Linguica Posted March 15, 2015 Hi, I have been thinking about a minor project, and to get help doing it / motivate me to actually do it, I would like to solicit people's opinions: * what you consider the 10 best levels from the 68 levels that comprise Ultimate Doom / Doom 2 * what you consider the 10 worst levels from the 68 levels that comprise Ultimate Doom / Doom 2 That is all. Thank you and god bless. 0 Share this post Link to post
Jaws In Space Posted March 15, 2015 Ten Best Doom 2 Map 16 Doom E3M6 Doom E3M2 Doom 2 Map 6 Doom E1M7 Doom 2 Map 13 Doom 2 Map 18 Doom E4M3 Doom E1M9 Doom 2 Map 11 Ten Worst Doom E3M5 Doom 2 Map 17 Doom E4M6 Doom E2M6 Doom 2 Map 24 Doom E3M7 Doom 2 Map 19 Doom E2M9 Doom 2 Map 23 Doom 2 Map 27 0 Share this post Link to post
AD_79 Posted March 15, 2015 hmm these are not in order of how much I like them, by the way BEST 10: -E1M5 -E1M7 -E4M1 -E4M6 -MAP02 -MAP11 -MAP14 -MAP15 -MAP26 -MAP29 WORST 10: -E2M6 -E3M1 -E3M2 -E3M4 -MAP10 -MAP16 -MAP18 -MAP21 -MAP27 -MAP30 0 Share this post Link to post
dew Posted March 15, 2015 I'll play your game this one time, Brandon. best 10: map03 map01 map11 map15 map16 map14 map21 e1m5 e3m6 e4m2 worst 10: e3m2 x10, but also e3m9 e3m1 e3m8 e3m5 e3m4 e1m9 map30 e2m7 map05 0 Share this post Link to post
Memfis Posted March 15, 2015 I did not put much thought into this, ask me again and maybe I'll provide totally different answers. I don't really have strong opinions on these levels: they're just something I played a lot in childhood. Favorite: e1m5, e2m7, e3m6, e4m5, e4m6, map02, map11, map18, map19, map24. Least favorite: e1m6, e1m9, e2m5, e3m4, e3m5, map09, map16, map23, map28, map32. 0 Share this post Link to post
Deleted_Account Posted March 15, 2015 Oh this is hard, my best/worst tends to fluctuate, currently it's; -10 Best Ultimate Doom- e1m2: Nuclear Plant e1m3: Toxin Refinery e1m7: Computer Station e2m2: Containment Area e2m4: Deimos Lab e2m5: Command Center e2m7: Spawning Vats e3m2: Slough of Despair e3m6: Mt. Erebus e3m7: Limbo -10 Worst Ultimate Doom- All of 'Thy Flesh Consumed' Military Base -10 Best Doom II- Map 01: Entryway Map 02: Underhalls Map 05: The Waste Tunnels Map 10: Refueling Base Map 13: Downtown Map 15: Industrial Zone Map 16: Suburbs Map 18: The Courtyard Map 26: The Abandoned Mines Map 27: The Living End -10 Worst Doom II- Map 03: The Gantlet Map 07: Dead Simple Map 08: Tricks and Traps Map 12: The Factory Map 20: Gotcha! Map 21: Nirvana Map 23: Barrels o' Fun Map 27: Monster Condo Map 28: The Spirit World Map 30: Icon of Sin 0 Share this post Link to post
baja blast rd. Posted March 15, 2015 Didn't stop to define a set of consistent criteria, so there's a mix of "love/hate because it was fun/unfun" and "good/bad because of objective qualities X/Y" that led to slight contradictions in one or two places (e.g., with "The Pit"). Best E1M1: Hangar E1M3: Toxin Refinery E1M5: Phobos Lab E1M7: Computer Station E2M4: Deimos Lab E2M6: Halls of the Damned E4M1: Hell Beneath E4M6: Against Thee Wickedly MAP11: Circle of Death MAP29: The Living End Worst E1M9: Military Base E2M3: Refinery E2M9: Fortress of Mystery E3M2: Slough of Despair E3M8: Dis MAP09: The Pit MAP21: Nirvana MAP30: Icon of Sin (edit: derp, forgot this one even existed) MAP31: Wolfenstein MAP32: Grosse 0 Share this post Link to post
AD_79 Posted March 15, 2015 just a little note, I don't consider MAP31 and MAP32 to be real Doom maps :v 0 Share this post Link to post
