Craneo Posted June 20 not sure if I'll participate, need to read the rules a bit carefully too was thinking of mixing MAP04 from Doom 2 with either E1M3 or E2M2... 0 Share this post Link to post
DoomGuy999 Posted June 20 (edited) @DoomGuy999 Selection 1: E6M9 - Shattered Homecoming Selection 2: E1M1 - Hangar Map 32: Hangar Homecoming Side Notes Spoiler Does the resource wad contain sigil II textures? Also, I'm not the best with map info and stuff, if there is a tutorial please show me. I'd want to do a phobos sky. Please ignore my custom title. the last map I actually released was 9 months ago. Edited June 20 by DoomGuy999 0 Share this post Link to post
JackDBS Posted June 20 (edited) First Map: Plutonia MAP27 (Anti-Christ) Second Map: Plutonia MAP31 (Cyberden) Desired Slot: MAP28 Would've chosen TEETH.wad as the second choice but seems that's not allowed. 1 Share this post Link to post
DoomGappy Posted June 20 Good luck with the project, hope we can at least finish ours before yours is out. 0 Share this post Link to post
Cutman Posted June 20 (edited) 2 hours ago, roadworx said: hmmm. will there be any form of quality control in this? you're much more experienced than most cp managers (seemingly a rarity these days), though i'm still cautious. I am fairly lenient than most people but maps that look carelessly thrown together I will pick up on. Like I said in the post you have to try and make a good effort. If a map is submitted that doesn't meet quality standards I will encourage the author to retry. See my example map for expected quality, though even this I consider above average for what I expect! 1 hour ago, ViolentBeetle said: How much liberty am I supposed to take? My plan right now is to basically take the kind of island seen on Erebus with the kind of building design present, but will probably map with more modern sensibilities. And I don't want to have the water pit and maybe lose some buildings that don't fit. That is entirely up to you! You will be the judge of what elements of the two map you should use, whether it's just a set of traps or how the level is decorated. If I walk around the map and can't see a single thing referencing either map I may inquire. However I have been playing these games for decades so even if the references are tucked away I'm sure I'll spot and accept them. 1 hour ago, DoomGuy999 said: @DoomGuy999 Side Notes Reveal hidden contents Does the resource wad contain sigil II textures? Also, I'm not the best with map info and stuff, if there is a tutorial please show me. I'd want to do a phobos sky. Please ignore my custom title. the last map I actually released was 9 months ago. The pack should have the Sigil 2 textures in there. 4 minutes ago, DoomGappy said: Good luck with the project, hope we can at least finish ours before yours is out. Thanks, I hope so too! 2 Share this post Link to post
DoomGuy999 Posted June 20 Cutman, is it okay if I put one little corruption cards reference/ easter egg? 0 Share this post Link to post
Cutman Posted June 20 (edited) 9 minutes ago, DoomGuy999 said: Cutman, is it okay if I put one little corruption cards reference/ easter egg? Sure if it doesn't take away from the theme of the project! Ok so the slots filled up like hotcakes, but we have some issues! @JackDBS Your choices must be from two different IWADs. Sadly no Master Levels this time, I wanted to keep things simple. Maybe in a future one we'll include them! I've kept you a slot if you wish to change maps. Doom2 MAP01 has been claimed three times! @NiGHTS108 got there first, followed by @Meyland12 and@DynamiteKaitorn. Doom E4M6 was claimed first by @Djoga then by @Gothic. Plutonia MAP01 was claimed by @WASFDDDDD first, then by @mr-around Doom E1M1 was first claimed by @Meyland12 then by @DoomGuy999 In the spirit of making a unique set of maps, would any of you be willing to change your claimed map choices? Have a think, there's tons of possibilities. If you have your heart set on a combination I won't unclaim your slots but I will at least have to space them about a bit in the finished product. If any of you wish to change your map choices just let me know. Feel free to discuss this matter with each other here. For everyone else who claimed slots, you're locked in! Check the spreadsheet as a confirmation, I will update the front post later. 2 Share this post Link to post
