Well, this mapset was enjoyable for me. I know, everyone has different tastes, but this one has nice vanilla tricks and main gameplay made think about some routes to not get killed instantly. In other words, I say it was challenging experience. In texture and detailing case, it could be better, but I won't complain for that.
Generally good episode replacement, but ruined by overuse of lost souls in e3m8. Why do people do this? It's not entertaining, it's not clever - their novelty wore off in about 3 minutes in original Doom. Nothing, but nothing, ruins an otherwise enjoyable game than waves of lost souls ad nauseam. There were 250 monsters as is - and author had to spoil it by overwhelming things with around 200 lost souls. Stop doing this. Just stop. I want a patch that will erase these things from a wad as it loads.
this one is really well done. plenty of variety here, mostly large maps that are expansive but not extremely heavy on the monster count. i imagine this is what Sunder would be if it wasn't a slaughterfest wad. certainly recommended, fuck dem haters.