qualifies, he has ic2005 and map in CC3.

[yakfak]

think my fave Ribbiks map is sd20x7 MAP02 :3 vdgg's picks are really good though

Edited May 13, 2020 by yakfak

[Roofi]

Currently :

 

- Death-Destiny with :

      . Beesong

      . Nochance

      . Dark Resolution 2008 map 10 "The Soulscarred Universe"

 

- Jonas Feragen with :

 

      . Map 18 "Excess Meat"

      . Map 19 "Mind Trap"

      . Map 32 "Playground" (all maps come from HR2)

 

- TimeOfDeath with :

 

      . Nina Dobrev 2

      . The Room Below

      . Slaughterfest 2012 map 29 "Degrassi"

[Arbys550]

My favorite mapper is insane_gazebo and imo his best map is sunder map15

[Pixel Fiend]

1. Dragonfly - Eviternity Map06 Reconnect

2. PAYLOAD4367 - Dark Universe Map02 We've Been Boarded

3. Tourniquet - Mayhem2048 Map21 Abernikula

[bioshockfan90]

bjorn ostmann, "theory of broken circles" from btsx e2 map15

[blkndsludgeguywholovesdoom]

 

Rf

 

RF1024 - amazing gameplay, almost total conversion, and great use of the 1024 concept.

Notebook - also unreleased on idgames for some reason. Amazing 3rd Episode set.

Mapgame - Episode 1 set. Once again changes on a large scale to Knee Deep in the Dead while making it feel like a whole new episode.

Wirebrush - one level. really great!

 

Stormwalker

 

Oblvion

Flashback to Hell

(sorry only two here)

 

Memfis

 

Alive

Horalky

kukuku

fighting, fighting 2