Ghost173

This, this, THIS!

This. Personally I think Doom 2's cyberdemon would eat Doom 3's cyberdemon for breakfast. They just need to update the gfx, obviously.

I have not played Doom 3 and I don't intend to. I have seen images of the imp, baron and archville and they all look very similair which takes away that distinguishing feeling you get when you face different enemies. It will be extremely hard to create another Doom game that is as significant as DOOM/DOOM 2. However like many have said in this thread that the majority of FPS games nowadays are tring to keep up with the gfx which is all well and good, but it won't make a new generation FPS. For Doom 4 to be a success and to be different it needs to recreate that feeling of the original Dooms where there was a fair amount of skill required in terms of strafing etc. It should be much faster paced with none or little cutscences. If you told anyone today who played current FPS such as COD to play Congo on UV they would struggle. That feeling that a ridiculously large amount of barons surrounding you creates is much more intense and creates that feeling of being completely out numbered but you know you can still get your way out of it somehow. Just my 2 cents.