Maximum Matt

Good ol' Kes Gaming

What about a purple key, so we can make Prince-themed megawads??

Because it sounds awesome, it gibs zombies and it's bound to 6, the most Satanic number

Aw HELL to the no

Add in rocket and plasma zombies Give the pinky demons gib animations too Change the hell knight sprites to something, anything else. Seriously, keep the attacks, HP, movement and SFX the same, just make it look different to the Baron. Give the arch-vile a melee "push" attack that doesn't hurt, but is dangerous (especially when positioned near inescapable pits, would give a whole new dynamic to them) Make the cyberdemon randomly change firing volleys of one, two or three rockets Give the Icon Of Sin something like Mancubus fireballs from the eyes every now and then (signposted by them starting to glow like two seconds before), or maybe a hitscan attack like the arch-vile's, but insta-death. And give it a horrifically scary bite animation (also insta-death) if you get too close. Oh, and make it bleed instead of bullet puffs when you shoot at it. Make the Pain Elementals not exist

If it were a sequel (which I believe would be cheekily titled Wolf 4D) there would have to include projectile enemies, but what would the nazis throw? Not grenades surely, bouncing mechanics were difficult enough for Quake in '96. Rocks? Treasure? Bones? Chicken drumsticks? Dog shite? The mind boggles. But they definitely would've kept the Death Camtm in, that's fer damn sure

Ain't the worst one either - worst opener, possibly. Certainly very atmospheric, the green-and yellow color scheme is used well, very evil looking, it's the first Doom map to advertise a rock band - and if by your metric of 'best' means 'most difficult', then yeah, everybody's pistol-starting this one, but best of all time? Over Romero's efforts from the same episode? Over the E1 maps, and Containment Area, and The Living End, over HABITAT? I'll reiterate my "aw hell no" comment with gusto and the quickness. But I may indeed be moved to write a textwall about Thy Flesh Consumed, the misunderstood episode of UDoom.

E4M1?? Aw hell no

Deep cut

Well, you need an atmosphere first, to grow them in the first place

You gotta use the SSG, bro, it's all cool and wicked

I just think Bromero heard that Phobos and Deimos is like Latin for 'fear' and 'terror' and was like, "hell yeah"

In Vanilla the word replaces the time taken

I seem to remember in the Doom novel the BFG had 'gyro-stabilizers' which I guess is to help keep it steady/no kickback when fired, and that it had no trigger, you had to squeeze the handle. So there's that. But my pick would be the chainsaw

Except for when you let go of the trigger.

Baron hide be tough

Yeah man, Speed (map12) is like Perfect Hatred (E4M2) part II

That's Them Bones by AIC then

This classic sounds like it was made with MIDI software - This would be perfect for, say, E1M4.

They invented Marvel too

Chocolate is the way to go

So Quake is officially the first FPS ever then.

I hate the word "tier" now

Wasn't Commander Keen supposed to be Quake or something?

Nice coincidence, there's a guy who's going through all the beta versions of the Doom II levels, and he just did the levels that turned into The Spirit World today: