Guest Antaran Posted October 4, 2000 God can do enything. So he can create a stone so heavy, than He can't carry it up. He can do enything but he can't carry up the stone, else He can carry up the stone because He can do everything, but He can't create a stone so heavy He can't carry it up. Then is He a God? Have a nice thinking! :) 0 Share this post Link to post
AndrewB Posted October 4, 2000 I can solve that problem. The solution is, god CAN'T do just anything. I'll bet you he couldn't make the stone in the first place. I don't believe in that kind of god. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest destROYer Posted October 4, 2000 Shaviro said:I have a cat! I like to set stuff on fire hehehehehehhHEHHAHHA MUHAHAHAHA 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Duke Nukem Posted October 4, 2000 destROYer said:I like to set stuff on fire hehehehehehhHEHHAHHA MUHAHAHAHA Are you implying, Roy, that you will burn his kitty? 0 Share this post Link to post
stphrz Posted October 4, 2000 destROYer said:I like to set stuff on fire hehehehehehhHEHHAHHA MUHAHAHAHA Yeah? Well I blow stuff up with fireworks..... When I have 'em that is :) 0 Share this post Link to post
stphrz Posted October 4, 2000 Q. Can God create a stone so heavy that even he can't lift it? A. If he wants to. Q. Can God then lift that stone? A. If he wants to. So there :P 0 Share this post Link to post
fodders Posted October 4, 2000 Duke Nukem said:Are you implying, Roy, that you will burn his kitty? Burn his kitty or singe his pussy? 0 Share this post Link to post
fodders Posted October 4, 2000 Stphrz said:Grow up Fod :) It was impossible to resist: sorry :) 0 Share this post Link to post
Sir Fragsalot Posted October 5, 2000 You know, I just heard that argument a few days ago... Anyway, that's a paradox. It's like trying to use WinZip to zip a file into itself. Actually, I wonder what happens if you try that... As for God, I don't think He's done very much creation in the past few million years. He hasn't done a whole lot after Genesis. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest destROYer Posted October 5, 2000 Shaviro said:I do that! GO ROYS SURVEY! YEAH!! WOOOOO MEEEE that caps-lock button is yelling at me again 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Antaran Posted October 5, 2000 Sir Fragsalot said:You know, I just heard that argument a few days ago... Anyway, that's a paradox. It's like trying to use WinZip to zip a file into itself. Actually, I wonder what happens if you try that... As for God, I don't think He's done very much creation in the past few million years. He hasn't done a whole lot after Genesis. You're close! I will put the sollution soon :) 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Firebrandt Posted October 5, 2000 Stphrz said:Q. Can God create a stone so heavy that even he can't lift it? A. If he wants to. Q. Can God then lift that stone? A. If he wants to. So there :P Yes, exactly. A being that is *infinitely* dimensional can't be measured using only three dimensional physics. Try to envision a 3D sphere wandering around in a 2D universe. The little 2D people would be very confused. :] 0 Share this post Link to post
geekmarine Posted October 5, 2000 Well, actually the concepts of "stone" and "weight" are only manifestations of the laws of our universe, thus to answer the question it would have to be implied that God was a part of our universe, which He created, and so the laws of physics would actually apply to Him. Now the problem with that is, I don't think anyone has seen God within our universe lately, and because He created it, He probably exists outside of our universe, where the laws of physics don't apply, making the whole question pointless. Another problem is the fact that saying Hee could "lift" the stone implies that He is a physical entity like a human, which He is obviously not, or He wouldn't have been able to create the universe. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest ChriS Posted October 5, 2000 Can we not get into these spammy lengthy posts that take 20-40 replies? 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Antaran Posted October 5, 2000 You needn't read all messages in forum. If you don't want to take vote in disscusion, then be quiet please. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest Antaran Posted October 5, 2000 geekmarine said:Well, actually the concepts of "stone" and "weight" are only manifestations of the laws of our universe, thus to answer the question it would have to be implied that God was a part of our universe, which He created, and so the laws of physics would actually apply to Him. Now the problem with that is, I don't think anyone has seen God within our universe lately, and because He created it, He probably exists outside of our universe, where the laws of physics don't apply, making the whole question pointless. Another problem is the fact that saying Hee could "lift" the stone implies that He is a physical entity like a human, which He is obviously not, or He wouldn't have been able to create the universe. Hmmm, I can form my problem otherway: God is undestructable, and he can do everything. He can't destroy himself (because He's undestructable), so He can't do everything. :) So you can see theory of Universe is not needed. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest PainoMan Posted October 5, 2000 Quit stealing George Carlin's 25 year old material. 0 Share this post Link to post
Guest fraggle` Posted October 11, 2000 Stphrz said:Q. Can God create a stone so heavy that even he can't lift it? A. If he wants to. Q. Can God then lift that stone? A. If he wants to. So there :P you cant prove the existence or nonexistence of god using logic because god is something which defies logic 0 Share this post Link to post
