Jump to content
Search In
  • More options...
Find results that contain...
Find results in...
SirTimberWolf

First chapter of my novel. Just giving it away! Have a read!

Recommended Posts

:)

Thought I'd just post this up here in case anyone wants to take a look at it, completely free. Have a read and see if you like it :)


There's profanity and violence (realistic) so if you find those things distasteful or disturbing you may not want to read this.
That having been said: : http://www.filesend.net/download.php?f=0642086f10aa823e13d6810bcdb61c42

After you read it please post here saying you did and if you feel like criting it, feel free.

No strings attached. Just kindda proud of it and I'm hoping someone else might enjoy it too ^_^;

Share this post


Link to post

I've been conditioned to expect godawful writing quality on the internet, so I gotta say I'm really impressed with what I saw here. I do think it needs some polish, but you exhibit a firm grasp on how to use the written word.

I have some suggestions to help strengthen this, but would you prefer I post 'em here or send them in a PM?

Share this post


Link to post

Coming from you that means alot, thanks :)

Either is fine, I'm not ashamed to admit my faults and learn from them. Please, post away.

And thank you for reading it too :)

Share this post


Link to post

Well, the rhetorical issues can easily be solved by an excessive amount of proofreading and the back pages of a Webster's dictionary (well, I'm excessive; I dunno about everyone else). I also suggest using twelve-point courier / times new roman font and double-spacing. It's easier on the eye.

For dialogue, you clearly understand the rule about starting a new paragraph when the speaker changes (a nice change of pace, lemme tell you--I've seen entire stories comprised of a single paragraph). But you have a habit of linking blocks of description with lines of dialogue when the two aren't necessarily directly related to one-another. You'll want to keep an eye on that. And especially don't put dialogue at the end of a long descriptive paragraph if you can help it.

The biggest problem I have is the content, which is probably the hardest part of a writer's job next to marketing. First, this could be an interesting story, except so little actually happens in the course of 33 pages that it doesn't really give me incentive to keep reading, especially with its lack of resolution: each individual chapter of a story needs to be treated like its own story with its own rising action, climax, and conclusion. Anything you tell the reader should advance the story; otherwise, throw it out.

Second, if anyone suddenly found themselves in the middle of a shootout they wouldn't recover right away, yet your characters freak out and then abruptly forget about it for a while, and then when they bring the incident up again they talk about it like calling the police is an arbitrary thing. They certainly wouldn't wait until the next day to do it, especially if they had been the intended victims.

Third, the story is so centralized on a boy's relationship with his teacher (I got the impression she's his teacher) that I thought it was going to be a saucy teacher-student romance story, which would've been pretty sweet, so the presence of the shooters seems like a non-sequitur. I think it's partly due to the lack of buildup to the action and the over-abundance of characterization. Finally, in the scene at Sam's place, I noticed a decline in the quality and coherence of the writing, like you were running out of steam. Nothing that proofreading or a rewrite couldn't fix.

In summary, build up to the action more, only give us details that advance the story, and proofread the crap out of it when you're done. Maybe you can condense this chapter into "Jon and Kat go to gas station and get shot at" and rewrite the rest in the later sections. Or just make this a short story about their sexual tension and end it with the two of them being so thankful to have survived the shooting that they break down and have sex and get it over with. I dunno. Either direction could be fun.

lol I suppose I should've warned you beforehand that I'm pretty serious about all this shit...

Share this post


Link to post

At first I was a little stricken by your post but after printing it out and reading it on paper I see a lot of your points. My original idea was to show that both of them were strong (in different ways) and that they could put the situation in the background until such a time that they NEEDED to deal with it.

However now I see I kindda missed the mark on that one ** I'll have another try at it after I get chapter 2 done (tonight I hope) and we'll see what happens.

As for Samantha's part, I didn't notice it peter out but my mind might be tired right now so I'll give it another read later and see what's up.

Could I possibly convince you to take another look at it when I get done? I know you're probably busy but this is the most feedback I've gotten >.> If not no biggie. :)

Thanks again for reading this, I do appriciate the (very well focused) feedback and I hope I'll improve from it :)

Share this post


Link to post

I'm used to in-depth workshops and stuff, so sorry if I put ya off at first. Writers should help each other out, and online writing communities aren't too helpful in that regard....

If you get another version go ahead and post it. I wouldn't mind taking another look when I get around to it.

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×