We'll be getting a lot of these I'm sure, but I just spotted the first Doom 3 review that I know of, and it happens to be over on our old buddy and host TeleFragged. OK so it's not really the first review, but I'm not counting PC Gamer and whatever other publications got their hands on a pre-gold version so they could pump out a review in a timely manner. Here's a bit:
DOOM 3 promises jaw-dropping visuals, moments that'll scare you right out of your seat, and intense close-combat action against evil that only the artists at id could have ever dreamed up. After years of massive hype, though, many games wind up being just plain not worth all that effort. I'm happy to say that DOOM 3 does not fall into this pile; it's an excellent game with a style that few can even rival.
Yeah I think he likes it.