Please stop posting in third person, Fabysk.
Why would someone's first mod warrant a website, facebook page, reddit, wikia and several threads? You admitted that it's his first project, and one that is not so good.
Wow, this got me shocked! It's not because fabysk's mod sucked, but how you treated him on his first published Doom wad.
If by ACS you meant ripping others' works without credits and alternating between print, delay and camera/fade transitions, then the ACS ability might not be all that amazing. Nowhere does the author say anything about this being his first mod. It's hard to discern original material to lifted/edited things from others with the lack of credits.
I thought it was a really great wad for a starter. Fabysk, you did an incredible job in the ACS of the last mission. Very impressive that you had implemented two endings to your wad. Escially the ending where the evil voice was actually Richtoffen. It got me thinking a lot. Good job on your first wad.
Why should I be compelled to finish something that is completely intolerable (to me, can't speak for the others) and lacks the quality to play? I commented using my own experience, but what authority do I have? I'm just another member passing their own opinion. Stop complimenting yourself, please.
And as of you other people, why do you treat him like this. After reading his reddit post, he literally almost quit because of you guys. I feel so bad for Fabysk now. What kind of pricks are you people. Criticizing a wad that you have never completed. [/b]
Please read my response to Chubz.
And for the record, Doomworld wad/mod reviewers just want flawless work. Why didnt you guys go easy on Fabysk. This gets me disappointed of how you assholes treated him.
reference links for anyone interested
edit: 3: http://nr.reddit.com/r/Doom/comment...ye_project_115/
Please, show me this "community", or "people" you speak of.
In other cases, I will only make another Doom wad that the community wants. If people here want me to help them contribute a wad, I will gladly help out since I have an amazing experience in ACS. Second, I will no longer to Doomworld ever again. Posting about my mod there was a HUGE mistake. I regret posting there. Here's a tip for everyone. If you plan to post your wad to get Doomers to play, DO NOT go to Doomworld. They will crush you for one tiny mistake like misspelling a print script. Thats how I felt afterwards.
Again, disclaimer here that I can't speak for others, so this is a personal reaction. I will respond to the audio file that you have made specifically towards me.
My main negative and blunt reaction to this mod was the overblown advertisement. I've no personal grudge against the author
"happy face thing"
The happy face was a joke, and was never anything serious. The me posting on facebook ordeal was a joke, and having tacked it onto the previous section had left a bad connotation - especially coming off the earlier post. There was no genuine animosity for that, and was not intended to be taken literally.
However, as mentioned earlier, none of this was an intended attack on the author, or his ideals in his grand vision. I was disgusted by the overhyping (mind you this is a personal preference) - followed by what was ripping off others' content and pasting from commercialized material. Looking back now, the wording I used - "ego" "loser", was harsh, and unnecessary, but ironically it works now (not at the time of the posts) for Fabysk's need to open a second account.
Even so, I agree with your notion, that I had stepped too far into this, and made inappropriate comments following the first 2. The other stuff I've said is agreeably negative. I do apologize for my actions, but I have no intentions on erasing it to atone.
I don't intend to use any "status" or "past authority" as an excuse to attack someone, and the notion of doing so has never crossed my mind. I've had my share of forum drama from way back when (on the Skulltag forums) from shitty mapping. I admit; I stepped out of line and commented poorly. For that, I apologize, but on the contrary, I am willing to help new mappers (if they want it) - this project did not seem like the type to do so simply because, again, and again, of the overhyping promoting expandable "DLC".
Btw, these threads are not 'standard', and will NOT become 'standard', unless everyone starts creating pages left and right for their mods.
On another note, Essel noted that this new member coincidentally shares the same ip addreess/email as Fabysk themself, prompting me to ask again, why won't he respond to me directly? He wrote up responses on his wikia/reddit page, and reposted it here under another alias to add another member on "his side", so to say.
Link here. This is even more of what I am horrified by: creating an alternate account simply to nominate your own project and defend yourself as 2 people.
Last edited by BloodyAcid on Aug 27 2013 at 06:48