First Phase

First of all, I love that the author has put love into the map, you can tell by simply the Marine on the ground (it made me laugh)

The map is fine apart from some minor beginner errors, I would recommend making the hallways narrower, having them be so big doesn't really add anything when there is only 1 enemy or none at all.

I liked the map for its simplicity, yes, I would have wished that the rooms like the dining room, where the life potions are, had been more frequent, more than anything because of the amount of enemies and life there are.

Everything is too big and/or empty, some parts are literally useless door transitions without anything in it, monsters are ridiculously placed… What a shame, because we feel like the author could had made better, but stayed on something way bellow its means :/

Well, I'm saying that, but this is a first map after all, so I don't want to be too bad, and leave a 3/5 as Misty did, but this objectively deserve less.

I didn't see anything new, besides some newbish mistakes, which can be fixed with some experience and help. Hallway and flat design, small ceiling sectors for trying to hide additional door texture, lots of empty spaces and way too little monsters to kill. Old good Doom doesn't work that way, I recommend study more good maps and check how they made things. For first time effort I'm leaving 3 stars.