Reviews:
Getsu Fune
playing through the whole thing on continuous could be fun, but the scenarios where enemies are directly behind the player are fucking shit.x
Anonymous
spawn, spawn, spawn. ambush, ambush, ambush. warp, warp, warp.x
Anonymous
Ammo is very tight, and I recommend dialing it down at least to HMP for a more enjoyable experience. UV is a true test of conservation, almost map after map. That said it's quite an enjoyable mapset at this reduced difficulty so I can't rate it below a 4/5 - pretty darn good, and worthy overall of the caco it received even though I cannot recommend UV on this one.x
Anonymous
could be alot betterx
mrthejoshmon
Amazing amounts of fun, this megawad is a must play for any Doom enthusiast.x
Anonymous
Amazing design and excellent gameplay. You could say these are as good as the original Doom levels but the truth is their 10x better. Well done and thank you.x
Anonymous
I like this! Only problem with it is how hard it is. x
Anonymous
Pretty darn good vanilla dooming with many surprise attacks coming from all directions keeping difficulty up and the player on their toes. Just short of greatness. 4/5. -TRRobin.x
playerlin
Even I hate DooM 1 due lack of SSG but this megawad/3 episodes installation just pure awesome, I don't see it's boring but if you plays too long from first to second episode, it should be getting boring on some of early Episode 3 levels...but yeah, I have fun with this wad. 4.5/5x
Anonymous
Boring as shit. 2/5x
Lizardcommando
I dunno how this got such high scores. It's alright but the map design is really repetitive. 3/5x
NightFright
Brings the challenge of some harder Doom II WADs to the first Doom. Prepare for loads of Sergeants and Imps at all times, and Barons like to join the party, too. Level design is great, and the skyboxes contribute a lot to the Jupiter scenario. Cacoward is well-earned, and anything not liking this does not know what's good. :) 5/5 - NightFrightx
Anonymous
A good map-set. Recommended, even though E1 and E2 were released separately in earlier years.x
Anonymous
Wonderful. Had a lot of fun playing this! 5/5 -unidenti7iedx
Anonymous
Beats DTWID any day. 5/5x
Anonymous
pure crap, anoying as hell, ugly design.x
Anonymous
A great map set I thoroughly enjoyed. Thanks for all the effort you put into polishing this up, it really shows. A great mix of old school gaming style and new(er) aesthetics, I really had a great time playing this and I'll be looking for your other maps. An unabashed 5 star masterpiece. -Sir TimberWolf x
Anonymous
I agree with some people reviews about the design and gameplay aspects being a little repetitive, but it's a solid piece of work and well worth playing. 4 Stars.x
Anonymous
hard but enjoyable. 4/5x
Anonymous
not bad. but E1M8 is nonsense. 3/5x
Anonymous
One of the best doom(I) wads I've played but episode 3 felt a bit rushed and a lot of the levels were a bit short - still the quality was good and so 4/5x
Anonymous
i enjoyed it as much as some other megawads though not as much as DTWID. 4/5x
Anonymous
Has a good classic Doom atmosphere.x
Anonymous
Its just a back to the basics, no nonsense, distilled essence of Doom Doomery here. You never know whats coming next because each new encounter is just so damn different from the last. Visuals are exactly what they need to be. They are elegantly simple and faithful to the original iwads while at the same time adding having their own flair. 5/5 -FoHx
Anonymous
not bad at allx
Anonymous
Fan-f@#king-tastic!! Best Doom 1 megawad I have ever played... best use of Doom 1 monsters EVER. Cannot speak highly enough about this mapset... boss levels weren't as challenging as the normal levels, but it was the same in the Iwads as well.... E1M8 was a nice gimmick..... PLAY THIS NOW!!x
Anonymous
Basically quite well done, must have been a lot of work. However, overall architecture is repetitive, and playability becomes quite predictable after a few maps - so gets a bit boring due because of no real surprises. Overall: solid 4/5x
Anonymous
One of the best classic doom 1 megawads. Wow! I've just finished it and it's sooooo fun 5/5 - Optimusx
Anonymous
It would be better if the skybox changed every episode. Oh well.x
Anonymous
5/5 for this wad, 0/5 for all the haters.x
Anonymous
That old-fashioned stuff never gets old. I have to say there's too much teleport ambushes in E2 & E3 for my taste, but 5/5 anyway.x
Anonymous
Rocking maps. Very atmospheric with a modernized touch to the classic space / hell vibes that the original doom episodes had! Gonna run this bad boy on TNS! 5*x
Anonymous
Hate it. 0/5x
Anonymous
Legendary. Deserves being played.x
Anonymous
Most detailed classic wad I ever seen. Unfortunately, gameplay isn't always on par with the looks.x
Anonymous
1 stars - slick enough, but very average. I don't know how this got 4 stars.x
Anonymous
Been playing this wad since he started it. The final release is awesome. Extremely hard at times. Excellent wad. -GRBx
Anonymous
wow, this is damn good wad! I will play this with my monster randomizer mod (stuff from realm667). it will be so damn fun! I rate this 5/5. -FistMarinex
Anonymous
To be fair, as a level designer, each level has its own unique linear setup and engages the player from point A to point Z with the right amount of challenges no matter what mode it's placed in. The scenry's awesome with good detail all around. The music fits in, too. Keep it up! - Doom Mastax
Anonymous
Shit. 5/5x
Anonymous
This is abolutely excellent. The only thing I dislike about this wad is overuse of revenants.x
Anonymous
Four stars. Why not five? Because it's a repack.x
Anonymous
One of the top Doom I megawads. Good level designs and lengths, a sense of oldschool play that oddly manages to stray (in a good way) from ever truly just mimicking original styles. And oddly I like the DTWID-planned soundtrack appearing in here as well. It's time this project FINALLY gets a legitimate cacoward, in eleven months that is. 5/5x