pro texture edit request

[Memfis]

The iwad texture STONE4 doesn't tile too well vertically (very noticeable seam). Anyone wants to try to fix it?

[jmickle66666666]

does this work for you? http://puu.sh/7zfLa.png

edit: one sec I think my files messed up...

[plums]

My attempt, better than the original but not perfect:



eh, that looks pretty bad, I'll have a proper go at it again later if no one else has done a good one. Maybe jmickle's is good, can't see it tiled right now.

[plums]

OK, here's the best I'm going to get I think:






If it's good enough for you, it should be easy to apply to the other similar STONE textures as well.
Interestingly now it looks like there's a seam 1/4 of the way from the top now, too. Eh.

edit: Fixed up the new crack a little more

[Memfis]

Very nice work, thanks a lot guys!

p.s. It would be nice to see a project that attempts to fix stuff like this in the iwad textures. I remember some Plutonia ones having similar noticeable seams, for example.

[plums]

Memfis said:

It would be nice to see a project that attempts to fix stuff like this in the iwad textures. I remember some Plutonia ones having similar noticeable seams, for example.

I've thought about this before, when I was trying to tweak sky textures for D2INO. Having all the skies vertically tile, at least a little, would be helpful.

The Plutonia DBRAIN replacement textures shift around by 1px on some frames, it's always looked like an error to me but maybe it's intentional?