felgro

RE: "Apparently doesn't know what an 'episode' is -- No Sleep for the Dead is a full 9(+1) map set." He was refering to there being no full E2 I think.

Yeah my mistake on that one. :)

hi, 40oz here with another contrarian opinion. Every review, whether it's sloppily written or not, overly negative, or generally annoying, is useful as long as the reviewer is honest. Some players may not have a fun time playing a wad that is generally well received. It's not the player's responsibility to adapt their reviews to the general consensus of the wad. If the guy can't get it to work in Doomsday, that may be useful information for Doomsday users. It could also be useful information for the creator to make play instructions more clear and apparent in the description or text file. If you're someone who doesn't agree with that particular review, you're welcome to post your own positive review with maxed out stars to negate the impact that bad review did to the wad. But you shouldn't harp on someone for writing a bad review, because sometimes people with a very low threshold for fun can actually be extremely valuable.

There are some people such as myself, who are in a rare position where many people tend to enjoy whatever I make because they appreciate that I'm taking the time to map at all. So when I get positive feedback for that, that can actually be kind of annoying for me because the review is closer to dishonesty than about the quality of my work.