NiGHTS108 Posted June 20 (edited) 8 minutes ago, Cutman said: Doom2 MAP01 has been claimed three times! @NiGHTS108 got there first, followed by @Meyland12 and@DynamiteKaitorn. Do any of you guys want to switch? I hate to be stubborn but I mean, I did get there first and I think my idea is quite funny (I’m thinking some kind of like, Entryway-ception with Go 2 It in a sense) (Also, worth noting that Entryway and Hangar has already been fused in Amalgoom) 0 Share this post Link to post
DankMetal Posted June 20 You know what? Screw it, i'm gonna join >:3333 Selection 1: E4M4 from Ultimate Doom Selection 2: Map 14: The Inmost Dens from Doom 2 Map slot: 14 1 Share this post Link to post
JackDBS Posted June 21 @CutmanSwap MAP27 of Plutonia with Doom 2 MAP29 0 Share this post Link to post
roadworx Posted June 21 ...fuck it i'll be mixing map10 from doom 2 with map23 of plutonia. slot 23? 1 Share this post Link to post
Gothic Posted June 21 (edited) 59 minutes ago, Cutman said: Doom E4M6 was claimed first by @Djoga then by @Gothic. @Cutman In that case, I'd like to switch to E3M5 Edited June 21 by Gothic 0 Share this post Link to post
capsaicin Posted June 21 Very interesting project.@Cutman I'd like to mix Doom II map06 with Plutonia map08. Slot 11 works for me but I don't mind switching. 0 Share this post Link to post
Argent Agent Posted June 21 I think I will give this a shot.@Cutman First Map Choice: Plutonia MAP24 Second Map Choice: TNT MAP31 Desired Map Slot: MAP15 1 Share this post Link to post
Cutman 999 Posted June 21 (edited) @Cutman First map choice: Doom 2 Map09 Second map choice: TNT map16 Desired map slot: Map09 Also, when's the deadline? 0 Share this post Link to post
Quin Posted June 21 @Cutman First Map Choice: Doom II Map09 Second Map Choice: Plutonia Experiment Map02 Desired map slot: Map11 Map Name: The Pit of Souls 0 Share this post Link to post
WASFDDDDD Posted June 21 (edited) 5 hours ago, Cutman said: Sure if it doesn't take away from the theme of the project! Ok so the slots filled up like hotcakes, but we have some issues! @JackDBS Your choices must be from two different IWADs. Sadly no Master Levels this time, I wanted to keep things simple. Maybe in a future one we'll include them! I've kept you a slot if you wish to change maps. Doom2 MAP01 has been claimed three times! @NiGHTS108 got there first, followed by @Meyland12 and@DynamiteKaitorn. Doom E4M6 was claimed first by @Djoga then by @Gothic. Plutonia MAP01 was claimed by @WASFDDDDD first, then by @mr-around Doom E1M1 was first claimed by @Meyland12 then by @DoomGuy999 In the spirit of making a unique set of maps, would any of you be willing to change your claimed map choices? Have a think, there's tons of possibilities. If you have your heart set on a combination I won't unclaim your slots but I will at least have to space them about a bit in the finished product. If any of you wish to change your map choices just let me know. Feel free to discuss this matter with each other here. For everyone else who claimed slots, you're locked in! Check the spreadsheet as a confirmation, I will update the front post later. Changing wouldn't be a problem for me, I just picked Congo because I wanted an exterior level to contrast Underhalls How does Well of Souls instead of Congo sound? (Is there seriously not a single archvile in Well of Souls? Damnit, and I had such good plans for them too...) Edited June 21 by WASFDDDDD 0 Share this post Link to post
Grizzly Old B Posted June 21 @Cutman First map choice: Doom 2 MAP24 “The Chasm” Second map choice: Sigil E5M1 “Baphomet's Demesne” Desired map slot: 31 Yup, I'm not done with The Chasm yet ... ;-) (Have been contributing a Chasm tribute to the Tribute Quilt II community project.) 0 Share this post Link to post
Grizzly Old B Posted June 21 Whoops, I just saw that Doom 2 MAP24 is already one of @Bendy1's map choices. If this is not desireable, I'd like to keep slot 31, but make up my mind for my first map choice. 0 Share this post Link to post
ViolentBeetle Posted June 21 There's no restriction on picking a name for a map, right? 0 Share this post Link to post
Cutman Posted June 21 (edited) 2 hours ago, ViolentBeetle said: There's no restriction on picking a name for a map, right? Nope, just nothing offensive. The slots are filling up but we have some more duplicate map entries! @Gothic chose TNT MAP16 first before @Cutman 999 did. Could you work out a replacement map to use if your heart isn't set on it? @Cutman 999 chose Plutonia's Well of Souls just before @Quin and @WASFDDDDD. Could you discuss if you're willing to change that map? Also slot 11 was taken so I moved Quin to slot 12. 9 hours ago, Cutman 999 said: @Cutman Also, when's the deadline? I wanted to gauge interest before setting a strict deadline, however 3 weeks after someone claims a slot I will badger them to see progress. I'll set a hard deadline once every slot is filled and I'm confident it can be met. Edited June 21 by Cutman 2 Share this post Link to post
