Certainly, but please specify that it's a review of the DMR Beta, and not the finalized product - People may get the wrong impression.
I was going to do a map for it, but I instead decided to write a review for this wad.
Do take this into consideration.
I appreciate the time and effort taken to write up this detailed review. The 5 secret maps weren't reviewed, but that's cool because they're screts, after all.
I think a lot of these maps are trying something "against conventions". Some succeeded and some failed, depending who you ask. I think there are enough old style maps in there for someone who likes a more traditional DM, though. (That's pretty much what my maps are in there for :P ) Although we know some of them haven't aged well, I'd hate to see a review of some of the Dwango maps - A few of them are way out there, but I like having something a little different in the mix.
A prime example is the review of The Grand Void. Others have hailed it as one of the more creative and interesting maps in the set, and so I'm glad to have an opposing viewpoint. [To clarify though, ~4 hours is not 'no effort' ;) ]
That said, I can agree with a lot of the criticisms given. Spelling "Dwango" as a map was about as creative as spelling "Weed" as a map. ;P Some of the large maps are a bit too large, to the point of getting lost. I can imagine these maps being perfect for 10+ players, though. (Not bots!) Those who like brit10 paced deathmatch may not find them to be their cup of tea, or who knows, some may find the calmer pacing good for their play style. Akin to E1 deathmtach, perhaps.
Above all else - A pretty map does not make a good map, necessarily. I'm pretty happy most of the maps here are a good leap away from "over detailed", I personally can't stand color clashing in my maps and usually people call that 'detail'. It's a very strange phenomenon of modern Doom mapping.
Again, thanks for the time taken to write this all up - It's very appreciated! I hope to hear back from more users soon, more feedback is always better.