Scythe

Easily my favorite wad. Great detail and traps keep you on your toes. Very difficult on UV. 5/5

the first 3 levels are great then things slow down. I don't like map most all of the levels after 10 at all. 2/5

Nice. 5/5

^Scythe 2 is much better than Scythe 1! But Scythe 1 is okay too!

This megawad is pretty damned fun and I think it fuckin' rocks! I always liked small interesting, well designed maps and this thing oozes with them. Keep up the good work. -Doom_Dude

A series of small but fantastic maps in every aspect. I had a blast playing this and wish Scythe II would come out someday - as Erik Alm is a genius!

Fucking epic. I will never get tired of playing this WAD. 7/5

only thing better than this is requiem.

The best thing since, ummmmmm, sliced bread??!! 5/5 Great work : ) Adz123

heh. Nice wad... :) -Torn

Fast, brutal, and fun. Excellent.

Holy shit. One of the best WADs I've ever played. Kept me going for HOURS. 5/5

This is badass!

Truely an awesome wad. Nearly all maps are small (exceptions are 29, 30, ?19), but they all look & play great. Unless you hate small maps, this wad is an absolute don't miss. On a side note, a very clever trick is used in Map28 (Run From It); I had to read some and take a peak in an editor to see how it's done. Basically, there's a seperate Player1 start in an area which can't be reached, and a crusher takes about 30 seconds to reach (and kill) that player. When that player is killed, so are you.

levels were ugly and boring. gameplay was yawn inducing. not nearly as epic as everyone says.

No doubt the best in the Scythe series. I always en up playing at least 5-6 maps when my initial plan was to play onely one or two. That is evidence of great maps/gameplay :) 5*, well deserved.

I havn't had this much fun since i first fired up doom. The only people who wouldn't like this wad are people who havn't played it, or are in the cracker box.

This .wad is awesome 5/5. Stage 26 is really hard.

First 3rd: average. Second 3rd: Pretty damn good. Third 3rd: Legendary. (3 + 4 +5 )/3 = 4 stars.

Definitely in my top5 of best WADs ever. It has short and powerful maps, with well thought-out layout and seriously one of the greatest atmospheres I've ever encountered in a Doom WAD. Map19 is probably my most favorite map ever, but that's also due to the song which fits perfectly to the theme. Another great aspect is the monster placement. Also the slaughter maps are pretty neat to play, like map26 and map30. The only negative point is map28 as I couldn't finish it withouth cheating...

I really liked the short and difficult levels towards the end. They provided a good challenge while not being tedious to retry if failed. The long difficult ones (29,30) were good too, but nothing unique. (lots of levels like that in AV, HR, and HR2 :P) 5/5 because this wad has some of my favorite levels.

This was the first megawad I had ever tried from the Doomworld top 100 list. Good times! ~vf

Now this is what I call great quality! The mapping was very good and the gameplay was well balanced; the first levels are very easy and the last levels (especially 26, 28 and 30) are very hard. Another thing I like about this megawad is that the levels are short and sweet. The challenge is quite different from Hell Revealed, Alien Vandetta and Deus Vult, but it gets more similar in the last levels, and that is what makes Scythe unique. Download this now! 5/5

Best Megawad.

Best megawad ever made. Not a single level in this map feels unfinished or overdone. The maps are interesting, and the gameplay is top notch. Even in the last few levels, where you're fighting hundreds of monsters at a time, the levels still flow smoothly. If garbage like cutscenes and gimmicky scripting is what you're after, go download Zdoom maps. If you want to be "WOW'ed" by big open spaces with stupid amounts of monsters, go play Deus Vult. If you want to play Doom, download this.