Zed Posted March 15, 2015 I agree with AD_79, those two doesn't even feel like Doom (especially for those of us who played Wolf3D before Doom), so I don't include them (and if I were to include them, they will no doubt be the worst of the 68...) My list: Best E1M1 - Hangar E1M7 - Computer Station E2M8 - Tower of Babel E3M2 - Slough of Despair E4M1 - Hell Beneath E4M9 - Fear MAP03 - The Gantlet MAP06 - The Crusher MAP10 - Refueling Base MAP17 - Tenements Worst E1M9 - Military Base E2M2 - Containment Area E2M4 - Demos Lab E3M3 - Pandemonium E3M6 - Mt. Erebus MAP09 - The Pit MAP12 - The Factory MAP13 - Downtown MAP16 - Suburbs MAP30 - Icon of Sin EDIT 0 Share this post Link to post
Marcaek Posted March 15, 2015 Best: E1M2 E1M3 E2M2 E2M4 E3M6 E4M6 E4M2 MAP11 MAP23 MAP29 Worst: E3M1 E3M9 E2M9 E3M8 E3M5 E4M8 MAP21 MAP30 MAP31 MAP32 You'd probably think I was a huge Doom 1 fanboy, but actually I like almost all of Doom 2 wheras the Doom 1 maps I didn't mention don't do much for me in comparison. 0 Share this post Link to post
Tarnsman Posted March 16, 2015 Best: E1M7 E2M5 E3M6 E4M2 E4M6 Map 09 Map 11 Map 20 Map 24 Map 29 Worst: E1M9 E2M3 E2M9 E3M1 E3M4 E3M8 E3M9 E4M5 E4M8 E4M9 0 Share this post Link to post
mrthejoshmon Posted March 16, 2015 Best from top (10th place) to bottom (1st place): MAP04 MAP18 E1M9 E4M9 E4M2 E2M8 E1M4 E1M2 E2M3 MAP27 Worst (Ditto, 10th down): E3M7 E3M2 E2M6 E2M5 MAP10 MAP09 MAP28 MAP19 MAP25 E4M4 (UUUUUURRRRRRRGGGGGG) 0 Share this post Link to post
IMX Posted March 16, 2015 in no specific order *10 best levels E3M3 E3M1 MAP06 E2M4 E2M7 E1M7 E1M6 MAP29 E4M6 E4M2 *10 worst levels MAP09 (only four mentions so far) MAP24 E3M2 E4M9 MAP01 MAP13 E1M9 E2M6 MAP10 MAP28 0 Share this post Link to post
Marnetmar Posted March 16, 2015 Best: E1M1 E1M2 E1M7 E2M2 E4M2 E4M6 MAP05 MAP15 MAP17 MAP18 Worst: E1M9 E2M3 E2M7 E3M1 E3M5 E3M9 MAP13 MAP21 MAP22 MAP30 0 Share this post Link to post
RocknRoll420 Posted March 16, 2015 best: map10 map07 e2m2 e1m7 map13 map29 map27 map09 e4m1 e1m8 worst: e3m5 map21 e3m1 e2m9 e2m5 map23 map25 e3m3 e4m7 e3m7 don't really feel that strongly about the worst maps, there's not many maps that are super terrible. 0 Share this post Link to post
Mithran Denizen Posted March 16, 2015 In no particular order: BEST: -E4M2 -E1M5 -MAP29 -E3M3 - this is how E2 maps should've felt -E3M6 - I like sprawling nonlinearity -MAP19 -MAP04 - I like dark techbase levels -MAP11 -MAP15 -MAP26 WORST: -E2M3 - the most 'blah' map I can think of -E4M4 -E3M1 - cool ideas, crappy execution -E3M8 - less engaging than E2M8 in pretty much every way -MAP30 - -MAP05 - The reason I don't play Doom 2 levels continuously from MAP01 -MAP08 - cool the first time, gimmicky enough to ignore afterward -MAP10 - the other reason I don't play Doom 2 levels continuously -MAP21 -E2M6 -MAP27 0 Share this post Link to post
Use Posted March 16, 2015 cheers e1m2 e1m5 e1m7 e2m2 e2m5 e3m7 map11 map12 map16 map24 jeers e2m3 e3m1 e3m2 e3m9 e4m1 map04 map07 map21 map23 map30 0 Share this post Link to post
NoisyVelvet Posted March 16, 2015 Best (roughly in order): MAP16: Suburbs MAP13: Downtown MAP24: Chasm MAP08: Tricks and Traps MAP27: Monster Condo MAP14: Inmost Dens MAP15: Industrial Zone MAP02: Underhalls E3M6: Mt. Erebus E1M7: Computer Station Worst (unorderd): E2M3: Refinery E2M5: Command Center E2M6: Halls of the Damned E3M1: Hell Keep E3M3: Pandemonium E3M4: House of Pain E3M9: Warrens E4M8: Unto The Cruel E2M7: Spawning Vats MAP30: Icon of Sin 0 Share this post Link to post
