As an ex-high school girl myself I have to say, I didn't see many high school girls looking as good as the 2004 one... but neither did I see a freakier nose than the 2005 one....
And yes I'm a judgemental whore! Thats what comes from surviving the aforementioned high school thing...
Heh I guess my point is they look to prim and proper. Going to a public school in the city, I tend to see less fancy dresses and makeup, but more tight jeans and dollar store lip-gloss. But whatever :/