Reviews:
Getsu Fune
has quite a few good maps throughout, and is quite Plutonic. I do not like MAP11 (arch-viles), 15 (where the fuck am I going) or 20 (chaingunners in the worst places possible) at all though. also you can get stuck in MAP31. worth a play apart from that stuff.x
Spectre01
Disappointing compared to the original and PL2. Starts out promising but fades into small, cramped and aesthetically boring maps. Maps 11, 31 and 32 especially don't deliver. The story text is also epic maymay tier and doesn't help the overall lacking atmosphere. Map 15 is good though. 2/5x
Combinebobnt
I enjoyed this pack less than 1 and 2, but that is to be expected with the fluctuating quality of a community project like this. Still decentx
riderr3
There are not many memorable levels like pl2 but it still keep the original plutonia flow.x
Anonymous
very nice plutoniax
Nazgul9
A mixed bag of generally lower quality maps than Plutonia 2. Some pretty good ones, lots of variably successful remakes of known maps and also a number of notorious duds, among which map 11 sticks out like a sore thumb. I have huge respect for Darkwave0000 because of his brilliant work on SoD and some other favorites of mine, and cannot grasp how he could release such a huge monotonous snoozefest devoid of any action whatsoever (except for a bunch of pop-up archviles in open spaces. Barf...) 3/5x
Anonymous
swag me teh fuk out m8x
killer2
Very good mappack. Feels like playing Plutonia all over again, only harder. x
Anonymous
Highly recommended for Plutonia fansx
Anonymous
Bit strange that this is under /ports/ when its vanilla compatible.x
molten_
Fantastically hard mapset that is very true to the original material while implementing some more modern design philosophies -- Basically Plutonia if it were actually good. (I only half kid) 5/5x
Anonymous
Great plutonia megawad, well worth playing.x
Anonymous
Just great. x
Anonymous
Ok to play for the most part, but not really a match for Plutonia 2, IMO. Has its moments but overall the lowish difficulty is slightly disappointing... Never been a fan of Pcorf maps (the ones in this wad kind of suck, as expected), thankfully there's only a handful here...x
DoomGeek101
This may be my better choice than Plutiona 2. But not really sure. Overall, this is pretty fucking good. 5/5 - DoomGeek101x
Cynical
Map 01- Chaingunners in open areas, and "nonlinearity" that's really "pick the right route or die because you don't have ammo". Map 02- Endless boxing with Pinkies that can't attack you because of wonky level geometry. Map 03- Chaingunners in open areas, then a Mastermind that you don't have any way to kill guarding a key and a switch. That was all I needed to see. Plutonia 2 wasn't great (aside from Gusta's maps, of course), but it was miles better than this.x
Anonymous
Well it isn't as modernized compared to PL2, and it is somewhat closer to the original Plutonia, but everything I said in my PL2 review still applies here, if anything just to a slightly lesser extent. It still doesn't match the true magic that made PL1 what it is, but rather it's another great tribute, another great community effort, and another reason to own Final Doom. And finally, another near top rate wad in its own right. - kakhome1 x
Anonymous
Nothing will ever occupy the spot in my mind the original Plutonia had, but this and PL2 are both well worth it (and two more reasons why you need to have Final Doom)! Trying to emulate Plutonia perfectly is like DTWID, IMO. You'll succeed at making great maps, you'll have a hit megawad, and you'll get 5/5 from a lot of voters me included...but you'll never truly actually do it to a perfect T.x
Anonymous
Not as good as PL2 but still a very good one! 4/5x
Anonymous
Not as good as Plutonia 2 but still very much worth playing. Very challenging on Ultra-Violence too. Maps are mostly great, a few are just okay. Map 15 sucks and is not fun. Overall I was satisfied though. Overall though 4.5/5.x
Anonymous
Simply brilliant set of plutonia maps. Everything you liked about Plutonia is here plus more! In fact, I think this even exceeds Plutonia 2! No less than 5/5. -TRRobin.x
Anonymous
It's different from Plutonia 2, more a reimagining than a successor. I enjoyed both a lot but some will definitely have their preferences. For me I just take them for what they are: very worthwhile community mapsets.x
Anonymous
To me, it was an average trip. some maps really stood out and some really sucked balls, especially the later ones.x
Anonymous
I love PRCP, I'm now on MAP08 at UV difficulty and I'm loving it so far! Hope we expect a TNT Revisited Community Project soon titled TNTRCP or TRCPx
Anonymous
very nicex
Anonymous
^ Plutonia 2 are very much superior compared to Plutonia revisited but anyway, revisited has some 4 or 5 very ugly maps, many decent and some OUTSTANG maps. Overall, it's a great megawad. 4/5 -MarkAnthonyx
Anonymous