Demon of the Well Posted March 16, 2015 Hmm.....I'll probably change my mind about something 30 seconds after I submit the post, but what the hell. Best E2M6 -- Halls of the Damned E2M2 -- Containment Area E1M7 -- Computer Station E3M6 -- Mt. Erebus E4M6 -- Against Thee Wickedly Map 27 -- Monster Condo Map 24 -- The Chasm Map 09 -- The Pit Map 15 -- Industrial Zone Map 16 -- Suburbs Worst E2M3 -- Refinery (worst of all) E3M1 -- Hell Keep (damn close) E4M4 -- Unruly Evil (also damn close) E4M8 -- Unto the Cruel E2M9 -- Fortress of Mystery Map 31 -- Wolfenstein Map 32 -- Grosse Map 22 -- The Catacombs Map 21 -- Nirvana Map 07 -- Dead Simple If you take the tack that maps 31 and 32 don't really 'count' somehow, I guess I'd substitute E3M8 and E3M9. ....damn, that was hard. 0 Share this post Link to post
Gordon Posted March 16, 2015 Best: E1M3 E1M7 E1M8 E2M4 E2M6 E4M6 MAP08 MAP10 MAP14 MAP22 Worst: E2M3 E3M2 E3M7 E4M5 E4M7 MAP09 MAP12 MAP17 MAP24 MAP28 I think E2M3 is the only map I actually dislike. 0 Share this post Link to post
Alfonzo Posted March 16, 2015 Good: E1M7 E3M6 E4M2 E4M6 MAP11 MAP14 MAP15 MAP24 MAP26 MAP29 Bad: E1M9 E2M3 E2M7 E3M1 E3M4 E4M5 E4M9 MAP25 MAP31 MAP32 I'm The Guy With The Gun: E2M9 0 Share this post Link to post
baja blast rd. Posted March 16, 2015 Linguica said:Hi, I have been thinking about a minor project, and to get help doing it / motivate me to actually do it, I would like to solicit people's opinions: Were you planning to compile these lists, to see which ones get the most mentions in each category? I like doing that sort of thing, but I'll ask so I don't end up wasting my time if you are planning to do it. 0 Share this post Link to post
Dime Posted March 16, 2015 Best Tricks and Traps Underhalls Living End Computer Station Phobos Anomaly E2M1 Hangar Spirit World Barrels O Fun Mount Erebus Worst Citadel Industrial Zone Spawning Vats Nirvana Chasm Limbo E4M4 E4M5 The Factory Suburbs 0 Share this post Link to post
purist Posted March 16, 2015 Best Phobos Lab Slough of Despair Hell Beneath Perfect Hatred Underhalls Tricks and Traps Refueling Base Circle of Death Innermost Dens Abandoned Mines Worst Deimos Lab Hell Keep Unholy Cathedral Dis Industrial Zone The Citedal the Chasm Icon of Sin Wolfenstein Grosse 0 Share this post Link to post
ASD Posted March 16, 2015 Compiling stats? Best E1M5 E2M4 E2M7 E3M7 E4M2 E4M6 MAP03 MAP08 MAP19 MAP24 Worst E3M1 E3M2 E3M8 E4M1 E4M3 E4M4 MAP12 MAP14 MAP15 MAP17 0 Share this post Link to post
glenzinho Posted March 16, 2015 Best E1M3 E1M5 E1M6 E1M7 E1M8 E3M6 E4M2 E4M8 MAP28 MAP29 Worst E2M1 E2M3 E4M1 E4M7 MAP07 MAP19 MAP20 MAP22 MAP25 MAP27 0 Share this post Link to post
Never_Again Posted March 16, 2015 Best: E1M1 E1M7 E2M2 E2M4 E3M5 E4M5 E4M6 MAP14 MAP17 MAP26 Worst: E2M9 E3M2 E3M8 MAP08 MAP10 MAP12 MAP13 MAP16 MAP21 MAP23 edit: forgot D2 in the best list 0 Share this post Link to post
Avoozl Posted March 16, 2015 E2M3 E2M5 E2M6 E3M7 E4M5 E4M7 MAP09 MAP10 MAP15 MAP18 E2M9 E3M9 E4M4 MAP07 MAP11 MAP14 MAP21 MAP22 MAP31 MAP32 0 Share this post Link to post
Super Flip Posted March 16, 2015 Best: E1M1 E2M2 E2M7 E1M4 E3M7 Map01 Map28 Map05 Map09 Map25 Worst: Map13 Map21 Map24 Map30 Map11 E3M2 E3M9 E2M9 E4M3 E4M2 0 Share this post Link to post