Walter confetti Posted June 21 If more IWADS are aviable to be used, it could be better imo. But for not messing up too much the things, the way it was done it's good. Oh well, i could always trying to do my own take! A way to better understand what slot use for their mashups is to create a list of what maps are free to use here on OP or in the levels sheet, it's a good idea? I played yesterday the E4MAP01 mashup, cool map and both levels are recognizable somehow, i didn't understand what the secret Blue key does, as well as the broken BIGDOOR2 in the E4M1 outdoor area, are the things connected? While i'm pretty tempted to join this, i'm not sure i'll do It... Maybe in the future? I was thinking of a good pair to join as well... Spoiler Too bad Dead Simple is already taken, because this morning i had in mind a match made in Hell with E2M8 lol Well, i could always doing that at my own as i wrote above Also, talking about maps with in-game special assets (ExM8, MAP07, MAP32 keen special), they follow the same rules you gave for MAP30 (remove the main fight/gimmick from the chosen map)? Or they can be mashed up in a new way, with the main gimmick modified for the occasion? 0 Share this post Link to post
Cutman Posted June 21 (edited) 13 minutes ago, Walter confetti said: I played yesterday the E4MAP01 mashup, cool map and both levels are recognizable somehow, i didn't understand what the secret Blue key does, as well as the broken BIGDOOR2 in the E4M1 outdoor area, are the things connected? Whoops! I broke something while trying to help multiplayer stuff. I'll upload a new version. Edit: Redownload to fix the door. 13 minutes ago, Walter confetti said: Also, talking about maps with in-game special assets (ExM8, MAP07, MAP32 keen special), they follow the same rules you gave for MAP30 (remove the main fight/gimmick from the chosen map)? Or they can be mashed up in a new way, with the main gimmick modified for the occasion? If your chosen slot has the ability to use the specials (which is only useful for Doom2 maps), you can use them. Otherwise no. You'll have to get creative! If we get a 'Third Mix' after this I will definitely open up more IWADs for use! 1 Share this post Link to post
Apex CHUD Posted June 21 Unfortunately I would like to inflict a map on you. MAP13 I guess, will mash up TNT MAP02 + E2M4. Should be interesting since the gameplay of each is pretty much the opposite of the other. We'll see what I can do! 0 Share this post Link to post
WASFDDDDD Posted June 21 6 hours ago, Cutman said: @Cutman 999 chose Plutonia's Well of Souls just before @Quin and @WASFDDDDD. Could you discuss if you're willing to change that map? Also slot 11 was taken so I moved Quin to slot 12. Could you spread us all out some more instead? I'm all for more variety, but asking people to change what maps they're doing so much is a little bit much to ask tbh I think with just 3 maps sourcing from Well of Souls out of a full 32, it's probably fine as long as they're all distinctive in their own ways. Just don't let any more in 0 Share this post Link to post
DukeOfDoom Posted June 21 (edited) I'd like to give it a try myself. @Cutman First map choice: E2M6 (Doom) Second map choice: MAP08 (Doom 2) Desired map slot: MAP13. Edited June 21 by DukeOfDoom 0 Share this post Link to post
Cutman Posted June 21 (edited) 1 hour ago, WASFDDDDD said: Could you spread us all out some more instead? I'm all for more variety, but asking people to change what maps they're doing so much is a little bit much to ask tbh I think with just 3 maps sourcing from Well of Souls out of a full 32, it's probably fine as long as they're all distinctive in their own ways. Just don't let any more in I agree actually. I will still continue to point out conflicts in case one of the authors wants as much uniqueness as possible. @DukeOfDoom had to move you to slot 18 as 13 just got took! 1 Share this post Link to post
DukeOfDoom Posted June 21 @Cutman Okay, no worries, I don't mind being reassigned to MAP18. :) 0 Share this post Link to post