It has its flaws, a few very nasty places scattered across the levels and another goddamn Icon of Sin level, but anyway - it's a legend reborn. Really outstanding work and much more consistent and reminiscent of original Plutonia than Plutonia 2 was. 5/5 - Demonologistx
Anonymous
all plutonia maps are awesomex
Anonymous
This kicks Plutonia 2 out of the way, as it was mostly much harder than Plutonia and more complex. Now this .wad creates the real "Plutonia". MAP15 was a pain, but it was great plus the music, and it is in the right place for a long map (halfway). 5/5x
Anonymous
the best megawad ever. map 15 is hard as hell but pure art.thanks to the doom community for this great stuff!x
Anonymous
If this is vanilla compatible, why is it in 'levels/doom2/ports /megawads'? Otherwise great stuff.x
Anonymous
Makes the BIGGEST mistake any map makers can make: NEVER LET THE PLAYER RUN OUT OF AMMO. Nothing is more boring than a horde of demons to kill and just fists to do it.x
Anonymous
Overhyped Plutonia remake. Original and sequel are still much better than this.x
Anonymous
The true plutonia! 5/5x
Anonymous
Legendary ~ a faithful tribute to Plutonia. 5 starsx
Anonymous
Nice megawad...well, I don't very like Plutonia but I think these maps are good or even better. But, I stupidly to play with UV but I still have fun until Map21... yeah...later maps are reason I hate some of original Plutonia...But they're not bad...just Plutonia style... 4/5 -playerlinx
Anonymous
good wad and better than PL2!!! 3/5x
Anonymous
Really good wad, easy 5/5 from me.x
Anonymous
Like PL2, its mostly good, but not perfect. There are some really good levels in here, but also a few duds.x
Anonymous
new legend.x
Anonymous
Some music choices seemed off, and some maps missing the signature teleport entrances/exits kinda throws me off a little. BUT, this certainly has the levels being a hell of a lot more plutonia-ish than PL2 ever did. PL2's problem was that its levels seemed more in style of AV and Scythe 2 rather than actually following Plutonia's style. x
Anonymous
Plutonia 2 is better in terms of being sequel and introduction to something new. This one, Plutonia Revisited, is good as being expansion to original or remake.x
Anonymous
Very good. A bit too similar (homages or not) to the original at places, but it doesnt matter.x
Anonymous
This wad is more than legendary, this is Godlike. So wonderful and awesome in gameplay, the best tribute to Plutonia! 5 stars, obviouslyx
Anonymous
Great. 5 stars. Even better than PL2. Like its predecessors, it's pretty hard but not "almost impossible" like HR and AV are... While most other WADs today are mostly mediocre or just plain bad and amatuerish, this one keeps me satisfied :) PLUTONIA LIVES ON!!!x
Anonymous
The real Plutonia 2x
Anonymous
Its really fantastic. Tough levels with a lot of variety in each one. Well designed beautiful levels.x
Anonymous
All I gotta say is: "Winning" -Primex
Anonymous
Good WAD. Also, while those games are good, Doom 2 is much better then mortal kombat, portal and minesweeper combined.x
Anonymous
5/5 much much better than plutonia 2x
Anonymous
This was really fun, great work guys! ~vfx
Anonymous
Great WAD, really matches the Plutonia style well. Individual maps range from solid to prodigal. Secret level is annoyingly hard to find, super-secret level is easy. Bug in MAP31: various item score items are not marked multiplayer. 5/5 - ZZx
Anonymous
This is the "REAL" plutonia 2. Great stuff!x
Anonymous
Wow awesome work guys. And it's vanilla too! Probably more like Plutonia than Plutonia 2 was. 5 Stars.x
Anonymous
Keep up the good work, man!x
Anonymous
Full of fun, Full of monsters, Full of DOOM, Full of Detail, Full of Plutonia. 5/5 If you don't have this yet then why the hell are you waiting for? --C30N9x
Anonymous
It's an awesome Doom wad, but it shouldn't be compared to other games. 5/5. And remember, Mortal Combat isn't even available for PC.x
Anonymous
Very nice wad, but neither it nor Portal 2 can live up to the glory that is Mortal Kombat. Still, 5/5.x
Anonymous
Stunning mapset, maybe even better than Plutonia 2 *****x
Anonymous
Very good megawad. At least as good as Plutonia 2. BTW Portal 2 was also released the same day - much better than Mortal Kombat.x
Anonymous
Nice work! I'd play this over Mortal Kombat any day! LOL it was released the same day, too!x
Anonymous
Lots of nice maps in this set and a couple are really outstanding. If you liked the Plutonia experiment I recommend you give this a try. dwrTagx
Anonymous
Excellent work from the community. Mostly very consistent, and the weaker maps still delivers plutonic nostalgia and fun gameplay. Well done! 5 Stars.x
Anonymous
I'll concede that I'm slightly invested in this .WAD, as I made the whole of one map. So I'll ignore that and say I loved playing through the other 32 maps. Very fun and a great Plutonia megawad with quite a few great maps! 5* -Phobusx