Here's a little rundown for anyone "curious" enough to try this.
Download size: 56MB
3x 1440x900 "wallpapers" (aka poor screenshots)
3x website "rank up" keys
First off, why are you even making a website, facebook page for a simple mod? What's this member rank up nonsense, and more importantly, why would anyone care to "rank up" for you? (I can see that there is exactly one user on the site -> you). What's with this crazy promotion requiring website registration and facebook page? Who'd care that much?
Textfile, nothing bad, let's move on to the wad.
67.2MB download, parsed through SLADE, and what do I see? 14.19MB/10.32MB/7.12MB/2.34MB MP3 files, sizing up the wad. Next, a cluster of messy pasted Decorate/markers all over the place, devoid of the original authors of the content. It's pretty obvious when your mod and all of it's DLC glory contains mostly content ripped from other resource websites, without so much as a mention of the creators. It's just popping open Realm and pasting stuff back and forth.
Here are some stuff you should have credited: Hmm, maybe this
Anyways, on to the actual mod. I mean, that's what all this snazzy fancy promotion is for right? This mod did warrant 2 expansions worth of DLC, and fancy addons alongside some genuinely worthless changelogs.
10 seconds in, and there's a typo. 15 seconds, started campaign, and another one. An unskippable cutscene ends the level. Wow, that was worth nothing. I learned that Robert and Steve are friends. That's about it. Robert Harris? Is there some specific reason you chose the name "Harris" of all possibilities?
Second "level" of militia blue. For this huge download, I expected some half-decent maps, not some blockish reminiscent of the 90's. You expect players to play this as their very first Doom mods, even barricading players to set up their controls. Really. Good thing the intense 2050 militia training only lasted 15 seconds - that really preps me for upcoming monster hordes. All 3 marines say the same things - lazy much? I also can't for the life of me skip these fucking slow and useless cutscenes where the camera pops from gray marine to gray marine.
Five minutes of cutscenes. When do I get to play? This retarded objective idea is insanely dumb. Yes yes, get ordered by a private, who sends one guy into the hordes. Finally, I get my gun. Wait, what? It's impossible to die because you regenerate like 15 health per second. The repetitive objectives aren't exactly useful or interesting. "Get through this building" gee, I wonder where else these impassible linedefs could take me.
The next level is an edit of MAP05 from Doom 2, showcasing all of McGee's interesting level designs being mushed up into a linear plow. Why are there stimpacks anyways? You can't die with that absurd regeneration rate. Some random standalone "hellraiser" (think green recoloured chaingunner) perforates you with an instakill overpowred mancubus missile. The floor is instakill, what? Why? There's a section on the floor for getting back up FOR A REASON, but no, you have to instantly gib the player.
Oh sorry, minor correction -> it's not completely linear. There's an optional section where you can fight some overpowered humanoid monsters with a ... modified BFG and recoloured plasmagun. Then a dead end, with no way out except by cheating.
More brilliant objectives. "Go back to the beginning"
Hey, where's all that hunky music I downloaded? The first few maps seem to play the original Doom 2 MIDIs to their fully glory instead of the oversized mp3's. Hmm, one hit kill rocket marine, one hit kill mancubus marine, random SSG guys and rapid fire plasma marines. Inconsistencies everywhere. On that note, you forgot to mark one of the doors with your catchphrase, marine stumping "this door is barred"
adhbiurwotgjhod more cutscenes. fuck. me.
And what's the next map? Can you guess? yep, a modified version of MAP04, with broken black textures everywhere because the author doesn't know how to organize.
Pop open a few doors, and get locked into another fucking cutscene. A quest? Where'd that come from? I thought we were using an objective based system, not quests. Ok, so I do some random favor for the butcher in this deserted techbase MAP04 look-a-like. Ok, I lowered the temperature for the asshole, and there's no indication of what to do next. No "quest complete" or anything other than you doing some fucking asshat a favor.
Hey look at this original mapping skill:
Next map. Finally, no more bullshit cutscenes. But boy, these buildings look familiar. REALLY FAMILIAR. (I just can't quite name it, something from plutonia?)
All the switches have had their actions removed, and doors are gone too. I thought that the little hunt would be more interesting, but when you meant "find 5 skulls" you should have said "find all 5 stacked in the same spot". The replaced buildings have one texture thoughout and aoifjoitgi fuck this stuff is ugly.
You didn't remove the out-of-context MAP07 text blurb.
Next map. [Objective Complete] for what? For watching a cutscene. Fantastic. Where's my achievement?
For the next piece, I can't help but think you ripped it off another author's work. Even if it's original, you've already shamed yourself for this. Unknown polyobj, and red diamond signifying broken decorate code. I quit. Done.
Congratulations, I can't even say that you've attempted to map. You added a few sectors here and there and tried to repackage the original Doom 2 levels as yours. I can't even commend your efforts with all that rubbish cutscenes because you failed at copy/pasting resource wads.
None of the music played, and the "wallpapers" are butt ugly.
Why am I hating on you? Not because you're a new mapper and that I refuse to help (on the contrary, I'd gladly help someone new), but the attitude you've taken towards your own "mod" is more of that like you're already a prodigy amongst us, speaking to 'fans' and putting out 'DLC'. To make matters worse, there's a separate multiplayer mod and EVEN MORE updates of you ripping out maps and calling them your own.
Waste of my time. (But then again, I asked for it, didn't I? :P)